Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 ... 32
Day 5
 
Mittens
User Avatar
The Godfather
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 69
Group:Overlord
Posts:11,449
Joined:Sep 23, 2015
Post #16: 19th Jun 2017 7:18 PM 
Shittier Ahoda @ 19/6/2017 18:14
Mittens @ 19/6/2017 19:09
I think lamps and Angi are masons because I don't see Angi as making that move if they're scum together.

That being said, we could go on forever theorizing on whether or not a recruit on masons would work, or if it would attack Vic just like a recruit on scum..



Think of it like this. If a mason recruits cult they die. It works both ways. I think Lamps is mason at this point and Vic failed his recruitment

I completely agree, but there enough left up for question based on the lack of info in Vic's role flip that there is a layer of questionability.

I still want to see if Miko will ever answer My question from like Day 2

And I would be ok with a Merc lynch at this point
 
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #17: 19th Jun 2017 7:19 PM 
Vic was lynched on Day 4. He claims to have been roleblocked on N1. This means he likely attempted to recruit on N2 and N3.

If you believe he tried to recruit Lamps and failed, then there is at least one more cult member out there right now.

If you believe he faked his attempt on Lamps, it's possible there are at least 2 more cult members out there right now.

Add to that, 5 or 6 likely mafia members, and this is starting to get dire for town.
 
   
Herm
User Avatar
Definitely not a Quran Burner
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Godfather
Posts:29,713
Joined:Feb 20, 2014
Post #18: 19th Jun 2017 7:20 PM 
Ya, Angi sticking up for Lamps really helped out.

I don't think two scum would claim mason unless they were really close getting majority.
 
   
Spin
User Avatar
Milk Bowl
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 119
Group:Godfather
Posts:25,300
Joined:Feb 18, 2015
Post #19: 19th Jun 2017 7:23 PM 
Shout out to Primate, who's now killed the Town Forensic Investigator, the Town Vanilla, and tried to kill the Town Doctor.

No wonder we haven't caught any mafia yet...Primate is doing their job for them.
 
   
Herm
User Avatar
Definitely not a Quran Burner
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Godfather
Posts:29,713
Joined:Feb 20, 2014
Post #20: 19th Jun 2017 7:29 PM 
We sure Primate isn't Serial Killer?
 
   
Grumpy Ass Old Woman
User Avatar
FU DADD
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 137
Group:Godfather
Posts:32,699
Joined:Feb 22, 2014
Post #21: 19th Jun 2017 7:31 PM 
Herminator @ 19/6/2017 19:29
We sure Primate isn't Serial Killer?



Nope but a game with cult and mafia the town would have to have a vig
Curtis @ 25/7/2017 9:44
Great job Ahoda

   
gabagool
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 363
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,418
Joined:Jan 2, 2016
Post #22: 19th Jun 2017 7:31 PM 
In Primate's defense I've had a really hard time getting reads on people this game. Vig is a really difficult role.
"All this from a slice of gabagool?"
   
Herm
User Avatar
Definitely not a Quran Burner
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Godfather
Posts:29,713
Joined:Feb 20, 2014
Post #23: 19th Jun 2017 7:36 PM 
True.

The only iffy one was Badger, Timmah didn't claim until after his survival and Curtis was hard to read this game.
 
   
gabagool
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 363
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,418
Joined:Jan 2, 2016
Post #24: 19th Jun 2017 7:37 PM 
I'm kind of doubting the existence of an SK, though I don't want want to be naive either. Just the trend of only two kills a night when having a vig makes sense makes me skeptical about an SK.
"All this from a slice of gabagool?"
   
Christian
User Avatar
Captain Charisma
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,182
Group:Godfather
Posts:35,995
Joined:Apr 29, 2014
Post #25: 19th Jun 2017 7:42 PM 
I doubt Vic would call out Lamps if he had actually recruited him. Angi backed up Lamps' claim, so they're definitely part of the same group (not cult). But which faction? Lynching him would solve that mystery, but are their other options for today?
 
   
Christian
User Avatar
Captain Charisma
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,182
Group:Godfather
Posts:35,995
Joined:Apr 29, 2014
Post #26: 19th Jun 2017 7:43 PM 
It'd make sense to have a vig over SK.
 
   
Grumpy Ass Old Woman
User Avatar
FU DADD
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 137
Group:Godfather
Posts:32,699
Joined:Feb 22, 2014
Post #27: 19th Jun 2017 7:49 PM 
I'd like to hear from sock

##lynch sock
Curtis @ 25/7/2017 9:44
Great job Ahoda

   
gabagool
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 363
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,418
Joined:Jan 2, 2016
Post #28: 19th Jun 2017 7:55 PM 
Christian @ 19/6/2017 17:42
I doubt Vic would call out Lamps if he had actually recruited him. Angi backed up Lamps' claim, so they're definitely part of the same group (not cult). But which faction? Lynching him would solve that mystery, but are their other options for today?


While I agree, I also think risking lynching a mason is probably not a great idea since it's def helpful to town to have multiple minds working together in private. I'd assume there'd maybe be a third mason? I've only ever seen mason teams of three but I don't really know what's typical...

Anyway, yeah I am still a bit skeptical of Lamps' alignment but Angi outing herself seems like a pretty bold move if they were, in fact, both actually scum and the mason thing was a lie.
"All this from a slice of gabagool?"
   
gabagool
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 363
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,418
Joined:Jan 2, 2016
Post #29: 19th Jun 2017 7:56 PM 
I feel like Captain Obvious tonight. Sorry just thinking out loud... :p
"All this from a slice of gabagool?"
   
Mercator
User Avatar
The Last Snowcrab
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 133
Group:Overlord
Posts:11,515
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #30: 19th Jun 2017 8:06 PM 
Mittens @ 19/6/2017 16:59
So with Vic's flip it says the recruitment would fail if he targeted scum, but didn't mention anything about masons or getting attacked if he targeted scum. Makes me think Lamps is in fact Mason since Angi voucned for him, and Vic was also attacked. Thoughts?

Wut.

If there were masons he couldn't recruit surely his role would say something about unrecruitable roles, not just scum.

If he was telling the truth about failing to recruit, then Lamps must be scum since the mafia kill is missing and he said he was blocked.
And it seemed like Vic was SURE Lamps was scum, so he most probably failed to recruit him.
Winner of Worst Avatar 2018+
   
1 Users Viewing (1 Guests)
  61. Person of Interest Mafia  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service