Man I look so bad based on end of D1

Curtis @ 22/11/2018 20:44

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:43 Man I look so bad based on end of D1 how come

Well I defended Rose hardcore

And I wanted jamie lynched over her (still want him lynched in general)

Can everyone give me their top 2 scum suspects

For funzies

Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:47

Why do you still want Jamie lynched Nav?

I don't buy his role. Its not a CC I just don't buy that as a real role and think it's a fake claim (admittedly clever and thought out one but still fake)

Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:52

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:49 Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:47 Why do you still want Jamie lynched Nav? I don't buy his role. Its not a CC I just don't buy that as a real role and think it's a fake claim (admittedly clever and thought out one but still fake) Okay. I don't see why. Also, did you decide to prove your role last night?

No because it would probably do more harm than good as of right now.

Lamps @ 22/11/2018 23:20

Ah the voting thing I see. Impossible to prove, but doubt he would limit himself like that if he were scum.

Well he WAS under a bit of pressure and needed some kind of claim

On mobile so not quoting

@Cultis, I absolutely would jump to the defense of my scummate Rose the way I did.

@Madz, Pointing out I looked scummy is also something I would do as scum (mostly for the lolz factor)

Re: not proving my role - it's time sensitive and I didn't get enough feedback to use it in a beneficial way. Like I said it can be proven without doubt that it's me and that it's a town role but I can't prove it today.

Re: just role I still don't buy it and part of it is because I'm trying to think of which Xmen character would even fit that role and I can't imagine any. But I'm not AS well versed in the comics as I'd like to be so there's that. It feels like a role that harms town instead of helping them which I thought in a relatively smaller game like this one (what is this like 27 people?) seems out of place.

Jamie's role not just role *

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 5:07

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:45 Curtis @ 22/11/2018 20:44 Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:43 Man I look so bad based on end of D1 how come Well I defended Rose hardcore And I wanted jamie lynched over her (still want him lynched in general) you’re such an ass, you would want me lynched even if i had a mod confirmed town role

Don't flatter yourself kid. I just don't buy the role is all.

Thanks Buffaroo

Ahoda @ 23/11/2018 12:47

Nav asked for everyone’s top 2 scum reads. Pretty sure he has day kill Everyone ignores him

Not a daykill. But CLOSE to one

Claiming sucks but whatever.

My role allows me to nominate 2 people. Only one of those 2 people can be lynched on that day. I have to pick these 2 people either at night or within the first 5 hours of a day.

I planned on using this role last night and nominating jamie and whoever on Rose's train shifted the tide in her favor. This was when I thought Rose would flip town. Imo pushing for a Rose lynch on D1 is a bad idea and scummy because Rose is so ridiculously easy to spot as scum on subsequent days that it's basically a freebie. But when she flipped town, I didn't have a solid reason to limit the lynch on anyone for any reason.

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 15:34

Nominate me and you tonight

Deal

I don't know if I'll be around much in the evening. The deadline is apparently 8.34 PST? Shadow has this terrible habit of not naming a time and just being 24 hours from this post which I never understood why he can't just name a deadline like a normal host. I'm gonna do a quick read through and cast a lynch vote.

So the only real thoughts I have based on D1 is that Rose got lynched with just 5 votes. Meaning her teammates were not around to help start a different train. Or they tried to start a train and it failed. The only other train was jamie and of the 3 people on it I find Kat scummier than Helios. But I think it's possible regardless that at least some of the Mafia team is among the lower posters of D1 and D2.

So I'm gonna

##lynch Shawn

And I think Merc is town for one of his EOD posts on D1.