Where would you rank Cagayan on your list of favorites?

Maybe it's because it's still so fresh in my mind, but I might put it at #1. The cast was so good and Probst was right about mostly everyone coming to play. Great editing, classic characters, the worst tribe of all time, a F2 and a great end game, and probably my favorite TC of all time

I'd say it's either my favorite or tied with Amazon or Vanuatu

eh, it was good but i'd need to wait a few months because I can fairly rank it.

It could probably crack top 5, personally. MAYBE top 3. Lots of good early seasons that I have loved exponentially more after the rewatch (Marquesas, Africa, Amazon).

This is one of my favorite seasons ever. This is a cast that the show needed for a very long time. Every single person on the show had a character, a purpose and a motive. They all had decent amounts of screen time and the editing kept me guessing on who would actually win. And for the first time in a very long time, my pre-game favorite ends up winning.

Hard to beat out some of the nostalgia of my younger years, but I think this show is Top 5 for me, maybe even higher. Like KC said, this is the cast the show has been looking for and needed. Hopefully it's rejuvenated casting and production to look harder for newbies and to not fall back on a returnee twist to fill in slots and draw viewers.

This is defenitley up there! Marquesas is still my number #1 though. But I don't think any season can beat that one. I have to say Cagayan is in a close #3 right behind Tocantins.

I think Amazon, Heroes vs Villains, and Chris' season were better. This is probably around top 5 though

No love for One World?













JK

Top 5easy

1. Tocantins - Coach. The best Survivor bromance to date. Tyson is the best when he's not even trying to win. Coach again.
2. Vanuatu - Ice Queen almost beats all men forever. Only a redneck in a red tanktop can save them. Eliza is shocked all season.
3. Pearl Islands - So many good storylines including Fairplay. Sandra wins a cool mil.
4. HvV - Sandra is the best player of all time: A case study.
5. Cagayan - Psycho T Vlachos is king of the jungle. Spencer "Charlie Brown" Bledsoe. Would be #1 if Brice and Jeremiah/LJ had switched in the boot order.

I'd rank this probably number 1
Fvf and hvv top 3. It's hard for me to rank hvv cuz I was spoiled for it. It's also hard to rank seasons with returning players vs fresh faces
Cagayan twist and 3 tribe format was a breath of fresh air. It's a kick in the gut going back to blood vsvwater.

Atleast it's newbies though. Just the fact that more names are going to be added to the survivor family makes me so happy. And also new people are always very interesting to watch, becasue you grow to love um. And I am very anxious to see if this BvW works better with newbies. I for one am pretty excited for it! :-D

I've really enjoyed most seasons of Survivor actually. From seasons 21 and onwards, I feel it was definitely better than Nicaragua, South Pacific and Philippines.

Patrick @ 24/5/2014 3:01

No love for One World?

I loved One World.

One World wasn't all to great. It wasn't the worst, but it was def not the best. It was very predictable near the end. But it had female domination. <3 Thats a plus side.

And I think the most underrated season is Thailand. That's still one of my favorites. Is def in my top 10.

thrillhouse @ 24/5/2014 10:40

1. Tocantins - Coach. The best Survivor bromance to date. Tyson is the best when he's not even trying to win. Coach again. 2. Vanuatu - Ice Queen almost beats all men forever. Only a redneck in a red tanktop can save them. Eliza is shocked all season. 3. Pearl Islands - So many good storylines including Fairplay. Sandra wins a cool mil. 4. HvV - Sandra is the best player of all time: A case study. 5. Cagayan - Psycho T Vlachos is king of the jungle. Spencer "Charlie Brown" Bledsoe. Would be #1 if Brice and Jeremiah/LJ had switched in the boot order.

Take out Tochantine and HvV and add Gabon and BvW at the bottom and I think thats mine

Miko @ 24/5/2014 17:15

One World wasn't all to great. It wasn't the worst, but it was def not the best. It was very predictable near the end. But it had female domination. <3 Thats a plus side.

That's why I loved it so much.