Moose @ 20/12/2014 8:51

Well, Herm, I didn't realize how scummy it was to suggest inactives during the second day. I just thought that would have been the best way to go when we still didn't know much. I also suggested looking at inactives that were active the day before to try to find scum. I thought it was a good idea.

If we're gonna look at Moose for trying to get in actives we should be looking at Ari too

Brainsday @ 20/12/2014 12:04

Moose @ 20/12/2014 8:51 Well, Herm, I didn't realize how scummy it was to suggest inactives during the second day. I just thought that would have been the best way to go when we still didn't know much. I also suggested looking at inactives that were active the day before to try to find scum. I thought it was a good idea. If we're gonna look at Moose for trying to get in actives we should be looking at Ari too

I don't think it's all that scummy to look at inactives on day 2. We didn't have any conclusive information, and why not keep people in the game who are actually playing?

I think today, though, we have enough to go off of for a lynch. I would say the most obvious is *kimmy who clearly stated she made a vote just to get someone out who was trying to lynch her.

Well, I'm about to head out for Atlanta, so I'm just gonna go head and ##lynch *kimmy for the same reason I stated earlier. I'll be checking on my phone, but I probably won't say much the rest of today.

Peace out.

I didn't like the reason *kimmy gave for lynching Moose yesterday. It made sense for her to vote for her, like Lamps suggested, but the reason she gave made it look bad. Can't tell if it's scumminess or being "new". I stiill find Moose and Herm a little suspicious, but I don't think they can both be scum unless they're trying to distance themselves from each other, with Herm suspecting Moose.

Cash, why didn't you just vote for Moose yesterday instead of tying it up? Sorry if you answered this already. Do you not find her scummy at all?

Animal, why was your vote on Matt yesterday when a few people suggested Aries being on his train at the end of Day 1 made him more than likely Town?

I do find Moose more scummy than Kimmy but I have the feeling that scum is hiding in this game.

Ive seen DR in this thread but she hasnt said anything. Not like her. Silenced?

Huge :| at the tie vote.

Still have a lot to catch up on, thoughts soon-ish

Ari @ 20/12/2014 12:06

Ive seen DR in this thread but she hasnt said anything. Not like her. Silenced?

Nope! I was on earlier after just waking up but didn't really have my thoughts collected yet.

Kimmy and Moose are both pretty scummy to me, kimmy a bit more, but I can't decide which one is more suspicious. Kimmy's posts yesterday about how she wasn't even going to bother defending herself anymore, as she pushed the vote further away from herself and onto Moose really came off bad, though. After yesterday ended up giving us nothing, I want to lynch one of them so we can at least know what to do with Day 2's voting patterns, but I'm also not liking the fact that we're boxing in on only two options today.

Is it odd that with both Moose and *kimmy in the hot seat yesterday and continuing into today, that there's not even been a hint of a claim from either? What should we make of that, if anything? This is a genuine question about their behaviour, I'm not fishing.

Christian @ 20/12/2014 12:17

Is it odd that with both Moose and *kimmy in the hot seat yesterday and continuing into today, that there's not even been a hint of a claim from either? What should we make of that, if anything? This is a genuine question about their behaviour, I'm not fishing.

That's part of why kimmy's "I'm not even going to defend myself!" bothered me as much as it did and why I'm having trouble letting go of Moose as a suspect. There's a lot of kicking and screaming and deflecting, but nothing concrete that would clear them.

Well this sucks. It was obvious Craig was town and the annoying thing is he made himself look scummy, so those who attacked him might be town too. We need to go after someone random today..

So many people not saying much is NOT bito.

Herm's exhibits about Moose for his reasons to lynch her seemed all fluff and no stuff, if that makes sense. :P

He presented 3 quotes from Moose and basically said "I find this scummy" with no real explanations. Am I the only one who found that to be a weird post? And this is where I get all twisted up about things, because if I suspect Moose, how can I suspect Herm, and vice versa, unless this is what they want. But I feel like we can learn a lot from lynching Moose. So as of right now, I lean that way.

dr @ 20/12/2014 13:16

Ari @ 20/12/2014 12:06 Ive seen DR in this thread but she hasnt said anything. Not like her. Silenced? Nope! I was on earlier after just waking up but didn't really have my thoughts collected yet. Kimmy and Moose are both pretty scummy to me, kimmy a bit more, but I can't decide which one is more suspicious. Kimmy's posts yesterday about how she wasn't even going to bother defending herself anymore, as she pushed the vote further away from herself and onto Moose really came off bad, though. After yesterday ended up giving us nothing, I want to lynch one of them so we can at least know what to do with Day 2's voting patterns, but I'm also not liking the fact that we're boxing in on only two options today.

This. I feel like with the way the vote was so even we have to lynch one of them today. I agree with what you're saying about Kimmy. Her actions didn't quite match her words. But Herm quoting those posts of Moose's again have me right back to what I was thinking yesterday so I'm leaning toward a Moose lynch today.

Vernon of 2014 @ 20/12/2014 13:46

So many people not saying much is NOT bito.

lol the irony