For what its worth, I dont think Penner will be able to sponge the cult recruiter role so if we think Primate is more likely mafia lynching him is fine

I looked back at Mittens' posts and its not really intuitive who he may have tracked that night. He mentioned believing Timmah's claim so I would guess he checked someone who voted for Timmah. Primate is definitely a candidate for that. So is Robb.

Penner @ 29/10/2019 10:49

Lamps @ 29/10/2019 10:43 I just think the info on JJ is made up. You didn’t mention her once day 2. Also a sponge and a backup in 1 game is hard to buy. You have no reason to be 100% truthful about your info since that doesn’t help you meet your wincon i guess. My role is 100% sponge, and I have no incentive to lie because my wincon is unattainable with Cody dead.

there presumably is another cult recruit besides you. drawing a lynch to anyone that is not them will help them. there could also have been a cult backup recruiter, thought i admit that is a long shot. plus you have the potential to recruit 1 last time. in fact i would go so far as to say you may be intentionally giving mixed info. handing us real scum Primate to stay alive to recruit 1 more member. then if you flip what you claim there would be serious consideration for lynching Buffy based on your claim, but that part could be a lie to get town lynched and help the now possibly 2 cult left over.

Prince Navneeta @ 29/10/2019 18:17

For what its worth, I dont think Penner will be able to sponge the cult recruiter role so if we think Primate is more likely mafia lynching him is fine

Why do you think this?

Primate @ 29/10/2019 16:57

Only on page 6, but gonna have to catch up this afternoon.

*quickly checks scum board*

Scumbuddy: “Oh damn Primate you’re in so much trouble. Fuck Penner!”

Primate @ 29/10/2019 16:59

WAIT! Did Penner claim some BS info on me?

Primate
Havo
Nav;
Wikey
Buffy?

Prince Navneeta @ 29/10/2019 13:17

For what its worth, I dont think Penner will be able to sponge the cult recruiter role so if we think Primate is more likely mafia lynching him is fine

Oh yeah probably not but who knows.

Prince Navneeta @ 29/10/2019 13:20

I looked back at Mittens' posts and its not really intuitive who he may have tracked that night. He mentioned believing Timmah's claim so I would guess he checked someone who voted for Timmah. Primate is definitely a candidate for that. So is Robb.

If Primate is possible bus driver, all the more reason he should go.

Also. looking back on D1 votes. Robb was 3rd vote on Dadd. He abandoned that vote shortly before deadline but I think the other 2 (me being one) had unlynched already. I think he just stays on Dadd to "look good " if he's mafia. Idk. Just something I noticed.

I’m not a fan of keeping Penner in the game, but maybe it’s better to actually lynch Primafia?

Lamps @ 29/10/2019 13:55

I’m not a fan of keeping Penner in the game, but maybe it’s better to actually lynch Primafia?

Same. We need a double lynch.

Where is the daykiller when we need them?

oh wtf, i didnt realize this was a different account brb

im317 @ 29/10/2019 9:28

Penner @ 29/10/2019 10:49 Lamps @ 29/10/2019 10:43 I just think the info on JJ is made up. You didn’t mention her once day 2. Also a sponge and a backup in 1 game is hard to buy. You have no reason to be 100% truthful about your info since that doesn’t help you meet your wincon i guess. My role is 100% sponge, and I have no incentive to lie because my wincon is unattainable with Cody dead. there presumably is another cult recruit besides you. drawing a lynch to anyone that is not them will help them. there could also have been a cult backup recruiter, thought i admit that is a long shot. plus you have the potential to recruit 1 last time. in fact i would go so far as to say you may be intentionally giving mixed info. handing us real scum Primate to stay alive to recruit 1 more member. then if you flip what you claim there would be serious consideration for lynching Buffy based on your claim, but that part could be a lie to get town lynched and help the now possibly 2 cult left over.

this is the 317 i love to see

##lynch penner

I think legit Townies need to take a deep breath, play some game theory, and think about whether it’s best to lynch someone who’s 100% not a threat to win or 80% chance to make you lose

That 80% is from the town POV, as I recognize not everyone has the certainty I do