Listened to this one about 7-8 times already. Which probably means I like it. Some songs tend to get stuck in my head, but I can't tell which ones they are. Maybe the songs are a bit too similar or don't stand out enough?

That's probably my biggest issue. Each time I put it on, I intend to listen to all the songs closely, but after the first song I simply lose my attention until At The Door or Not the Same Anymore (my two favorites probably).

Kinda really want to judge each song though, so I will give it another attempt later. Don't mind it at all.

Need more opinions / votes :P

Ok listened another time yesterday and again lost focus after the first song :/

Gonna listen again now and rate each song.

1. The Adults Are Talking 8/10 - I really really like this song. It doesn't go anywhere, but I don't mind. Just a really fun song.
2. Selfless 5/10 - don't hate it, but I lost attention and it didn't do anything for me.
3. Brooklyn Bridge to Chorus 6/10 - decent intro, boring chorus, boring song.
4. Bad Decisions 5/10 - beginning is OK, but then it's kinda meh... sounds almost like a No Doubt song and I hate No Doubt.
5. Eternal Summer 5/10 - zzzzz boring
6. At the Door 9/10 - yup I really love this song, probably one of their best. Julian's vocals are so good here.
7. Why Are Sundays So Depressing 4/10 - annoying song
8. Not the Same Anymore 9/10 - great song, I can't decide if this or At the Door is my favorite. This is the one that gets stuck in my head constantly. Powerful vocals, kind of old school The Strokes.
9. Ode to the Mets 8/10 - weird song but it is quite OK

Overall not a great album I guess. Too many boring / annoying songs. Some very good songs too. I guess my average grade is a 7 so will give it a 7.

A few more votes? :P