Thanks again to everyone who played, it was a long game but allowed me to host for the first time which was something idk if I'll do again (im bad at flavour). Huge thanks to Christian for helping run this thing, couldn't have done it without you.

Hall of Fame:

TIB - Hugely impressed with how TIB played this game. His reads were usually on point and had a strong town vibe from early on. Also correctly saving Badger twice (once with his gift from angi, the other with his role) and Hern once really helped town. Awesome job!

Badger - For having a lackluster role compared to others and one that may have been tested if he was ever forced to claim, he scum hunted probably the best or one of the best this game. I saw him as the town leader and he did a fantastic job.

Angi - someone else I was hugely impressed with this game, her reads were on point af and while her gift giving didn't have the best luck (minus TIB's gift), she still played super well this game. A little more confidence in herself and she could be a force in future games.

Vlady - Having his chaos brother die Day 1, he definitely had an uphill battle to try and meet his win condition and a lot of the time his actions didn't go to plan or failed because whoever he used it on would die that night. He had some rough luck with his targets but always attempted to make them look shady and get them lynched. He did a great job at blending into town and got Kiwi lynched successfully. Had he survived the night he died, he had stolen Brian's vote and random.org finally gave him a target he could realistically get lynched, I really think he could have won for him & spin.

Town - Town really ran this game and even if they had a few hiccups in terms of who got lynched on given days, they came out success even with an inactive mafia/questionable SKer. They had some great luck/reads on some scum and were able to get a few of them lynched based on this. Honourable Town Players: Hern, Timmah, Farlig, Miko.

Zach (& Ahoda) - Definitely the mafia MVPs this game. Ahoda lead the team with night actions and Zach picked up the torch once Ahoda was lynched. Zach made a good short term fake claim (not bad for his first mafia experience and no team to help him) that got a town lynched instead of him. Unlucky with the Timmah broadcast, he could have made it deeper in the game. Unlucky with who you guys janitor'd and tracked but the ninja kill on DS was smart! Great work to both of you & TY for at least trying when mafia.

Hall of Lame:

Inactive Town & Mafia- Town had a few inactives but wasn't as bad as the mafia team. It was a bad roll and considered rerolling when I saw who the team was but wanted everything to be settled the first time and not change anything. patrick never made a post on the mafia forum which was disappointing. Nofo didn't try at all. Rose was on vacation, bad timing on that one, & brian wasn't around. Mafia team was v disappointing :(

Merc - You tried hard merc but were really unsuccessful and just wrong on a lot of your reads. The switch to the Maddie train really lands you on this list, it was so bizarre and I don't fully blame you but I felt you were the turning point on that lynch.

DS - I understood from a game standpoint what you were trying to do but like everyone has already said, it was just a snowball effect of bad decision and just kept growing. The fake day cop claim and the back and forth of if you were kidding or not was just a lot. I was sad you picked Spin of all people given Team Chaos was my baby but that's not why you're here. You wanted to draw attention to yourself to get your role activated and you could claim it (typical DS fashion tbh) but I really think had you just waited, you would have activated it eventually and not got the watcher lynched in the process.

Stephen - The no killing was definitely frustrating as you needed to be the last one to survive in order to win and you could have probably done that if you killed each night and your choices were better. You were playing like a vig and it just got you lynched quicker. Instead of trying to take out more confirmed Town people (like Badger/Angi/TIB/Hern) you went with people like patrick, josh, sock, vlady. All weird choices at the time you killed them.

Night Actions

Spoiler

+

Night 1: Mafia Brian sends Zach to Kill DS Zach ninja kills DS (successful) Nofo silences Vlady Rose - nothing patrick roleblocks lamps (does nothing) Ahoda tracks maddie (she doesn't leave) SK: Stephen - no action Chaos Vlady steals Lamps' vote (blocked by Curtis) Town: Angi - gift #2 to Primate (Fails, no Primate to give gift) TIB - heal himself (not attacked) Miko - no action Timmah - broadcast (success) Mittens - watch DS (fails, DS' action activated) Curtis - roleblock vlady (success) Farlig - Lie Detects Ahoda denying being scum (waits until D3 to get results) Maddie - no action im317 - checks Helios (not a lover) Josh - can't kill Helios - no action Primate - Leaves Pawnee Sock - no dead town Hern - scans Brian (sees as Town) Night 2: Mafia Brian sends Rose to kill Curtis Zach - nothing Nofo silences Badger (success) Rose - janitor'd Curtis (success) patrick roleblocks timmah (success) Ahoda tracks sock (he doesn't leave) SK: Stephen - no action Chaos Vlady - redirect lamps to curtis (fails, lamps dead) Town: Angi - gift #3 to Ahoda (success) TIB - heal helios (not attacked) Miko - tracks Merc (Merc doesn't leave) Timmah - broadcast (BLOCKED) Curtis - roleblock Boc (does nothing) Farlig - detects Hern saying he's town with credentials (Ahoda's result came back false) Maddie - no action im317 - checks sock (not a lover) Josh - kills Lamps (success) Helios - no action Primate- Leaves Pawnee Sock - backup Watcher (success) Hern - scan Primate (fail, no primate) Night 3: Mafia Brian sends Rose to kill Farlig Zach - nothing Nofo silences TIB (success) Rose - sent to kill Farlig (success) patrick roleblocks Miko (success) SK: Stephen - kill patrick (success) Chaos Vlady roleblock im317 (success) Town: Angi - gift #1 to TIB (success) TIB - heal miko (not attacked) Miko - watch farlig (BLOCKED) Timmah - broadcast (success) Farlig - detects Maddie is 200% town (Hern results come back false, farlig dead) Maddie - no action im317 - checks TIB (not a lover) Josh - N/A Helios - motivate Angi (success but Angi out of actions) Primate - Leaves Pawnee Sock - watches Badger (no visitors) Hern - scans Helios (sees as Town) Night 4: Mafia Brian sends Rose to kill Badger Zach - nothing Nofo silences Helios (success) Rose - sent to kill Badger (bussed to kill herself) SK: Stephen - kill josh (success) Chaos Vlady redirect im317 to primate (fail, im317 dead) Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal self (not attacked), bus badger & rose (rose kills herself) Miko - no action Timmah - broadcast (success) Maddie - day action day 3 to interview Miko (fails, was lynched) im317 - checks Zach (redirected to primate, fails bcz dead) Josh - kills im317 (success) Helios - no action Primate - no action Sock - watches Timmah (no visitors) Hern - scans Kiwi (sees as Town) Night 5: Mafia Brian sends nofo to kill helios Nofo sent to kill Heios (success) SK: Stephen - kill helios (success) Chaos Vlady roleblock Sock (success) Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal badger (not attacked) Miko - watch badger (see TIB visit) Timmah - no action Helios - motivate Miko Primate - no action Sock - watches badger (blocked) Hern - scans Merc (sees as Town) Night 6: Mafia Brian kills Hern (failed) SK: Stephen - kill sock (success) Chaos Vlady steal Brian's vote (success) Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal Hern (success) Miko - heal badger & miko (not attacked) Timmah - broadcast (success) Primate - no action Sock - watches TIB (dead) Hern - scans Timmah (sees as Town) Night 7: Mafia Brian kills Hern (success) SK: Stephen - no action Chaos Vlady roleblock hern (fail, he dead) Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal self (not attacked) Miko - kill Boc (success) Timmah - broadcast (success) Hern - scans Stephen (dies) Night 8: Mafia Brian kills Badger (fails) SK: Stephen - kill Vlady Chaos Vlady steal Brian's vote (dead) Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal badger (success) Miko - no actions Timmah - broadcast (success) Night 9: SK: Stephen - no action Town: Angi - out of gifts TIB - heal self (not attacked) Miko - no actions Timmah - broadcast (success) THE END.

i was killed by town? damn it. i was right about DS lying day 1, day 2 i was part of a large group that misinterpreted the wording of the role which effectively made the ninja kill also unstoppable. i was not only on the Ahoda train but at a pivotal time and i like to think i really helped get that lynched moved off Merc. and on day 4 i was on Zach not Maddie, and well the info i wanted to test only happened to be right i should still have gotten town cred for that vote.

so why did you kill me Josh?

Josh was terrible. He didn't even try to scum hunt or question his suspects during the day and apparently barely paid attention at all.

What's with all these vigs killing townies? I can't remember a vig who killed scum in the past.... 5, 6 games?

Lamps @ 7/6/2017 14:00

Josh was terrible. He didn't even try to scum hunt or question his suspects during the day and apparently barely paid attention at all. What's with all these vigs killing townies? I can't remember a vig who killed scum in the past.... 5, 6 games?

in fairness some of those kills in recent games took out very suspicious town and moved the game along giving scum less options to deflect lynches onto.

Maybe, but they were still town. And Josh didn't take out semi active question marks like for example zach did in this other recent game imo.

(Not sure if this has been covered) The lynching targets for the chaos team were:
Lamps
im317
Sock
Kiwi
Brian

jamie ♂ @ 7/6/2017 20:32

(Not sure if this has been covered) The lynching targets for the chaos team were: Lamps im317 Sock Kiwi Brian

HOW DARE YOU

Sock @ 7/6/2017 16:34

jamie ♂ @ 7/6/2017 20:32 (Not sure if this has been covered) The lynching targets for the chaos team were: Lamps im317 Sock Kiwi Brian HOW DARE YOU

Now you know why I had my "suspicions" of you. ;)

So DS died because flavor wise the dancers wouldn't notice a ninja to block?
(: (: (: (:

I hate the dancers!

Lamps @ 7/6/2017 11:00

Josh was terrible. He didn't even try to scum hunt or question his suspects during the day and apparently barely paid attention at all. What's with all these vigs killing townies? I can't remember a vig who killed scum in the past.... 5, 6 games?

I took out a couple when I was vig a few games ago

Mercator @ 7/6/2017 14:16

So DS died because flavor wise the dancers wouldn't notice a ninja to block? (: (: (: (:

Gotcha dancers should ESPECIALLY catch ninjas imo

Because the flavor would've been hilarious

If you think you are bad a flavor you should check out the last game i modded at glb :)

thisisbad @ 7/6/2017 19:23

If you think you are bad a flavor you should check out the last game i modded at glb :)

If I host a mafia it will be called Bland Mafia,