Buffy @ 10/11/2015 22:45

Mafia board was a good read, especially with the mostly European scum.

Wow, I thought Henry had a boner for me, but that was one hell of a raging clue.

And no, I didn't break the rules. I was allowed to lynch or unlynch. As long as I didn't like/dislike any posts, quote anyone, or use emoji's, I was free to lynch/unlych publicly as much as I wanted. I checked with Christian before I posted, which is why I didn't post until mid-day (I was waiting for clarification from him). Every one of my posts was a lynch or unlynch. Did my posting defeat the purpose of being silenced? Sure, but it was all within the rules I was provided.

Additionally, thank you Canuck for the gun. I'd been looking for a way to shoot Henry for a while now. Once I got that gun, there wasn't a doubt in my mind who was the target.

Screw all y'all

Dadd @ 10/11/2015 23:35

Screw all y'all

FU DADD

JC @ 11/11/2015 5:11

Night 3 Chris watches Rose JC investigates Redster (Not Vanilla) im317 kills Chris (poor Mrs. Cooper) Dylan tracks Timmah (doesn't see target visit anyone) Buffy blocks Ari (no Mafia kill) Canuck gives JC BP Vest ---------- So, why didn't I survive the kill attempt N6 if I had a BP Vest?

It was only valid the night after you received it (see Canuck's role).

Congrats town / im / Curtis, well played! Also good job Wikey! Man, I wish I could play like that when scum, never know what to say. You posted so many theories!

Thanks for hosting Christian! You did great! It was a lot of fun helping you and loved seeing it all play out.

Great game Christian, write ups really made the game enjoyable, as well as the set up.

So this should cause some bad feelings, but how was I able to give JC the gun when Buffy blocked me N4.

Also, I was pretty sure JC was town, but was suspected of being scum, that's why I gave him the BP vest N3, as I figured that scum wouldn't target him that night. Then if he could survive to the next day he would be safe that night, so I could give the gun to someone I knew would be alive. I did think about giving the gun to Buffy or Rose/Nobert, but I knew if they were targeted at night it would be wasted.

Also, I was sure that timmah, with his attention to detail, or possibly im317 because he was the vig, would have caught Wikey's slip at the start of day 8 when he told im317 that he would have shot Schrauben too. There's no way at that point that he knew which townie im317 killed unless he killed the other one. I was so frustrated that no one noticed his slip. I'm glad that town still won. I really wasn't sure how Brian died, and had thought that maybe it was the coal I gave him, which is why I gave im317 the coal on the night I died, just in case it was actually delayed poison and he was a SK, then I would kill him. Speaking of poison, shouldn't Wikey's poison been used up on N3, as I thought it was a 1 time thing. Don't mean to pick apart the game, just a couple things I noticed reading through the night actions.

Great job town, that was a nail biter!

In the end on Day 8, I first thought that Curtis had to be scum, then it was Timmah, but the more I thought about it, I realized it had to be Wikey because of a couple of things that got me suspicious prior to Ari's and Redster's lynches that had me convinced he had to be town.

Time to read the scum board. I wonder what scum really thought about all those ties.

Awesome game Captain Charisma!

JC @ 11/11/2015 5:22

Buffy @ 10/11/2015 22:45 Mafia board was a good read, especially with the mostly European scum. Wow, I thought Henry had a boner for me, but that was one hell of a raging clue. And no, I didn't break the rules. I was allowed to lynch or unlynch. As long as I didn't like/dislike any posts, quote anyone, or use emoji's, I was free to lynch/unlych publicly as much as I wanted. I checked with Christian before I posted, which is why I didn't post until mid-day (I was waiting for clarification from him). Every one of my posts was a lynch or unlynch. Did my posting defeat the purpose of being silenced? Sure, but it was all within the rules I was provided.

wow, I thought that dude was at least semi smart and somewehat honest, but he's just a super wet cunt leaving a trail of muddy sand everywehre.

listen, CUNT - you first used double paragraphs a la:
##lynch abc
nothing wrong there
but then you got lazy and just went with 1 paragraph, a la
#lynch xyz

now, this is a minor fuck-up on your behalf but it is a fuck-up, you used the wrong format when clearly you did it right before that. and considering you wanted to be extra smart about it you should have been punished when you pulled it off but made a mistake in the process. simple as that

now have a good day, CUNT

Thanks guys, I haven't played scum in ages, it was very fun! Looking forward to being town again though.

Me letting on that I knew Schrauben was the vig kill at the start of Day 8 does look kinda bad. However, it was pretty obvious that im317 killed him anyway, and I don't think you needed prior knowledge. He was the obvious choice for vig after the events of Day 7, whilst Canuck was almost 100% cleared. I don't blame 317 for shooting him (nor do I blame him for most of his choice of targets)

Still, I shouldn't have let on that I knew he did for certain. I actually expected to be called out on this during Day 9 when I repeated something along these lines, but Curtis never mentioned it.

But the biggest mistake, as Timmah pointed out, was not shooting 317 the final night. I had planned to right up until the end of Day 8. Then I changed my mind because:

Me on scumboard

My reason for going after Timmah is that if im317 is a SK, I want him to win if I can't, which means leaving him alone. He is also unlikely to target Timmah if he is vig.

I let sentiment get in the way! Right up to that point I thought town didn't deserve a win, and was banking on the outside chance 317 was third party. By doing this, I inadvertently made it easier for town to win. Going into that last day with the remaining vanilla knowing 100% that I was scum was a bad idea.

Henry_42 @ 11/11/2015 5:24

JC @ 11/11/2015 5:22 Buffy @ 10/11/2015 22:45 Mafia board was a good read, especially with the mostly European scum. Wow, I thought Henry had a boner for me, but that was one hell of a raging clue. And no, I didn't break the rules. I was allowed to lynch or unlynch. As long as I didn't like/dislike any posts, quote anyone, or use emoji's, I was free to lynch/unlych publicly as much as I wanted. I checked with Christian before I posted, which is why I didn't post until mid-day (I was waiting for clarification from him). Every one of my posts was a lynch or unlynch. Did my posting defeat the purpose of being silenced? Sure, but it was all within the rules I was provided. wow, I thought that dude was at least semi smart and somewehat honest, but he's just a super wet cunt leaving a trail of muddy sand everywehre. listen, CUNT - you first used double paragraphs a la: ##lynch abc nothing wrong there but then you got lazy and just went with 1 paragraph, a la #lynch xyz now, this is a minor fuck-up on your behalf but it is a fuck-up, you used the wrong format when clearly you did it right before that. and considering you wanted to be extra smart about it you should have been punished when you pulled it off but made a mistake in the process. simple as that now have a good day, CUNT

I hope someone kicks you in pills today.

I would have voted Vernon day 1 no matter if I were town or scum, just saying lmfao And OMGUS voting is so not my MO, I'm surprised Buffy got away with all that shit she said lol If I didn't know the scum team I would have thought she was scum just from that day alone lmfao


Thanks for a fun game Christian, was nice to watch and see Queen Bitch make it so far.

Thank you for tying it and saving me earlier Wikey :D