Should an inactive player be replaced?

I vote yes because even with the drawbacks for the player replacing, and the rest of the players in the game, I feel like it's better than having someone in the game who is completely inactive and continually being discussed as a lynch candidate strictly because they are inactive.

spindoctor02 @ 22/8/2017 16:09

Easy fix: just add a rule that if you go inactive for three straight phases (ex. D-N-D) without a legit excuse, you get modkilled. Might get some of the serial slackers to not sign up.

I kind of like that idea

Curtis @ 22/8/2017 19:36

I think a dead townie coming back in to replace someone is the dumbest thing

For an inactive town role? Completely disagree with you here, Curtis.

sexshygooknees usurygnome cryspin @ 25/8/2017 12:10

Curtis @ 23/8/2017 5:04 This dead player replacement argument isn't jiving with GLB'ers lust for graveyards you have no idea. hey mittens, run mount olympus 2 pls

I really should, but need to come up with a good wrinkle so the players who played vol. 1 don't ruin the fun!

Ahoda @ 25/8/2017 12:24

sexshygooknees usurygnome cryspin @ 25/8/2017 13:10 Curtis @ 23/8/2017 5:04 This dead player replacement argument isn't jiving with GLB'ers lust for graveyards you have no idea. hey mittens, run mount olympus 2 pls no, please dont

Fuck you, Ahoda. That was a fun game

vladykins @ 30/8/2017 15:03

Bryce @ 23/8/2017 17:21 The reason having a dead townie replace an inactive is kind of weird is not just because of what Lamps said, but also because if someone died a townie for whatever the reason, they could come back as 3rd party/mafia and I think the thought process for everyone else would be weird. Because they were confirmed town at death, but they could very well be something different. I think it just muddies the waters. I still wouldn't even want replacements. Just modkill them or wait until they get lynched. I've been a replacement in a few games after dying. It does mean I have had to differentiate what I feel about vlady I posting as opposed to vlady II.

Vlady I is a total cock