Buffy looked the worst yesterday based on votals alone.

Not feeling this Nav train. Feels lazy and very conveniently directed. Sticking with my vote where it is for now. I'm also quite content with voting for im317. Another decent example of a scummish post there which I'll dredge up in a second.

if Nav returns...

What would happen if he used his role at night? He named the two people. And one of them died during the night? What would happen the next day? Would his action be canceled? Would the surviving person be the lynched? Would he have to choose two new people??

I’ve had a vibe on josh today that hasn’t felt right with me

all I read was that he hadn't bothered to ask Shadow.

But I'll start looking at other options as well.

im317 @ 23/11/2018 19:52

still waiting on a role name from Jamie. not exactly opposed to his lynch, but i do want to get that last bit of info first.

Example of what I'm talking about. Not "opposed" but not "for".

Throw some lynches about. This middle of the road play always strikes me as really scummy.

Lynch tally

Nav (4/13): Jackie, Curtis, Spider, Christian
Shawn (2/13): Lamps, Nav
Christian (2/13): PORL, TIB
im317 (1/13): Buffy
Kat (1/13): Herm
Lamps (1/13): ???
Primate (1/13): Kat
Ahoda (0/13): Lamps
Curtis (0/13): ???

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 18:32

It's also not very "towny" to volunteer to be one of two people in a lynch if you're town.

That's what I'm getting at. That in no way clears nav, though.

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 19:28

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:24 Curtis @ 23/11/2018 18:20 I wanna lynch Nav but I also wanna tussle with him tomorrow as the two lynch options. I’m conflicted :( Dominating the day with that seems like it would be bad for town. It’s not a very productive role for Town no matter how it plays out really

and yet somehow Nav can't believe Jamie's role for the same reason. But I'm moving on.

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 19:32

It's also not very "towny" to volunteer to be one of two people in a lynch if you're town.

I wonder if I have a motive

We’ll have to revisit down the line

##lynch josh

PORL @ 23/11/2018 19:38

im317 @ 23/11/2018 19:52 still waiting on a role name from Jamie. not exactly opposed to his lynch, but i do want to get that last bit of info first. Example of what I'm talking about. Not "opposed" but not "for". Throw some lynches about. This middle of the road play always strikes me as really scummy.

i have a theory about his role, so depending on the name he gives i will either believe him and consider him town or not believe him and vote to lynch him. i need that last piece of info before i know which way im going to vote.

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 19:41

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 19:32 It's also not very "towny" to volunteer to be one of two people in a lynch if you're town. I wonder if I have a motive We’ll have to revisit down the line

Okay, see you then.

Mads @ 23/11/2018 18:35

Buffy looked the worst yesterday based on votals alone.

Mike starting the lynch, then bailing at the end looked worse to me, but mainly because I doubt Buffy would be that obvious.

Spider probably looks the best of the four.

Herm diving on at the end could be scum trying to get town cred.

Legit okay with a Curtis lynch too for what it's worth (:

It's early days and my reads are probably all over the place, but it's good to toss them out there if it distracts away from the usual business of picking two candidates and choosing who is the better between them. It's good to have other options on the table because it prevents that tunnel vision.