Boc @ 22/9/2016 19:20

Moose @ 22/9/2016 19:29 I temporarily forgot that Tim scanned Shadow when I said he could still be gf. Ignore that part of the previous post. It made no sense at all. ##Lynch Henry doesn't the godfather usually scan as town tho?

True.

Shadow @ 22/9/2016 20:34

lately she keeps trying to push an inactive lynch for really no reason and before that she was giving all kinds of ~~~scum tells~~~ like this one for example Moose Shadow i don't like Moose's posts today why not? Because you wanted Brian dead yesterday and I didn't think it was a good idea? Or because I'm happy that mafia was hurt in two ways? sooooo scummy

what's the scumtell? I think explained my thinking on that day.

Also, I'm pushing an inactive today because there's still mafia left. And I gave my thoughts on why I'm not lynching any of the others.

Moose @ 22/9/2016 20:36

Shadow @ 22/9/2016 20:34 lately she keeps trying to push an inactive lynch for really no reason and before that she was giving all kinds of ~~~scum tells~~~ like this one for example Moose Shadow i don't like Moose's posts today why not? Because you wanted Brian dead yesterday and I didn't think it was a good idea? Or because I'm happy that mafia was hurt in two ways? sooooo scummy what's the scumtell? I think explained my thinking on that day. Also, I'm pushing an inactive today because there's still mafia left. And I gave my thoughts on why I'm not lynching any of the others.

"i don't approve of the train yesterday!!!" followed by not actually lynching anyone on it

it's the type of shade throwing that maf does. throw out lil crumbs without actually incriminating urself. youve been doing it all season

Well the Brian train thing was more of thing towards you, Shadow - how you said you didn't like my posts, like you were trying to throw shade on me when you led town Brian's lynch train the previous day for barely a reason. I'm just saying that you can look at every action two or more ways. That's the way this game is, but scum is not what I be.

-dr @ 22/9/2016 19:10

I'm surprised Vernon didn't trigger his tree stump. That's puzzling to me

And lose a town vote? No.

I kind of don't see the need for a mass claim, but it wouldn't hurt if Shadow claims I guess. We have a GF in the game meaning Tim's scan means nothing. Is there anything else that would prove that you're town Shadow? Like scum lynch track record.

Would be a dick move for a GF to go inactive but it happens... So a Henry lynch would be an option.

Reading back, I find it hard to believe that the Godfather is Henry or Dylan. Both are ridiculously inactive, and the kills don't point to the GF not paying attention.

Which means it's between Boc, Shadow and Moose.

##Lynch Boc

I'd be so surprised if the Godfather was Henry or Dylan. The fact that Primate was going out for the kill suggests that the Godfather is at least semi-active and paying attention.

If I was scum and my Godfather was Henry or Dylan, I'd probably be making the night kill decisions on their behalf...and I would almost certainly send them out to do the kill rather than myself.

Further evidence that the Godfather is active.

Yeah that is a good point.

If I was the godfather, on day 1 Nobert probably would have hopped onto my train when the opportunity came up. Instead, he said there must be a lot of scum on my train (turns out there was pretty much none!) and lynched Henry, who he tried to make look bad that same day.

And if I was godfather, I wouldn't have called out Vic's slip up and gotten him lynched. (:

Plus, a lot of the time the godfather can't go out for the kill unless they're the last man standing. It's not necessarily someone active. I'm leaning towards it being Henry tbh. It seems like he had a lot more of the mafia's focus, both for going after and defending, than Dylan.

Perhaps Nobert didn't want to out himself so early, having seen the Wikey vote start to gain traction.

Also, the fact that scum mostly seemed to have sat back and let that train develop suggests it could have been between two scum.

sometimes the gf can't go out for the kill unless they're the last one left.

That's true. I gotta say I find it unlikely we are dealing with that here though

-dr @ 23/9/2016 8:38

That's true. I gotta say I find it unlikely we are dealing with that here though

Why? (:

Because it's rarely seen in FE games!