I'm not that thrilled with Nav in this game but idk if he's scum. Yeah, he could've been hardcore defending his teammate and I'll laugh if that is the case, but I don't really think he would've done that AND then said he'd prove his role and not do it. Scum Nav would've thought his claim through more than that.

That claim, though... that is a very creative role.

I do think his vote on Shawn seems pretty lazy and not Nav-like.

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 16:08

I think you’re being stubborn nav and just don’t want to admit that you could possibly be wrong and if/when I do die and I flip town you will just laugh like it’s no big deal

Did you see who I'm lynching? Maybe you want to do that.

I guess I believe the nav role, but doubt the alignment. It seems like a better role for mafia than town.

Jackie’s posts give me scum vibes today.

Shawn vote feels lazy and like a distraction from...something. From what I’m not sure, but maybe a Nav vote or discussion of something else.

I also just caught up but I think I missed Nav’s claim?

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 19:08

I think you’re being stubborn nav and just don’t want to admit that you could possibly be wrong and if/when I do die and I flip town you will just laugh like it’s no big deal

I tend to agree.

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 16:09

I'm not that thrilled with Nav in this game but idk if he's scum. Yeah, he could've been hardcore defending his teammate and I'll laugh if that is the case, but I don't really think he would've done that AND then said he'd prove his role and not do it. Scum Nav would've thought his claim through more than that. That claim, though... that is a very creative role. I do think his vote on Shawn seems pretty lazy and not Nav-like.

It's definitely lazy. My reasoning is that Rose's scum team didn't try to save her (her biggest supporter was me and I know I'm town).

Jamie seems to be freaking out for no reason.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:10

I guess I believe the nav role, but doubt the alignment. It seems like a better role for mafia than town.

I could see it being either.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 16:10

I guess I believe the nav role, but doubt the alignment. It seems like a better role for mafia than town.

A Mafia role that allows them to limit the lynch for a day seems way too OP to me.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 16:12

Jamie seems to be freaking out for no reason.

It's because I tried to get him lynched on D1.

I don't see how Jamie is freaking out...

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 18:30

Claiming sucks but whatever. My role allows me to nominate 2 people. Only one of those 2 people can be lynched on that day. I have to pick these 2 people either at night or within the first 5 hours of a day. I planned on using this role last night and nominating jamie and whoever on Rose's train shifted the tide in her favor. This was when I thought Rose would flip town. Imo pushing for a Rose lynch on D1 is a bad idea and scummy because Rose is so ridiculously easy to spot as scum on subsequent days that it's basically a freebie. But when she flipped town, I didn't have a solid reason to limit the lynch on anyone for any reason.

so having a role like yours, you can't believe that Jamie would have the role that he says he does?

Rose was bulletproof, but it didn't say she would scan as town unless I misread it?

Not sure what to make of that.

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 19:07

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:04 Have the roles not been tied to the characters so far? It seems like it to me, but I'm not a flavor expert like vlady. Yes, obviously, that's why you're not supposed to character claim. Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:05 I know my role is. see above

Also, sorry and nvm. I misread your post. (: