ITT we debate and discuss what should and shouldn't be for all things mafia.

First on the agenda

1. Cops
2. Pings
3. DS

Banish
Banish
Banish

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 0:24

ITT we debate and discuss what should and shouldn't be for all things mafia. First on the agenda 1. Cops - host's choice 2. Pings - illegal 3. DS

We could post all the roles that are available and then we discuss which roles should be banished and kept/allowed.

If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them.

I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor.

Herm @ 26/6/2019 1:29

If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them. I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor.

I think the host should just do what they want and ignore the haters.

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 8:23

Herm @ 26/6/2019 1:29 If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them. I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor. I think the host should just do what they want and ignore the haters.

This svm

Rodney @ 25/6/2019 20:24

ITT we debate and discuss what should and shouldn't be for all things mafia. First on the agenda 1. Cops 2. Pings 3. DS

Fuck you dude

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 3:23

Herm @ 26/6/2019 1:29 If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them. I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor. I think the host should just do what they want and ignore the haters.

We’re never ACTUALLY going to declare that hosts can no longer use a certain role, that would be stupid

Curtis @ 26/6/2019 6:26

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 3:23 Herm @ 26/6/2019 1:29 If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them. I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor. I think the host should just do what they want and ignore the haters. We’re never ACTUALLY going to declare that hosts can no longer use a certain role, that would be stupid

As stupid as this thread tbh.

Only thing stupid is assuming this thread was to make laws instead of just talking about what we like and what works

You want to debate what the mod is allowed to do. Just think about that for a minute, and then let me know if you still don't think it's not stupid.

Ahoda @ 26/6/2019 8:04

You want to debate what the mod is allowed to do.

No he doesn’t

Cop is fun when you JUST have to worry about a doctor on them. It gives them a little bit less of a reason to immediately claim because they know they won't be safe forever.

But when you throw in all of the additional roles we've created on top of it, it makes it a little OP.

I think murdering Penner should be illegal, but lynches are ok