I've only been Town once, in a game on ProM that wasn't taken seriously so I don't know how I feel about being Town, but I tell myself I would love it because of some things already posted here, namely the freedom of having nothing to hide. I guess my experience in Lab 2 was technically Town, even though it wasn't a Mafia game, and I loved that.

I've been Godfather twice (once here and once on the only other ProM Mafia I played) and lost it for my side both times at the end of the game as the only remaining Mafia. I think I might have even lynched myself both times like a scrub. I think I would like being a non-Godfather Mafia member, but I don't know.

I've been third party twice, and I think I might prefer it. Because you disappoint no one but yourself with a loss. I liked the prospect of being third party Triplet more than when I was Serial Killer.

So based on my performance I seem to function a lot better as Town, but I feel like the excitement of being third party trumps everything else. So 3P.