Curtis First Place Dick Reputation: 1,170 Group: Admin Posts: 79,236 Joined: Jun 22, 2012
Post #1 : 10th Dec 2015 7:50 PM
Survivor: Cagayan
VIDEO
VS
Survivor: Pearl Islands
VIDEO
---------------------------------
New round means new question to accompany each poll!
Rank your top three and bottom three players from the season (do this for both seasons!)
TOP
1. Favorite player
2.
3.
BOTTOM
1. Least favorite player
2.
3.
Outlast Chemical Plant Reputation: 6 Group: Veteran Posts: 1,467 Joined: Jun 6, 2014
Post #2 : 10th Dec 2015 8:12 PM Damn......just let both of these go on and eliminate EI/Philippines. I can't decide between those two either, but these are better seasons for sure IMO.
naonka : saus:: bill:
Patrick Sole Survivor Reputation: 63 Group: Legend Posts: 7,435 Joined: Jun 25, 2012
Post #3 : 10th Dec 2015 8:34 PM why
Curtis First Place Dick Reputation: 1,170 Group: Admin Posts: 79,236 Joined: Jun 22, 2012
Post #4 : 10th Dec 2015 8:35 PM
Dyl Butt Not Even Visible Reputation: 80 Group: Moderator Posts: 13,554 Joined: Jun 25, 2012
Post #5 : 10th Dec 2015 8:37 PM This is turrible
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
Herm Definitely not a Quran Burner Reputation: 212 Group: Godfather Posts: 29,713 Joined: Feb 20, 2014
Post #6 : 10th Dec 2015 9:19 PM I need to update myself on Cagayan, but clearly Pearl Islands should win this.
Herm Definitely not a Quran Burner Reputation: 212 Group: Godfather Posts: 29,713 Joined: Feb 20, 2014
Post #7 : 10th Dec 2015 9:21 PM Oh no. Brains vs Brawns vs Beauty.
Boc Reputation: 157 Group: Admin Posts: 19,204 Joined: Jun 22, 2012
Post #8 : 10th Dec 2015 10:16 PM Both were gr8, but I went with Pearl Islands. I dunno how much of that is nostalgia talking since I haven't seen it since it aired tho
Dyl Butt Not Even Visible Reputation: 80 Group: Moderator Posts: 13,554 Joined: Jun 25, 2012
Post #9 : 10th Dec 2015 10:20 PM Pearl Islands
1. Rupert (I loved him that season. So great)
2. Sandra
3. Jonny Fairplay
.
..
.
14. Christa
15. Trish
16. Lil
Cagayan
1. Woo
2. Tony
3. Tasha / Jefra
.
..
.
16. Garrett
17. Sarah
18. Spencer (I have since learned to be indifferent in Second chances)
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
JJ Pig Reputation: 164 Group: Godfather Posts: 33,771 Joined: Jun 28, 2012
Post #10 : 10th Dec 2015 11:15 PM
Pearl Islands
1. Sandra
2. Tijuana
3. Michelle
14. Rupert
15. Savage
16. Lil
Cagayan
1. Woo
2. Tony
3. Kass
16. Garrett
17. Sarah
18. Tasha
Curtis First Place Dick Reputation: 1,170 Group: Admin Posts: 79,236 Joined: Jun 22, 2012
Post #11 : 10th Dec 2015 11:34 PM Cagayan>>>
Lamps Sansa Reputation: 104 Group: Overlord Posts: 14,181 Joined: Oct 1, 2013
Post #12 : 11th Dec 2015 1:13 PM I liked both!
Favorites in Cagayan definitely Kass, then Tony, then Spencer.
Pearl def Burton, then Darrah, then Sandra.
Igor Minotaur Reputation: 147 Group: Deceased Posts: 6,270 Joined: Aug 8, 2014
Post #13 : 11th Dec 2015 1:16 PM Darrah is the shit
Winner of 11 Courses of Thanksgiving
Outlast Chemical Plant Reputation: 6 Group: Veteran Posts: 1,467 Joined: Jun 6, 2014
Post #14 : 12th Dec 2015 4:45 PM Voted Cagayan, liked the cast just a little bit more.
Cagayan Top
1. Tony
2. Spencer
3. Kass
Bottom (This cast is pretty perfect imo)
1. Trish
2. Morgan
3. Jeremiah
PI Top
1. Sandra
2. Fairplay
3. Burton
Bottom
1. Lill
2. Savage
3. Christa
naonka : saus:: bill:
jks HONK HONK Reputation: 61 Group: Elite Posts: 2,568 Joined: Jul 24, 2013
Post #15 : 13th Dec 2015 11:53 PM 1. Kass
2. Tony
3. Trish
16. David? Garrett? IDK they made episode one so good but i love this cast
17. Woo
18. Lindsey
5 Users Viewing (5 Guests)