Primate @ 23/11/2018 18:54

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 17:30 Claiming sucks but whatever. My role allows me to nominate 2 people. Only one of those 2 people can be lynched on that day. I have to pick these 2 people either at night or within the first 5 hours of a day. I planned on using this role last night and nominating jamie and whoever on Rose's train shifted the tide in her favor. This was when I thought Rose would flip town. Imo pushing for a Rose lynch on D1 is a bad idea and scummy because Rose is so ridiculously easy to spot as scum on subsequent days that it's basically a freebie. But when she flipped town, I didn't have a solid reason to limit the lynch on anyone for any reason. So it turns tomorrow into a no lynch unless we lynch you or curtis?

What happens if you’re town and so is curtis and tonight they kill one of you? Does the survivor get auto lynched?

Mittens @ 23/11/2018 18:56

Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 17:35 Curtis @ 23/11/2018 15:34 Nominate me and you tonight Deal LOL fucking calling everyone's bluff

It's most definitely not a bluff. I welcome it with open arms

Curtis @ 23/11/2018 17:56

Mittens @ 23/11/2018 18:56 Sebclops @ 23/11/2018 17:35 Curtis @ 23/11/2018 15:34 Nominate me and you tonight Deal LOL fucking calling everyone's bluff It's most definitely not a bluff. I welcome it with open arms

He's calling yours, and you're calling his. I laughed

Ahoda @ 23/11/2018 15:56

What happens if you’re town and so is curtis and tonight they kill one of you? Does the survivor get auto lynched?

I haven't actually used it yet. If I die tonight tomorrow is a normal day with everyone available to be lynched.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 18:44

Buffeminist @ 23/11/2018 11:12 ##lynch im317 I still get scum vibes from his narrative posts. It's like he's showing up just to post something, gets it out of the way, then leaves. That describes him in every game, ever. Are you scum, buffy?

In this game it's more pronounced and it seems like every post is for show. He does know how to scum hunt. I've seen it.

What if nobody votes for either of you tomorrow? Do one of you randomly die, or are we setting up a day of no info and no lynch?

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 15:51

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 15:10 Nav if the only reason you don't believe my role is because you can't match a mutant to it; perhaps stop trying to do that. I can't character claim so theres not much I can do to convince you otherwise. Also when have town roles ONLY helped town? Hated Townie? Vanilla? Miller? Fruit giver that does nothing? Princess? MY ROLE WHERE I HAVE TO BE FIRST ON A LYNCH Those are just off the top of my head; but do these roles help town? Or do some of them benefit scum? If every town role benefited town; mafia would never have a shot at winning. Not everyone can be a cop or doctor or vig etc care to comment on this nav?

Missed this.

There's a difference between roles that do nothing and roles that actively hurt town. My stance on smaller game sizes is that Town would have less roles that hurt us. Like I would be just as suspicious of a Hated Townie claim in this game. I understand throwing in Vanillas and Fruit givers and what not for balance but a role like yours is tough to buy.

Thisisbad @ 23/11/2018 18:52

It seems like Buffy was on Helios end of day yesterday but today Im instead. Has Helios moved off the radar? Or Im just an easy target

Why do you consider im317 an "easy target?" Maybe because he's being scummy? Also, I did make note of 317 yesterday as well.

Also, I think Helios seems more town today. I don't think he'd be that stubborn about Jamie if he was scum with Rose, unless Jamie is also scum. I just don't think he is.

Have the roles not been tied to the characters so far? It seems like it to me, but I'm not a flavor expert like vlady.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 16:01

What if nobody votes for either of you tomorrow? Do one of you randomly die, or are we setting up a day of no info and no lynch?

I don't think one of us would randomly die. If neither of us gets votes I imagine it ends in an NL (I can't imagine this actually happening btw). Haven't really bothered asking Shadow about it but I'll message him all of these questions.

I know my role is.

You also referred to this game of 27 as small... this isn’t small, it’s average if anything. Sure there aren’t 40 people playing but it’s not like this is a game of 15 or whatever ahodas game was and oh look there was a hated townie in that game.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:04

Have the roles not been tied to the characters so far? It seems like it to me, but I'm not a flavor expert like vlady.

Yes, obviously, that's why you're not supposed to character claim.

Primate @ 23/11/2018 19:05

I know my role is.

see above

J-A-M-I-E @ 23/11/2018 16:05

You also referred to this game of 27 as small... this isn’t small, it’s average if anything. Sure there aren’t 40 people playing but it’s not like this is a game of 15 or whatever ahodas game was and oh look there was a hated townie in that game.

I consider 27 small for FE.

And Ahoda's game isn't the best example because Ahoda.

I think you’re being stubborn nav and just don’t want to admit that you could possibly be wrong and if/when I do die and I flip town you will just laugh like it’s no big deal