I'm not stupid enough to do that if I were scum with Rose. It was more about Helios being shady to me and Rose not being there to defend herself. If I was scum with her, I would've just stayed on her train when she obviously had the majority.

Why do you still want Jamie lynched Nav?

Helios Garabandia @ 22/11/2018 23:47

Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 23:43 I'm not stupid enough to do that if I were scum with Rose. It was more about Helios being shady to me and Rose not being there to defend herself. If I was scum with her, I would've just stayed on her train when she obviously had the majority. Why is me sticking to my D1 voting policy (as I have done in virtually every game I've played) so much shadier than the other things that was going on D1?

With Jamie's claim, why would you keep your vote there? Rose/Jamie were very close and you stubbornly sticking to your policy lynch made no sense at that point.

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:49

Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:47 Why do you still want Jamie lynched Nav? I don't buy his role. Its not a CC I just don't buy that as a real role and think it's a fake claim (admittedly clever and thought out one but still fake)

Okay. I don't see why. Also, did you decide to prove your role last night?

Spider @ 23/11/2018 1:09

im317 @ 22/11/2018 22:41 so Buffy moved her vote off of Rose late, scum trying to save her? Spider and Herm joined the vote late, scum trying to gain town cred? keep in mind that Wikey(Mike) moved his vote late too (thought that seemed more like a :Wikey: thing then trying to save Rose imo) so until the last hour or so it looked like Rose was going to be the easy lynch. It's more simple than that. I'm town trying to get rid of scum. I don't know Mike, but him saying he would do whatever JJ would do made him seem scummy to me. They could be working together.

Wikey is a strange guy and he was probably drunk and clearly joking. Also, scum wouldn't usually post on the board to their scummates asking them what to do because they have their own board to do that in. Maybe you've seen it this game? :P

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 8:24

I did ask shadow this because it confused me, if someone was lynching like Buffy for example Buffy (1/10) - Some Asshole and then some asshole unlynches buffy Buffy (0/10) - Some Asshole I then can lynch buffy if I wanted to since she has zero votes. Buffy (1/10) - Some Asshole, Jamie This is allowed

I like this example a lot.

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 8:58

I can kinda see Nav going hard to save scum buddy Rose for fun Nav can you see yourself doing that

This is exactly what I was thinking. I'm torn between - no one would do that (because I wouldn't do that) and... if anyone would do that, it would be Nav. :P

Josh @ 23/11/2018 11:57

You're still getting lynched in that scenario, Buffy

mhm, it's the description of ??? that I appreciated

##lynch im317

I still get scum vibes from his narrative posts. It's like he's showing up just to post something, gets it out of the way, then leaves.

Christian @ 23/11/2018 12:40

so I don't believe he's lying about that.

If he's not lying about it, I don't see it as a scum role. That would be so limiting for scum in endgame. Town often gets sucky/limiting roles like that. And I've seen that role before. It's just odd that someone would use that as their fake claim and limit their ability to save themselves by doing so. I suppose it could've been a scum ploy since Rose was the counter train, but it seems like a stretch to me.

Jackie @ 23/11/2018 13:38

super strange to flex that you'll prove your role

:muscles:

I do appreciate the way Nav actively tries to confuse everyone.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 18:44

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 11:12 ##lynch im317 I still get scum vibes from his narrative posts. It's like he's showing up just to post something, gets it out of the way, then leaves. That describes him in every game, ever. Are you scum, buffy?

In this game it's more pronounced and it seems like every post is for show. He does know how to scum hunt. I've seen it.

Thisisbad @ 23/11/2018 18:52

It seems like Buffy was on Helios end of day yesterday but today Im instead. Has Helios moved off the radar? Or Im just an easy target

Why do you consider im317 an "easy target?" Maybe because he's being scummy? Also, I did make note of 317 yesterday as well.

Also, I think Helios seems more town today. I don't think he'd be that stubborn about Jamie if he was scum with Rose, unless Jamie is also scum. I just don't think he is.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:04

Have the roles not been tied to the characters so far? It seems like it to me, but I'm not a flavor expert like vlady.

Yes, obviously, that's why you're not supposed to character claim.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:05

I know my role is.

see above