Dylan @ 23/5/2014 16:54

eh, it was good but i'd need to wait a few months because I can fairly rank it. It could probably crack top 5, personally. MAYBE top 3. Lots of good early seasons that I have loved exponentially more after the rewatch (Marquesas, Africa, Amazon).

I thought Marquesas was worse on my rewatch. Besides C(K)athy, Sean, and I guess Rob, there weren't very memorable people for the most part. Rob wasn't even all that entertaining. And the ending for me was just boring.

Anyways, I would rank Cagayan in top 5 easily but I haven't really thought about it. Tony winning dropped it for me to be honest, but I'm not sure I would have walked away thinking Woo winning would have made it much better. Maybe if one of the stupid idols was actually played correctly it might have made for a much better season. I don't think people like Tony understood the game, but I think he was still a good winner, just not nearly one of the best. Spencer and Tash have to be two of the best players in the season but also ranked among some of the best ever. They just completely understood the game. It was great!

I guess a rough guess would be:

1. Heroes vs Villains
2. Philippines (probably because of who was on it)
3. FvF2 or maybe BvW
4. Cagayan
5. Vanuatu

I like seasons that keep me on my toes and guessing. A Survivor twist doesn't matter as much to me as much as the cast and their game comprehension does.

I guess returnee seasons are fun for me. I'm sick of seeing some of the people, but the people that return you know they will at least know what they are doing. It's fun to watch though I like fresh faces!

But this season everyone did come to play and it was an amazing season overall! Never knew what was going to happen!

The only downfall for CI for me (I almost put it in my top) was the idol. I want to see the looks on people's faces when an idol like that actually takes place. But it probably never will.

weird.

Penner!

They need to bring Nate back though.

Eh he wasn't a good player, but he was fun!