Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2
Day Five
 
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #1: 9th Feb 2017 8:25 PM 
Remember when I was scum hunting and told everyone mittens was scum and why I thought so? Yeah, that was fun.

(I know I wasn't the only one, but my vote analysis hot streak lives on!)
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #2: 9th Feb 2017 8:26 PM 
Also I've made statements that Buffy can check to prove I'm telling the truth and not a threat.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #3: 9th Feb 2017 8:33 PM 
Dylan @ 9/2/2017 20:28
Timmah @ 9/2/2017 20:26
Also I've made statements that Buffy can check to prove I'm telling the truth and not a threat.


I hope she did not verify your post and chose to use it on someone else. Clearly you are not town, I feel like seeing if someone else is town is more beneficial than seeing if you are kind of a bad guy, or really a bad guy.


Yeah I don't disagree. I said as much yesterday. But a guy needs to try and survive!
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #4: 9th Feb 2017 8:35 PM 
Dylan @ 9/2/2017 20:29
With that being said, I think Mittens flipping helps his claim even more. I am curious if we get rid of all the other mafia/thirdparty, but Chris and Timmah are still in the game, what happens?


I lose unless chris is lynched and I am on the lynch. Pretty plain and simple.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #5: 9th Feb 2017 9:27 PM 
Well that definitely sucks for me
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #6: 9th Feb 2017 9:29 PM 
I recall spin calling me lazy for using vote count analysis, which is a scum argument. But, I agree with Dylan that J$ blocking spin is a plus in the spin town column.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #7: 9th Feb 2017 9:33 PM 
So I have indisputable evidence that chris is mafia gf. Who's with me?
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #8: 9th Feb 2017 9:41 PM 
JJ @ 9/2/2017 21:36
Timmah @ 9/2/2017 21:29
I recall spin calling me lazy for using vote count analysis, which is a scum argument. But, I agree with Dylan that J$ blocking spin is a plus in the spin town column.



I also agree with the theory that JD could've blocked one of his team since he knew whoever gave him the double block could out him and make his mate look better.


My biggest concern with that is that they were already down 2 members, and mittens had a ton of heat. That move would most likely sacrifice J$ depleting their numbers even more. Not saying it's not an option though.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #9: 9th Feb 2017 11:31 PM 
Okay, so after you all lynch me at whatever point, there is actually something that stood out to me about chris. He specifically said that he didn't believe my claim because of HIS role. What would be so hard to believe about my claim that could have to do with his role if he's town? Lyncher gets their target randomized I believe but if it's not randomized, it would likely be a town target. Him saying that makes me think he doesn't believe it because he's actually mafia and didn't think that he could be my target bc of that.

Just a theory, but it definitely registered my attention.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #10: 10th Feb 2017 9:47 AM 
Darren Sanders @ 10/2/2017 7:08
Timmah @ 9/2/2017 18:33
So I have indisputable evidence that chris is mafia gf. Who's with me?


Is it that his only lynch vote on scum all game was on nofo after the darkus kill and he eventually unlynched?


Well, yeah in addition to that odd comment he made after my claim, he hasn't done anything town this game either.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #11: 10th Feb 2017 9:49 AM 
Primate @ 10/2/2017 9:43
Do the people who think Badger s the way to go think J$ was distancing by pushing on him?


There is a theory floating that since J$ had 2 blocks in the same night, he used one on a teammate. Like I said before, I don't think it's likely because that would basically mean they were chalking up J$ to being discovered, before he came out with all the rest of that info/hints.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #12: 10th Feb 2017 10:09 AM 
I still think Helios checks a lot of the boxes for scum this game.
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #13: 10th Feb 2017 10:25 AM 
Primate @ 10/2/2017 10:16
Primate @ 10/2/2017 9:03
Alive (17):

1. farlig- He's busy with Tax season...hard to read
2. Spin- leaning town
3. im317- Made a D4 post about the GF lie detecting as town Makes me think he could be GF?
5. Brian- Leaning town
6. Darren Sanders- Leaning town
7. Curt- Leaning town
11. Merc- I kind of agree with Buffy on him as potential AT
12. Dylan- Leaning town
14. Ahoda- Leaning town
15. Buffy - TOwn
16. Timmah- AT
17. drrrrrr- Potential AT
19. Badger- Not enough of a read for me. Leaning AT, but not by much.
20. Helios- Leaning town
21. Chris- Potential AT
28. Primate- Sexy AF
30. Thisisbad- Has made some odd votes, but may just not be paying attention. Potential AT

My take on those left


WRONG! Timmah is not AT. Timmah is AChris
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #14: 10th Feb 2017 12:44 PM 
So I get Chris just voting me all the time, but ahoda why vote me today? I mean, maybe at the end of the day I am the best lynch, but what good does it do to vote me early? What pressure does that apply? How does that help find actual harmful scum?
 
   
Timmah
User Avatar
The Butcher
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 94
Group:Legend
Posts:8,753
Joined:Jan 13, 2015
Post #15: 10th Feb 2017 1:10 PM 
Chris25 @ 10/2/2017 13:07
So what happens if Timmah is lying and just had to survive to the end or whatever. I wouldn't be surprised if DS kills me tonight for the lulz unless someone is obvi-scum.

At that point Timma


If they kill you, I can't win because I wouldn't have lynched you. So I lose.

If I make it to the end without lynching you, I still lose.
 
   
6 Users Viewing (6 Guests)
  54. Batman Mafia II: Gotham Knights  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service