Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Replacements?
 Poll Question: Should an inactive player be replaced?
Yes, no matter what
 
5 Votes
(24%)
No, no matter what
 
6 Votes
(29%)
Yes, only early in the game
 
10 Votes
(48%)
 
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #1: 22nd Aug 2017 5:09 PM 
Easy fix: just add a rule that if you go inactive for three straight phases (ex. D-N-D) without a legit excuse, you get modkilled.

Might get some of the serial slackers to not sign up.
 
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #2: 22nd Aug 2017 7:22 PM 
As a mod, there are only two types of people I can't stand.

1. Those who sign up and never participate.
2. Those who actively try to get modkilled.

Both of those people are basically giving a great big FU to the mod, for all the time and effort they put into coming up with the game. Those people should be subject to a sort of X-game ban or something.
 
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #3: 22nd Aug 2017 10:00 PM 
Ahoda @ 22/8/2017 20:07
spindoctor02 @ 22/8/2017 19:22
As a mod, there are only two types of people I can't stand.

1. Those who sign up and never participate.
2. Those who actively try to get modkilled.

Both of those people are basically giving a great big FU to the mod, for all the time and effort they put into coming up with the game. Those people should be subject to a sort of X-game ban or something.



I feel like you singled out DS


I was singling out Nofo, tbh
 
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #4: 25th Aug 2017 8:57 AM 
Primate @ 25/8/2017 8:47
Bryce @ 23/8/2017 16:21
The reason having a dead townie replace an inactive is kind of weird is not just because of what Lamps said, but also because if someone died a townie for whatever the reason, they could come back as 3rd party/mafia and I think the thought process for everyone else would be weird. Because they were confirmed town at death, but they could very well be something different. I think it just muddies the waters.

I still wouldn't even want replacements. Just modkill them or wait until they get lynched.

It can be a little confusing at first, but it isn't bad. I've been in a ton of games where it was used, and it really wasn't an issue.


Plus, who wouldn't want to lynch someone like Ahoda or Vern twice in a game?
 
   
3 Users Viewing (3 Guests)
  Mafia  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service