I just think its redundant. If we have something that kills Cerberus it has to either the bible or the explosives. IF the bible doesnt work we will throw the explosvies. If that doesnt work we can try everything else. If that doesnt work we are fucked anyways.

Even if cerberus only kills 5 people and we all move into a north room. Cerberus will just follow us into that north room and finish the rest of us.

I just dont see the point

Okay I just got a "no" so it's not in columns 7-9. Now I wish I had asked for 10-12. If we want to waste another question by repeating mine but asking for columns 10-12 then feel free.

hmm I dont like these no´s

Red has to be the truth guard though

Happy and Merc wouldnt have both gotten a no if red was the liar. (Since the key cant both be in rows 1-6 and 7-9)

Malarkey @ 17/4/2012 17:59

hmm I dont like these no´s

That's why I kinda wanna ask about the last 3 columns.

Malarkey @ 17/4/2012 15:57

I just think its redundant. If we have something that kills Cerberus it has to either the bible or the explosives. IF the bible doesnt work we will throw the explosvies. If that doesnt work we can try everything else. If that doesnt work we are fucked anyways. Even if cerberus only kills 5 people and we all move into a north room. Cerberus will just follow us into that north room and finish the rest of us. I just dont see the point

I'm going to repeat that I don't care anymore. If you think that's good enough, fine. Ask whatever you feel like asking.

Malarkey @ 17/4/2012 18:00

Red has to be the truth guard though Happy and Merc wouldnt have both gotten a no if red was the liar. (Since the key cant both be in rows 1-6 and 7-9)

Everyone's gotten a no so far.

Yeah just saying that both Happy and Merc asked the red guard. Both got a no

If red was the liar at least one of them would have gotten a yes

Unless either of them is lying, yadda yadda yadda

Anyways Me, rob and korr left

Any suggestions?

They both asked the blue guard.

gah

Well my point stands just swap red and blue :P

Tell me what question to ask now

Ask to clear wikey, since Pete cant? (If Pete ever comes back)

More people need to speak up so we can come to a good conclusion

Malarkey @ 17/4/2012 18:05

gah Well my point stands just swap red and blue :P

Actually they do basically confirm that the blue one is the truth teller. He would have said yes to at least one of them if he was the liar.

If we asked for rows 10-12 and he said no, he couldn't be the liar because he would have had to say yes at least once. If he said yes then he also couldn't be the liar because he would have to have said yes at least twice.