Day cop would be OK if it had to be publicly posted (##cop sock) Otherwise, it's too OP. Almost no way to weasel out of it.

Town Miller should only be given to Spin

I like the silly confusion causing roles.

Don't like the lawyer thing if it's unlimited.

Hate "no reveal" games.

Lawyer has its risks. Any scum on scum role like lawyer and scum doc put you at risk of 2 for 1 scum catches. Also it is balance for cop

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 16:25

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 16:23 Or when they make the cop corruptible but everyone ignores that anyway Or when people don't ignore it but realize the ability will soon slip away.

I was hating on town here not scum

Primate @ 26/6/2019 16:27

Day cop would be OK if it had to be publicly posted (##cop sock) Otherwise, it's too OP. Almost no way to weasel out of it.

That's kind of a fun idea. I get the dislike of cops and I haven't had them in either all of most of the games I've hosted but they're going to be in games so it's whatever. I do like the one time cop action idea, though.

Janitors and Cops have no place on this earth

I like janitors unless Spin refuses to use them.

I'm actually pro-janitor. One of the biggest challenges for scum is coming up with a claim that won't be CC'd. In role madness like most games here, it is nearly impossible to claim something standard.

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 16:37

I'm actually pro-janitor. One of the biggest challenges for scum is coming up with a claim that won't be CC'd. In role madness like most games here, it is nearly impossible to claim something standard.

Yeah I actually think that's the hardest part of being scum here. Playing in the Mafia Championship games, it's so easy if you're scum because you can just claim vanilla.

My favorite is cult, though. I love cult leader roles with cool twists.

I have major beef with cults. If it's not done right it can ruin a game. There should never be any way cult can recruit as fast as its lynched. I would never include a cult if it didn't have a hard cap and definitely no replacing dead members. Way too OP

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 16:24

I think the only role I would seriously want to ban would be the ability to pick a lynch train and be told how many scum are on it. I don't remember the name or the game but it was so bad.

That was one of the games I ran and Curtis got 4 people lynched when he was the scum. It was pretty funny