Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:52

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:49 Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 20:47 Why do you still want Jamie lynched Nav? I don't buy his role. Its not a CC I just don't buy that as a real role and think it's a fake claim (admittedly clever and thought out one but still fake) Okay. I don't see why. Also, did you decide to prove your role last night?

No because it would probably do more harm than good as of right now.

im317 @ 22/11/2018 22:41

so Buffy moved her vote off of Rose late, scum trying to save her? Spider and Herm joined the vote late, scum trying to gain town cred? keep in mind that Wikey(Mike) moved his vote late too (thought that seemed more like a :Wikey: thing then trying to save Rose imo) so until the last hour or so it looked like Rose was going to be the easy lynch.

It's more simple than that. I'm town trying to get rid of scum.

I don't know Mike, but him saying he would do whatever JJ would do made him seem scummy to me. They could be working together.

Did anyone try to save rose at end of day or sway vote?

Sebclops @ 22/11/2018 23:48

Can everyone give me their top 2 scum suspects For funzies

1. Zach
2. Zach


Or any of his multis (Maddie and josh)

Also, I experienced my first time getting locked out of a post/thread yesterday. I was typing a response to give my thoughts, but when I tried to post, it said the post was locked.


Anyways, I'll say what I was going to say yesterday. I was going to keep my vote on Rose since she wasn't very active. Glad that worked out. And I was also going to say two people who gave me scum vibes, Helios and Jackie.

Both seemed to come off too strong to me. Like they were trying to hide their scumness. Jackie was adamant that they're town, but it felt like they were trying too hard.

This is only my second game. And my second time playing with Helios. So far each game, Helios tries to accuse me of scum because I make mistakes people shouldn't make. I'm trying my best to catch up. I can't immediately know everything by D1 of my second game ever. I was town first game and I wasn't believed til I died and people saw I was telling the truth. I'm town again.

Spider @ 23/11/2018 1:18

This is only my second game. And my second time playing with Helios. So far each game, Helios tries to accuse me of scum because I make mistakes people shouldn't make. I'm trying my best to catch up. I can't immediately know everything by D1 of my second game ever. I was town first game and I wasn't believed til I died and people saw I was telling the truth. I'm town again.

I haven't accused you so far this game. I pointed out that your vote looked like blind following, which is generally a thing that scum does. I do know you're new to Mafia, so I haven't come at you nearly as forceful as I would have more veteran players for doing these things. I'll save that for a few more games down the road! :)

I was expecting more pages to read, but I guess Thanksgiving is stealing bandwidth.

Was there ever a point when the lynch could have gone either way in the end?

I would assume scum didn't do much lynching near the end.

Oh I read d1 without noticing Jamie’s claim? Or I forgot.

Ah the voting thing I see. Impossible to prove, but doubt he would limit himself like that if he were scum.

Whoever killed Farlig sucks.

Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 23:50

Helios Garabandia @ 22/11/2018 23:47 Buffeminist @ 22/11/2018 23:43 I'm not stupid enough to do that if I were scum with Rose. It was more about Helios being shady to me and Rose not being there to defend herself. If I was scum with her, I would've just stayed on her train when she obviously had the majority. Why is me sticking to my D1 voting policy (as I have done in virtually every game I've played) so much shadier than the other things that was going on D1? With Jamie's claim, why would you keep your vote there? Rose/Jamie were very close and you stubbornly sticking to your policy lynch made no sense at that point.

Jamie claimed in Post #507. By that point, it was 5-3 to Rose, about 5 minutes left in the Day, and the only real action being some shitposting about who should get D1'd, your attempts to get people to vote for me (which Mike did), and Nav coming out STRONG for Rose (which, lol). Also, and more importantly, not 100% sure if I buy a role with a voting restriction that makes you have to be first on a train. Hence me feeling secure in where my vote was.

As for today? I'm not sure yet. Not enough people have posted for me to get any kind of real read...

The entire Rose train including Wikey looks better than the rest imo.

Wait, that's a thing? I didn't understand what Jamie was trying to say D1. I didn't know a role would make you have to be the first in a train. That seems like an odd restriction.

I was surprised at Rose getting votes but it turned out well since she was scum.

I would have unlynched my vote for Jamie since he claimed but I wasn't online (most likely won't be around the deadline time on the weekday due to timezones).

I'll be back later to read over some posts and try to offer some input or something

Lamps @ 22/11/2018 23:20

Ah the voting thing I see. Impossible to prove, but doubt he would limit himself like that if he were scum.

Well he WAS under a bit of pressure and needed some kind of claim