| |
Kiwi
Detective Bollig
  | | Reputation: 38 | | Group: | Veteran | | Posts: | 1,876 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #1: 3rd Jan 2014 6:41 AM | |
How do we rank all the winners!
I haven't seen all seasons and put a note by them. I have based their ranking on what I have heard/youtube clips etc!
Top Tier
1) Parvati
2) Boston Rob
3) Brian
4) Todd H
5) Kim S
6) Hatch
7) Yul
8) JT
9) Tom
10) Earl
11) Jenna M
12) Ethan Z
13) Sandra
14) Chris D (Haven't seen this season)
15) Aras
16) Sophie
17) Cochran
18) Tyson
19) Dennis
20) Tina
21) Bob
22) Fabio
23) Danni (Haven't seen this season)
24) Natalie
25) Vee (Haven't seen this season)
26) Amber
| | |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
 | | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #2: 3rd Jan 2014 6:53 AM | |
1 Kim (I guess, so boring though)
2 J.T. (They were literally throwing themselves on top of eachother so he could win. I don't even like J.T. much)
3 Todd
4 Tom
5 Denise
6 Rob
7 Chris
8 Hatch
9 Parvati (Her HvV game was better I think)
10 Tina
11 Natalie
12 Yul (Over powered idol, meh)
13 Aras
14 Sophie
15 Cochran
16 Tyson
17 Sandra
18 Jenna
19 Bob
20 Fabio
21 Danni
22 Amber
Did not rank: Earl, Brian, Vee, Ethan | |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
| | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #3: 3rd Jan 2014 6:57 AM | |
Also that list isn't really accurate in that I think a lot of people below Boston Rob are better players than him, but in terms of the SEASONS, his gameplay in the one he won is what I ranked
Post Edited by Shadow @ 3rd Jan 2014 6:58 AM | |
| | | |
Kiwi
Detective Bollig
| | Reputation: 38 | | Group: | Veteran | | Posts: | 1,876 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #4: 3rd Jan 2014 7:03 AM | |
Ohhh ok. I based Parvati's off HvV as well. As I feel her Cook Island gameplay can be separated from FvF and HvV. I haven't seen BRob first season but feel he should have won twice and HvV was unlucky for him. I think JT was shown up in HvV. Season he won was great.
Basically I viewed it as if they were to play again, what level of gameplay would I expect them to bring. | | |
| | | |
Kiwi
Detective Bollig
| | Reputation: 38 | | Group: | Veteran | | Posts: | 1,876 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #5: 3rd Jan 2014 7:04 AM | |
If you based BRob off only his season he won why is he 5 spaces lower than Kim? Those two had such similar wins. | | |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
| | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #6: 3rd Jan 2014 7:04 AM | |
I think Parvati is a better player than some above her on the list too (3 seasons placing 1st 2nd and 6th), but I was ranking off the seasons they won specifically. | |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
| | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #7: 3rd Jan 2014 7:07 AM | |
|
| If you based BRob off only his season he won why is he 5 spaces lower than Kim? Those two had such similar wins. |
ur right, I ranked him subconsciously with the knowledge that it was his 4th time playing. I do think that has some impact but ya
Like with Parv she made a big risk going to F3 with Cirie in Micro - it wasn't as well thought out. But in HvV I saw her much more intelligent in her decision making.
So I guess I did consider multiple seasons..but if I was ranking Parv's HvV game i'd put her much higher. I am confusing myself | |
| | | |
Shadow
Mr. Cat
| | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,742 | | Joined: | Sep 16, 2013 |
| Post #8: 3rd Jan 2014 7:09 AM | |
Although with Rob's Redemption game, apparently his only way of winning was with Phillip/Natalie. The Jury didn't like him that much..so I think that is the difference with him and Kim. The Jury was her friends, despite burning them. They somehow mostly all still loved her. | |
| | | |
Kiwi
Detective Bollig
| | Reputation: 38 | | Group: | Veteran | | Posts: | 1,876 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #9: 3rd Jan 2014 7:11 AM | |
Oh really? Thats interesting with Rob... Hopefully Kim returns again soon, really wanna see her play with more competition. | | |
| | | |
Patrick
Sole Survivor
 | | Reputation: 63 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 7,435 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #10: 3rd Jan 2014 1:22 PM | |
I just started listening to Survivor Historians for Amazon since I did that rewatch. I had a big laugh when they said multiple times that Ranking Winners only started after Amazon so people could shit on Jenna. At the time a lot of people were not happy with her winning. | | |
| | | |
Patrick
Sole Survivor
| | Reputation: 63 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 7,435 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #11: 3rd Jan 2014 1:24 PM | |
|
How do we rank all the winners!
I haven't seen all seasons and put a note by them. I have based their ranking on what I have heard/youtube clips etc!
Top Tier
1) Parvati
2) Boston Rob
3) Brian
4) Todd H
5) Kim S
6) Hatch
7) Yul
8) JT
9) Tom
10) Earl
11) Jenna M
12) Ethan Z
13) Sandra
14) Chris D (Haven't seen this season)
15) Aras
16) Sophie
17) Cochran
18) Tyson
19) Dennis
20) Tina
21) Bob
22) Fabio
23) Danni (Haven't seen this season)
24) Natalie
25) Vee (Haven't seen this season)
26) Amber
|
You better watch Marquesas and Guatemala after Vanuatu! | | |
| | | |
Bryce
The Butcher
| | Reputation: 100 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 8,748 | | Joined: | Jun 26, 2012 |
| Post #12: 3rd Jan 2014 2:08 PM | |
Who the heck is Dennis? | | |
| | | |
Patrick
Sole Survivor
| | Reputation: 63 | | Group: | Legend | | Posts: | 7,435 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #13: 3rd Jan 2014 2:13 PM | |
| | |
| | | |
Dyl
Butt Not Even Visible
 | | Reputation: 80 | | Group: | Moderator | | Posts: | 13,554 | | Joined: | Jun 25, 2012 |
| Post #14: 3rd Jan 2014 4:00 PM | |
This would be tough... Bob would be last. Sandra (PI) would be a fair bit higher than HvV Sandra. Parvati wouldn't be as high, maybe bottom of top 10. Natalie would be 1 (: jk she wouldn't be that high. I'd take way too much time actually building a list which is why I don't want to do it. Kim would be #1 though. Rich, Earl, Rob and idk the fifth would round out the top 5. | "So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
|
| | | |
Justin
Shrink
 | | Reputation: -28 | | Group: | Regular | | Posts: | 711 | | Joined: | Dec 8, 2012 |
| Post #15: 22nd Mar 2014 10:35 PM | |
~Had Control~
1. Todd
2. Kim
3. Richard
4. Tina
5. Brian
6. Tom
7. JT
8. Parvati
9. Earl
10. Sophie
11. Cochran
~Weaved and/or Bobbed~
12. Denise
13. Danni
14. Vecepia
15. Chris
16. Sandra PI
17. Jenna
~Dormant Approach~
18. Sandra HvV
19. Natalie
20. Fabio
21. Aras
22. Bob
23. Ethan
~Unranked~
Yul- tyler perry idol
BRob- handed to him on silver platter | | |
| | | |
| 5 Users Viewing (5 Guests) |
|
|
