So was vlady silenced yesterday?

THE GREAT DR @ 21/5/2017 15:50

Hello I still didn't catch up yet and it's feeling a little late to start getting caught up, so lets start fresh KIWI Who is scum

Rose my scumdar is not what it use to be and I can no longer give you a full list of scum by Day 3. I can try for tomorrow or do you just want to turn yourself in now and get it over and done with?

I think we should look a bit more at vlady. Merc I get the vibe is town as a bit too forceful if he was mafia but could be wrong. Also wonder about Maddie

How did Lamps lie about his role...?

Angi what's your case for Merc aside from naming days? You don't think he's just a misled townie?

Timmah @ 21/5/2017 18:18

Kiwi @ 21/5/2017 0:09 How did Lamps lie about his role...? He claimed VT. Other thoughts without reading anything today: The spin and mittens lynches are going to be really helpful to look at. On day one I know there were mafia in thatnspin lynch as they got to hide behind DS claim and know that he wasn't mafia. There will have been mafia purposefully avoiding it too because they thought he'd flip town. Yesterday, the mafia knew mittens was not mafia, so they'd not hesitate to jump on the mittens lynch. Again, some may have stayed off knowing he could be town. On that count I'm looking at active players who did not vote mittens.

Good post, agreed. I'll have a look later and post my thoughts

Shittier Ahoda @ 21/5/2017 18:22

I'm going with ##lynch Patrick No post on D2 and only a couple,late D1 posts.

Are you saying this is scummy or are you lynching because he's inactive?

I don't think the Mittens lynch was stupid. Obviously it was wrong but I don't think not lynching Mittens was really an option given the uncertainty that would create in the following days. Definitely assumption based but either way assumptions had to be made as to our DS died

Angi @ 21/5/2017 18:24

Kiwi @ 21/5/2017 0:18 Angi what's your case for Merc aside from naming days? You don't think he's just a misled townie? I made my case Day 1 Both days he was right in both lynches......Day 2 in particular his insistence that Mitrend be scum. He is still trying to make the Day 2 lynchmake sense besides the fact that we now know Mittens was town. And he threw shade on me Day 1 by twisting my words and today just because I refused to be a sheep the first two days

Sorry lost me a bit there.... both days he was right including that miltrend was scum...?

Primate @ 21/5/2017 18:32

The people who tried to say mittens was lying because a town watcher shouldn't have watched ds looked the worst yeterday. I don't remember who that was though.

Yeah there were a few who said DS said Doctor/watcher shouldn't do anything on him so why would Mittens/they. That's definitely poor logic, especially because if he was Day cop they should be but those who made the argument seemed to be base it on his flip which obviously the watcher/doctor couldn't have known that night 1.

Whether that's scummy or just poor logic, who knows. I don't think scum really needed to drive the lynch yesterday in all honesty

Sorry that post is written in very broken English.. Its not me but my phone. I think anyway....

Still if Spins flip gives DS credibility, he's a day cop and his claim that watcher/doctor shouldn't bother with him as he's a dead man walking still doesn't make a lot of sense

^ Yeah I remember that when he said no actions but was roleblocked. Thought I was wrong when everyone said he claimed....