Nav, did you ever say the name of your role?

Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:35

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:22 Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:21 Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:20 I don't like the Nav voters. There's no reason to lynch him if he can prove his role the next day. proving role =/= proving alignment True, but do you think that would be a scum role? If it's real, I don't. In general, I usually lean more scum towards vote manipulation actions, especially if it's one-shot (which I've assumed this one is, because it's 100% broken if it's a multi-use role). This role in particular is more dangerous, and I'm not so sure how I feel about its alignment. It's much more likely this role will get a Townie killed since we're forced to lynch one of the two selected players, but because it's so likely this will kill a Townie, I have to wonder if it's horribly overpowered to give Mafia such a role? So basically, I have no idea. Hence me not putting a vote here and waiting to see what happens when the role is used.

so you're saying the death of a potential townie is worth the risk if it leads to the eventual death of the scum that used the role if the role lead to that townie's death? I know what I'm trying to ask but not doing a good job of it.

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 19:41

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 22:39 @Buffy, I hadnt really considered using it at night. But this day phase started super late so I could get no discussion going about who to nominate. Also I don't think I named any targets? Saying I would have nominated Cultis and Jamie was a response to being asked why I hadn't used it yet I meant the people you were talking about lynching/have lynched.

So you don't like a Shawn lynch? Interesting

that question to Nav in my last post got leftover by mistake.
I know he answered it. :P

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 22:44

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 19:41 Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 22:39 @Buffy, I hadnt really considered using it at night. But this day phase started super late so I could get no discussion going about who to nominate. Also I don't think I named any targets? Saying I would have nominated Cultis and Jamie was a response to being asked why I hadn't used it yet I meant the people you were talking about lynching/have lynched. So you don't like a Shawn lynch? Interesting

I already told you I thought it was a lazy lynch. I just don't have confidence in your reads at this time.

Ok I gotta go in a second

If I don't vote Nav, I think I'd go Kat or Zersch.

Christian @ 23/11/2018 22:41

Nav, did you ever say the name of your role? Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:35 Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:22 Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:21 Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:20 I don't like the Nav voters. There's no reason to lynch him if he can prove his role the next day. proving role =/= proving alignment True, but do you think that would be a scum role? If it's real, I don't. In general, I usually lean more scum towards vote manipulation actions, especially if it's one-shot (which I've assumed this one is, because it's 100% broken if it's a multi-use role). This role in particular is more dangerous, and I'm not so sure how I feel about its alignment. It's much more likely this role will get a Townie killed since we're forced to lynch one of the two selected players, but because it's so likely this will kill a Townie, I have to wonder if it's horribly overpowered to give Mafia such a role? So basically, I have no idea. Hence me not putting a vote here and waiting to see what happens when the role is used. so you're saying the death of a potential townie is worth the risk if it leads to the eventual death of the scum that used the role if the role lead to that townie's death? I know what I'm trying to ask but not doing a good job of it.

Let's try this: Are you asking if it is worthwhile to sacrifice a Townie if sacrificing said Townie gets scum killed?

I'd vote Zersch

Sorry I’ve been so inactive these first two days I’ve been very busy lately. Hoping to catch up soon

I do get the feeling that a lot of people are maybe skating by.

Shawn @ 23/11/2018 22:50

Sorry I’ve been so inactive these first two days I’ve been very busy lately. Hoping to catch up soon

Confirmed lie

I’d like to hear more from Merc and Mittens!

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:50

I'd vote Zersch

this, but Brian.

Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:49

Christian @ 23/11/2018 22:41 Nav, did you ever say the name of your role? Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:35 Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:22 Helios Garabandia @ 23/11/2018 22:21 Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 22:20 I don't like the Nav voters. There's no reason to lynch him if he can prove his role the next day. proving role =/= proving alignment True, but do you think that would be a scum role? If it's real, I don't. In general, I usually lean more scum towards vote manipulation actions, especially if it's one-shot (which I've assumed this one is, because it's 100% broken if it's a multi-use role). This role in particular is more dangerous, and I'm not so sure how I feel about its alignment. It's much more likely this role will get a Townie killed since we're forced to lynch one of the two selected players, but because it's so likely this will kill a Townie, I have to wonder if it's horribly overpowered to give Mafia such a role? So basically, I have no idea. Hence me not putting a vote here and waiting to see what happens when the role is used. so you're saying the death of a potential townie is worth the risk if it leads to the eventual death of the scum that used the role if the role lead to that townie's death? I know what I'm trying to ask but not doing a good job of it. Let's try this: Are you asking if it is worthwhile to sacrifice a Townie if sacrificing said Townie gets scum killed?

maybe. I know the answer to that is yes lol but wanted to understand that that's what you were saying. You said you leaned towards a role like that being scum and that most likely it'd kill a townie.

If Brian’s family leaves town and he’s still totally ghost, then I think it’s a safe bet he’s scum, but I know for a fact his niece and nephew are in town and he’s busy with family so I’m not as quick to call scum on him for not posting.