There is 0 chance he gets like 30 people to sign up and ends the game after day one when Timmah gets Chris lynched.

So really it's back to do you believe his role and is he a threat. I believe him so far, and think there are bigger priorities.

I also agree with Ahoda about lynching Chris.

thisisbad @ 7/2/2017 10:35

There is 0 chance he gets like 30 people to sign up and ends the game after day one when Timmah gets Chris lynched. So really it's back to do you believe his role and is he a threat. I believe him so far, and think there are bigger priorities. I also agree with Ahoda about lynching Chris.

If timmah's role works like spin described it, wouldn't Chris probably be town?

Helios Garabandia @ 7/2/2017 10:05

spindoctor02 @ 7/2/2017 9:53 ASSUMING TIMMAH IS TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT HIS ROLE... If he is 3rd Party Lyncher, the only way he wins is by getting his target lynched, right? This means, that both him and Town can both win, if Chris is lynched at some point in the game. It's not an either/or situation, from my understanding of the role. Here is the epicmafia description of Lyncher: https://epicmafia.com/role/140 *One person in the town irritates him. Selected at random. Mafia cannot be chosen. *Wins if that person is lynched. *Wins if town wins, while receiving less points. ------------ If that is indeed the flavor of his role, Helios, explain again to me how that's "anti-town" and we need to get rid of him right now? I guess I'm used to a different type of Mafia than you guys are. My win condition says that I win when all threats to the Town are eliminate, which I assume is the standard Town wincon used this game. And to me, that means everything that isn't Town has got to go. I can't wrap my head around this whole "Town can jointly win with third party" thing, because by definition, third party is anti-town.

What if Chris is not town? Then how am I a threat to town?

What if we lynch Chris and I win and am removed from the game. The game will not stop, AND TOWN CAN STILL WIN.

It's not rocket science.

For the record, I fully believe that Buffy is taking great joy from getting me lynched, whether she is town or not, which is why I already said that I knew this exact scenario was coming quite soon as soon as she started with the lie detector stuff.

If you guys want to lynch me, then it is what it is. You will see on my flip though that you have wasted the day and I could've been useful and not harmful to town in any way.

I don't like the idea of lynching Chris at all.

Town would (potentially) win, with an asterisk, there's nothing that points towards Chris as scum and there are at least three decent lynches today imo.

Wow. First of all, why are people so easily swayed that Timmah is not lying? What do you think Mafia is going to say when they're caught? He has to claim third party, no other choice.

The reason I chose Timmah is because he did some sketchy things imo which could point to him being mafia:

D1 - Lynches Chris and kinda seemed to buddy up to me, which always makes me suspicious, so I was watching him. Obviously didn't get involved in the Angi vs Vernon thing later which would be smart as scum to just keep a vote on Christ and stay out of.

D2 - Mentions Chris, Angi and Nofo briefly late in the day when he posts a summary of what he's reading - doesn't finish. Doesn't lynch anyone.

D3 - Finishes his D2 notes which seemed a little odd to me. It was almost like, "give me credit in hindsight now for all my suspicions on Angi which I didn't post until after she was lynched." He goes on to briefly mention Chris and I and how one or both could be scum since we're fighting but most of his attention this day goes to Mittens, Ahoda, Spin. He ends up lynching Sock.

His statement of being town that I checked was: D3 post #283 - Also, I'm town and I'm going to scum hunt.

It just struck me that instead of saying "I'm town" he added something subjective into his statement to maybe try to throw it off. That and the fact he's a very smart player who blends in well as mafia, as well as the behavior I posted above, made me check him.

So, yeah, he could absolutely be Third Party Lyncher like he claims or he could be lying scum who doesn't want to get lynched. I am leaning toward the latter and I agree with Helios that even if he is Third Party he has to go. Otherwise, he's always going to be a question mark and it's going to be brought up every day. If he really wants to help us scumhunt, answering the question of his alignment is best for town imo.

farlig @ 7/2/2017 9:37

thisisbad @ 7/2/2017 10:35 There is 0 chance he gets like 30 people to sign up and ends the game after day one when Timmah gets Chris lynched. So really it's back to do you believe his role and is he a threat. I believe him so far, and think there are bigger priorities. I also agree with Ahoda about lynching Chris. If timmah's role works like spin described it, wouldn't Chris probably be town?

I was just saying the Chris part because i think it's funny when he comes on and cusses people out for doubting him.

I've never liked/used lyncher role, have no idea how target is chosen. If random, Chris could be anything. I wouldn't actually lynch him just yet.

Safe lynch today is Timmah cause he's claimed 3rd party.

@Lamps what other targets you suggesting

If Chris is town and Timmah is lying, then we lynched a townie and left Timmah in for another night to wreck havoc.

I don't see a solution to this problem that isn't lynching Timmah. We either leave it alone and believe his third party lyncher and deal with him later or lynch him now.

I do not believe Chris is scum.

Lamps @ 7/2/2017 10:52

I don't like the idea of lynching Chris at all.

Never thought I'd agree with this statement.

thisisbad @ 7/2/2017 17:05

@Lamps what other targets you suggesting

Timmah obv, Johnny, Mittens, like I said before. I'm torn between Johnny and Timmah at this point.

Dylan @ 7/2/2017 11:06

If Chris is town and Timmah is lying, then we lynched a townie and left Timmah in for another night to wreck havoc. I don't see a solution to this problem that isn't lynching Timmah. We either leave it alone and believe his third party lyncher and deal with him later or lynch him now. I do not believe Chris is scum.

Thanks Dyl, i knew I always liked you for a reason.

##lynch timmah

Timmah baby you know I love you but I gotta do it

Do we have a count? Would hate if this day ends early, that'd be a waste of a day - especially if Timmah IS TP.