Gabon:
Winner: 5/10
Entertainment: 9/10
Cast Overall: 8/10
Gameplay: 7/10

South Pacific:
Winner: 5/10
Entertainment: 7/10
Cast Overall: 5/10
Gameplay: 5/10

Gabon>>SP

Both winners were meh. Gabon is one of the funniest seasons IMO, and SP is one that's surprisingly pretty funny. But for me, Gabon blows it out of the water with its cast (one of the best ever) and the gameplay, which wasn't even that great comparing it to other seasons, but SP and the seasons around it (RI/OW) almost killed the show with how bad the gameplay was outside of a couple of people. I could get why people like SP, but it's down way low on my list when you put everything together.