I think someone should run a game where everyone is a SK.

DS @ 26/6/2019 5:46

Rodney @ 25/6/2019 20:24 ITT we debate and discuss what should and shouldn't be for all things mafia. First on the agenda 1. Cops 2. Pings 3. DS Fuck you dude

You know, we aren't so different, you and i




(curt, this is how the main villains join forces in FE the musical)

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 10:49

DS @ 26/6/2019 5:46 Rodney @ 25/6/2019 20:24 ITT we debate and discuss what should and shouldn't be for all things mafia. First on the agenda 1. Cops 2. Pings 3. DS Fuck you dude You know, we aren't so different, you and i (curt, this is how the main villains join forces in FE the musical)

You’re not a villain buddy boy

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 8:03

Only thing stupid is assuming this thread was to make laws instead of just talking about what we like and what works

I think we know that...

I thought this was going to be a sort of Chivalric code for mafia players.

Too late, I just wrote it

Buffy @ 26/6/2019 1:23

Herm @ 26/6/2019 1:29 If a lot of people have a disdain for Cop roles we should probably stop using them. I'm used to the three main town roles in Mafia being Killer, Detective and Doctor. I think the host should just do what they want and ignore the haters.

Agreed

Yall are clowns

I'm OK with Cops, but hate daycops.
Am fine with Pinging
DS is fine, too

I do like when the mod complicates cop by throwing in multiples, etc...

I never see the role where they think they're cop, but they actually kill. Love that role. Want more of it.

Or when they make the cop corruptible but everyone ignores that anyway

Would be OK with pinging being illegal if mods prodded or replaced inactives. NOt asking mods to do more work, though.

I think the only role I would seriously want to ban would be the ability to pick a lynch train and be told how many scum are on it. I don't remember the name or the game but it was so bad.

Rodney @ 26/6/2019 16:23

Or when they make the cop corruptible but everyone ignores that anyway

Or when people don't ignore it but realize the ability will soon slip away.