Ameila - for going along with her father's plan
Gavin - for trying to let an innocent man get his hand cleaved off
Robin - for enabling a druggie
Charles - for lying and being a druggie
Joseph - for letting his wife steal instead of doing it himself

Robin is just a hard-working woman who doesn't want people stealing her bread! Her only crime is taking advantage of a drug addict but she probably lives in trying times!

Christian @ 28/5/2018 20:45

JJ @ 28/5/2018 20:41 Joseph - for letting his wife steal instead of doing it himself you mean instead of abiding by the law? :P I took it as he didn't know she had stolen the bread. Since he seemed so angry that she had kept quiet.

Maybe he didn't know, I'm not sure. I can look the other way if he didn't know. He's still least of the worst, meaning best? lol

Christian @ 28/5/2018 20:48

JJ @ 28/5/2018 20:45 Robin is just a hard-working woman who doesn't want people stealing her bread! Her only crime is taking advantage of a drug addict but she probably lives in trying times! She didn't have proof that Joseph stole the bread, but still got him sent down, by bribing a drug addict with drugs. And where'd she get them drugs anyhow, huh? :P

She went with her heart! How many people are in jail because of faulty witnesses/people who "just know" someone else was guilty? Happens all the time - and they probably didn't have DNA in this story.

Curtis @ 28/5/2018 20:48

He knew she stole it

Oh yeah it's in the story!

Christian @ 28/5/2018 20:50

Curtis @ 28/5/2018 20:48 He knew she stole it Did you just add that part in? Or did I actually miss it?

It's funny what people think they know...

oh

I prefer to think of Robin as a successful business woman.

Christian @ 28/5/2018 20:52

JJ @ 28/5/2018 20:49 Christian @ 28/5/2018 20:48 JJ @ 28/5/2018 20:45 Robin is just a hard-working woman who doesn't want people stealing her bread! Her only crime is taking advantage of a drug addict but she probably lives in trying times! She didn't have proof that Joseph stole the bread, but still got him sent down, by bribing a drug addict with drugs. And where'd she get them drugs anyhow, huh? :P She went with her heart! How many people are in jail because of faulty witnesses/people who "just know" someone else was guilty? Happens all the time - and they probably didn't have DNA in this story. she forced a drug addict to lie though and say he saw Joseph commit the crime, by promising to give him drugs that she either makes herself or sells on the side. lol

Well, I never said she wasn't guilty of something lol

Boc @ 28/5/2018 20:53

1. Robin - chopping off someone's hand for stealing some goddamn bread is a bit much! And he pretty much coerced Charles to falsely confess

I took it as the law/punishment of the times, not Robin's choice.

Wait, did this happen in 2018?

Wow, 2 votes for Robin?

#JusticeForRobin

Christian @ 28/5/2018 21:02

JJ @ 28/5/2018 21:01 Wow, 2 votes for Robin? #JusticeForRobin Does your opinion change at all if Robin was a successful businessman/part-time drug dealer?

No matter what sex/sexual preference Robin possesses, my opinion is the same.

At first I thought this was going to be a brain-teaser, so I read it very carefully lol.. but didn't notice anyone's sex or whether Joseph "knew" Amelia did it, just assumed, lol.

Curtis @ 28/5/2018 21:08

Christian @ 28/5/2018 21:04 it's like an episode of What Would You Do? where halfway through a scenario, they switch one of the actor's genders to see if anyone reacts differently. That's exactly what I did for the Alligator River story. That one had more to do with gender than this one tho

Was that the like the scorpion story?