If DR doesn't show up and/or claim, then I think that's the direction I will have to go today. Otherwise Badger would be my option #2.

I think it's unlikely Wikey is anti-town with his double voter role.

I believe Angi is town.

I know I am town.

dr-

Day 1:
Voted Free Candy - Was in no risk of getting lynched (2 people with more votes than him even after her vote)

Day 2:
Blatantly protected Lamps - stating that there are all sorts of ways to survive an attack N1. Threw shade at Dadd for pointing out that if Lamps was doctor that his role would have been ruined anyway.

Didn't end up voting anybody.

Day 3:
Voted Mal
Stated that Mal and Vlady were her main suspects.
Stated that she felt uncomfortable voting Herm or Wikey.
Unvoted Mal
Didn't end up voting anybody at day's end.

Day 4:
Spent the beginning of the day defending herself on why she didn't vote at the previous day's end.
Stated that she thought Vlady was a better lynch over Brian , but that Brian was very likely Mafia.

Posted her spreadsheet: http://imgur.com/ZQ1MCSb
Bad: Buffy , Ari , Wikey, Badger, Vlady
Fine: TIB , Ahoda , Curtis , Eben, Nofo , Chris, Timmah , Canuck , Jamie, Redster

Voted Brian to put him ahead with 4 minutes left, then unvoted and voted Vlady to put him ahead for good.

Day 5:
Lynched Brian with her first post of the day.

Didn't provide much else in her other posts.

Day 6:
Didn't post anything.

Day 7:
Lynched Badger.

Stated that she's busy with Sausage Island prep.

Day 8:
Didn't post.

Day 9:
Didn't post.

Day 10:
Fake daykilled Nofo.

Day 11:
Hasn't posted.


Conclusion:
The fact she has ended most days without voting anybody reads as bad to me - not wanting to be responsible for her decisions. I find it EXTREMELY interesting that on her reads spreadsheet every single person who has died as town was on her 'fine' list.. So either she had impeccable reads or she had inside info.. I'm tending to believe the latter.

I'll post a similar recap for Badger, Wikey, and Angi after lunch (hopefully!).

Badger

Day 1:
Lynched JC early on in the day.

Didn't post much else of substance.

Day 2:
Didn't post anything.

Day 3:
Agreed with Redster that folks jumping off Lamps lynch were likely scum, and stated that Herm stuck out the most to him.

Voted Herm

Stated that his role kinda sucks and town wouldn't be losing much if he were to be killed.

Unlynches Herm after he softclaims, and then states that there's a chance Chris ,Wikey, and Herm are all Town based on the vote splits.

Buffy , Canuck , and Jamie start the Dadd lynch. (In that order)

Lynches Dadd while stating that last minute lynch trains can garner some very good info.

States that he would be OK with a dr- lynch if there was more than 1 minute left.

Day 4:
(Only 2 posts this day)
Stated that he'd rather lynch a possible SK and ends up voting Vlady

Day 5:
Addresses that it seems unlikely Brian is in fact town doc.

When asked for his reads he states that dr- is a scum read, but also says that she always seems scummy to him.

He also states that Buffy is a scum read, but also backs off that by saying that he didn't know what to think about her now.

Finally, he states that if Brian is in fact town doc that Ahoda was doing distancing and that he has questions for Herm, but that he doubts Brian will flip that way.

Day 6:
Ari posts a list of suspects: Targets:
TIB - Dont remember him saying much.
Badger - Already explained.
Canuck - Already explained.
Jamie - On the Dadd lynch.
[color=greenRedster - Already explained.

Ari states: "##lynch Badger

He comes off worse than any of my other scum reads."

Badger agrees with Ari that Canuck had seemed scummy, but disagreed about Redster and stated he thought he was town.

After that post Ari posted:

"Not very convincing!

Who are your top 5 scum reads?"

Badger replied:

1. Canuck - Just get a scummy vibe from the way he posts.

2. Mal - Never seen the Priest's role here before and it seems a little covenant that he claimed it when Vladyou had claimed that other Priest role. Kinda looked like a claim that helped protect Brian so he could use his role.

3. Ari - looking back through the first few days I don't really see anything you've bothered to contribute until today, which could be because you are afraid the lynch might land on you if you don't start trying. Also claiming that an inactive members is scum at the beginning.

4. Jamie - Just a hunch. I find that town is a lot less likely to check in about being unable to post whereas scum looks for a bit of an alibi about why they have to miss some day phases.

5. Buffy - The one I feel least confident about, but she claimed way before necessary (usually she holds off doing so) and I know that even when she's scum she's really active.


Followed up with a post about confusing Buffy with someone else about the claim, so to disregard that part.


Badger lynched Canuck

Has a bit of banter with Buffy about his list.

Buffy's posted list on Day 6:
TOWN:

8. Buffy!

9. Angi - I don't see her counter-claiming the Godfather as mafia.

2. Ahoda - Claimed RB, seems believable.

19. Timmah - Claim seems believable.

11. Mal - Claim seems believable.



LEANING MORE TOWN:

15. Nofo - He claimed VT and is usually trolly when he doesn't like his role so I probably buy it. Timmah's info will be helpful with his claim.

13. Eben - Seems believable unless he was protected by mafia doc but the way Redster just backed off him makes me trust him more. On Vlady lynch against Brian.

COULD GO EITHER WAY:

27. Redster - I would lean town because he seems to be soft-claiming something; however, did accuse Eben then back off quickly when he survived an attack. Lynched Vlady over Brian.

10. Wikey - Could be town or scum role. Not contributing/scum-hunting.

26. Redster - Great son but... hasn't really done much. On Dadd lynch late but on Brian lynch against Vlady.

7. Drr - Has barely contributed. Would lean more scum but giving her benefit of the doubt for now due to Redster.

22. Ari - He has been very utr this game until this round. Lynched Brian over Vlady.

LEANING SCUM:

17. Badger - Hanging back a lot. His claim that he doesn't care if he's lynched comes off as town but it could be a trick! Also, he conveniently puts me on his list and then retracts his "evidence." Tongue On Dadd lynch late. Lynched Vlady over Brian.

1. TIB - Hasn't said much, not much of a read. On Vlady lynch over Brian.

16. Chris - He's either town not caring/paying attention or scum hiding behind his usual play style. On Vlady lynch against Brian.

21. Canuck - Not really contributing. idk if he'd just come out against Angi if he was scum - seems like a strange target to me. Jumped on Dadd's lynch right after me, on Brian lynch late but post seemed forced.

Day 7:
My role is Town Hated - I have no abilities except that if the lynch vote is tied between me and another person, I will be the one lynched. Otherwise I might as well be vanilla.

Throws shade on Jamie and Mal

Votes Jamie

Unvotes and votes for Mal, and then back to Jamie.

I got that far and realized something very important I had forgotten about.

DR is all but proven town IMO. Redster tracked Dadd (Cop) to DR's on Night 2, and Dadd didn't mention DR at all the following day (in 25 total posts).

Most Likely Scum
Badger
Wikey
Angi
Rose
Least Likely Scum

Badger is #1 priority for sure.

Dadd's posts make me think he investigated Wikey Night 2 and was trying to hint at it Day 3.. Before being lynched.

And to that point!

Wikey was put ahead as the leading vote getter when Jamie with 34 minutes left in the day and Badger unvoted with 25 minutes left.

After that Buffy was the first to vote for Dadd with 16 minutes left. Then the rest followed suit. A perfect save performed by Buffy.

##Lynch Wikey

YOU SCUM, BRO!

Still talking to myself. Awesome.

Wikey - Dadd (Cop) had a 'gut feeling' that he was scum, and had questioned him the day before.
Badger - Lynch him tomorrow if it's not Wikey (Unlikely IMO)
Angi - JOAT
DR - Investigated by Dadd and he didn't say a peep about it

If Wikey was scum, I can't piece together why he would get rid of Ari last round. He would have had this game in the bag with his double vote and Ari's vote. They could have forced a tie which would have been enough to lynch me (or if you don't believe me, force a no lynch where they can kill again at night and then have a majority vote).

The only reason he'did get rid of Ari is if he was trolling.

##Unlynch

God damn it, good point.

Unless he was doing aggressive distancing in order to steal the win?

It's Badger or Wikey.. If we lynch wrong it's down to 3 tomorrow and Town can still win.. unless it's Wikey with his double vote.

I'll leave mine on Wikey to play the odds.

##Lynch Wikey

I'm so fucking indecisive.

From my point of view it has to be Badger or Wikey (assuming there is only 1 left). Badger can only vote once, so he's less of a threat.

I still want to hear dr's claim if she decides to show up.

Hi Wikey

I don't know how any of you could possibly still think it's me.

I was all over Ari from the get go yesterday.

If I'm his scum buddy, it would have been retarded to push for him, given how close we would be to majority yesterday.

Wikey @ 17/5/2016 14:06

I don't know how any of you could possibly still think it's me. I was all over Ari from the get go yesterday. If I'm his scum buddy, it would have been retarded to push for him, given how close we would be to majority yesterday.

That's exactly what the plan was most likely.

Give you enough town cred to make it through today, and then you alone have the vote majority tomorrow.

Yesterday only four votes were required for majority. Between us me and Ari had three votes.

If you believe that I am scum, then you essentially believe that scum decided to throw away the game at the finish line in favor of throwing each other under the bus (:

Because if there was a mislynch yesterday, with my role in play today would have been a formality. Ari quickly votes someone and I pile on both my votes for a quick majority.