Klaus @ 17/4/2012 16:07

... ok. I asked the guard if it was possible for us to win together... he said NO. Willis didn't answer my question about traps, so, whatever. I don't really have time to find out. ##exit: east somebody toss a shoe if you've got one. I don't have time to wait.

Well that means there's liars in BOTH groups since the other one supposedly cleared us.

Either that or Wikey is a liar/scum and since he wasn't with us when they asked their answer doesn't matter.

So should we use some questions to find him or them who can't win with the rest of us? :)

hmm interesting. Wonder who it is....

Merc you better not be that stupid mole again

Well it could be more then one.

I estimate it would take 4 questions with a binary search to find the liar, but he could be among the people who ask the questions......

Well the only ones in our group who haven't role claimed are:

Bagshot
Paco
ublazob
Wikey
Zelda

And out of that group Paco was cleared by Pete.

People with role claims but no clear by Pete are:

Baby Pete (obviously)
Happy
Raking
Randolph

So I dunno what to do with all that.

Randolph was cleared by Pete. Was the time everyone wanted to lynch him.

Was rob cleared?

Also the other group got we were all "cleared" before Wikey came to our group. So we already had a bad guy before he caame

So its either bad guy(s) + wikey
or bad guy(s)

I hope this isnt some fuck up by Willis because of Raking. Or maybe RAking is simply lying i dunno.

I think Happy is pretty clean. His role doesnt seem like a bad guy role. Seems more like a role Willis wants us to think is a bad guy (like DR last game when she was a good thief)

Oh right I forgot.

Pretty positive rob wasn't cleared though.

I would like to check Wikey for obvious reasons that is cause he can't state his win condition to have it checked. :)

Helios
Korru
Malarkey
Raking
Randolph
Rob

All have yet to ask a question (these are people who will actually hopefully be on to ask, anyway)

So we have 6 more questions.

Paco seems pretty solid too me even if he hasnt role claimed.

A bad guy probably would have told us the red one is the truth one (just like the other group) and we would have continued to believe everyone was good + would be heading in the wrong direction for the key

Theory time:
Rob told us his role would appear out of nowhere some time. Maybe the mist thing triggered his role and he is a bad guy? Farfetched but I just wanted to point it out

Wikey, Zelda, Raking and Rob top my list.

I suggest just throwing Zelda into Cerberus and hope she makes him stay for a phase or 2 giving us some space.

By the way I really hope either Happy or I get a "yes". We've gotten nothing but "no" so far and I don't like it.

Randolph also kinda sacrificed his life. I dont think a bad guy would go ALL IN like that for his whole game on a challenge purely based on luck.

His "prisoner" role also fits the last game vanilla role. I dont think he knew that since he didnt play last time.

##Exit: East

well my role changed, meaning i cant communicate with jeffrey anymore, and he has to be dead for me to win with the sane prisoners.

i wish i could assure you more assertively but you guys can only take it at face value.

also, what would you like me to ask, and to which guard.