I think nav looks shadier for claiming he was going to love his role last night, which I read as him trying to deflect a little pressure maybe, and then not, than for defending Rose so hard.

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 12:47

I hope Wikey's scum with Rose and accidentally helped get her lynch with an early joke vote

As funny as that would be, that’s kind of how I read her votes. Possible mafia could’ve voted her early as a joke thinking there’s no way she’d actually get D1’d.

My parents are in town for thanksgiving and have been at my house all day. Going to try to catch up, but it looks like im317 is the lynch?

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:00

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 18:30 Claiming sucks but whatever. My role allows me to nominate 2 people. Only one of those 2 people can be lynched on that day. I have to pick these 2 people either at night or within the first 5 hours of a day. I planned on using this role last night and nominating jamie and whoever on Rose's train shifted the tide in her favor. This was when I thought Rose would flip town. Imo pushing for a Rose lynch on D1 is a bad idea and scummy because Rose is so ridiculously easy to spot as scum on subsequent days that it's basically a freebie. But when she flipped town, I didn't have a solid reason to limit the lynch on anyone for any reason. Why are you able to either pick at night or 5 hours into the day? If you die does it still go through? (sorry if you answered this but also feel free to yell at me if you did). I would think with this role you would always pick at the beginning of a day so it's not wasted and because you'd have a better idea of who to choose.

I may be lacking some perspective at this point, but this is a solid question. why would both of these options be in play?

Mads @ 23/11/2018 22:06

Oh Timmah I forgot you were playing.

Ouch, Mads! Ouch!

(Checks player list to make sure I am actually playing)

Found myself agreeing with Porl pretty much every time he posted. town lean there. Getting town JJ vibes too. Getting town vibes for Helios and ahoda too. The end of day 1 has me thinking town on herm and spider.

I don’t have a clue what curtis is about so far. Think I believe jamie for now. Nav is always tough to read and I went back and forth on him a couple times.

I can see the im317 stuff. He posts that narrative overview type stuff in most games, so it’s more the tunneling on his spearhead theory thing. None of that made a lot of sense to me.

Jackie made a classic scum post towards the start of the day. One of those “good job we lynched scum” type of posts. (I think it was Jackie, I’m on phone but I’ll go back and check)

I think that’s about all that stood out to me. @christian, what’s the vote count?

Yeah, it was definitely Jackie in her second post.

##lynch jackie

I could probably be convinced to go with the im317 though. The jamie and nav stuff just seemed like possible distractions, and that Jackie post just stuck with me as i read the day.

Yeah, we have 17 minutes, right?

She’s right about where i went. She just claimed the wrong role though?

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 23:26

PORL @ 23/11/2018 19:34 Y'all meta game way too much.

Dammit I agreed with this when he posted it. But a mafia watcher would not claim watcher. At least I wouldn’t.

##unlynch

Actually, yeah. Why no claim im17?

Uh, what?

##lynch im317

Oh. Posts are moving faster than my ability to post and keep up on my phone.