ahoda @ 7/2/2017 7:21

We could always lynch Chris and get rid of Timmah and Chris in 1 fowl swoop!

I love this idea

Although, leaving a claimed third party alive has never backfired for the town or anything

farlig @ 7/2/2017 8:51

Timmah, no point arguing with Helios. He didn't want to lynch nofo yesterday when nofo claimed town and didn't care that he killed town.

That's because Helios is mafia. You can see it in his inconsistencies, and the fact that he only posts to blend in.

farlig @ 7/2/2017 8:51

Timmah, no point arguing with Helios. He didn't want to lynch nofo yesterday when nofo claimed town and didn't care that he killed town.

One, that was D2.
Two, I'm not arguing this point with you again. Shit Town is still Town.
(and yes, I'm aware he flipped Mafia. at the time we were discussing this, he didn't look like anything more than asshole trollish Town.)

Timmah @ 7/2/2017 9:13

farlig @ 7/2/2017 8:51 Timmah, no point arguing with Helios. He didn't want to lynch nofo yesterday when nofo claimed town and didn't care that he killed town. That's because Helios is mafia. You can see it in his inconsistencies, and the fact that he only posts to blend in.

False.

Try again, though.

ASSUMING TIMMAH IS TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT HIS ROLE...

If he is 3rd Party Lyncher, the only way he wins is by getting his target lynched, right? This means, that both him and Town can both win, if Chris is lynched at some point in the game. It's not an either/or situation, from my understanding of the role.

Here is the epicmafia description of Lyncher: https://epicmafia.com/role/140

*One person in the town irritates him. Selected at random. Mafia cannot be chosen.
*Wins if that person is lynched.
*Wins if town wins, while receiving less points.

------------
If that is indeed the flavor of his role, Helios, explain again to me how that's "anti-town" and we need to get rid of him right now?

With the above stated, I think it's just as likely Timmah is Mafia, and is claiming lyncher to try to live a bit longer. If forced to place odds, I'd say it's 60% 3rd party lyncher, 40% mafia.

spindoctor02 @ 7/2/2017 9:53

ASSUMING TIMMAH IS TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT HIS ROLE... If he is 3rd Party Lyncher, the only way he wins is by getting his target lynched, right? This means, that both him and Town can both win, if Chris is lynched at some point in the game. It's not an either/or situation, from my understanding of the role. Here is the epicmafia description of Lyncher: https://epicmafia.com/role/140 *One person in the town irritates him. Selected at random. Mafia cannot be chosen. *Wins if that person is lynched. *Wins if town wins, while receiving less points. ------------ If that is indeed the flavor of his role, Helios, explain again to me how that's "anti-town" and we need to get rid of him right now?

I guess I'm used to a different type of Mafia than you guys are. My win condition says that I win when all threats to the Town are eliminate, which I assume is the standard Town wincon used this game. And to me, that means everything that isn't Town has got to go. I can't wrap my head around this whole "Town can jointly win with third party" thing, because by definition, third party is anti-town.

eliminated*

fucking spelling wtf

Timmah will die at some point this game, because we're NOT letting third party win. That being said, killing Mafia > killing TP, so I'm always open to other options.

Helios Garabandia @ 7/2/2017 10:05

spindoctor02 @ 7/2/2017 9:53 ASSUMING TIMMAH IS TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT HIS ROLE... If he is 3rd Party Lyncher, the only way he wins is by getting his target lynched, right? This means, that both him and Town can both win, if Chris is lynched at some point in the game. It's not an either/or situation, from my understanding of the role. Here is the epicmafia description of Lyncher: https://epicmafia.com/role/140 *One person in the town irritates him. Selected at random. Mafia cannot be chosen. *Wins if that person is lynched. *Wins if town wins, while receiving less points. ------------ If that is indeed the flavor of his role, Helios, explain again to me how that's "anti-town" and we need to get rid of him right now? I guess I'm used to a different type of Mafia than you guys are. My win condition says that I win when all threats to the Town are eliminate, which I assume is the standard Town wincon used this game. And to me, that means everything that isn't Town has got to go. I can't wrap my head around this whole "Town can jointly win with third party" thing, because by definition, third party is anti-town.

If Timmah is telling the truth it all depends on how Christian wrote the role up. In Epicmafia, the game would end when the target is lynched and I doubt Christian would end the game so Timmah could joint win with anyone at that point. 3rd party survivor type isn't a threat to the town since they can't kill so most mods allow them to joint. SK is 3rd party but they have to solo to win.

Helios Garabandia @ 7/2/2017 10:08

Timmah will die at some point this game, because we're NOT letting third party win. That being said, killing Mafia > killing TP, so I'm always open to other options.

Lynch Chris to get him and Timmah out of the game. ;)

For the record, in epicmafia if the lyncher actually gets his target lynched, the game ends. The second part about winning with the town is if his target is NKed or whatever, the lyncher can still sorta half-win if he's alive when the town wins

ahoda @ 7/2/2017 10:09

Helios Garabandia @ 7/2/2017 10:08 Timmah will die at some point this game, because we're NOT letting third party win. That being said, killing Mafia > killing TP, so I'm always open to other options. Lynch Chris to get him and Timmah out of the game. ;)

Back the fuck off bitch. I'm fucking carrying this game for town so far.

itsbrianyay @ 7/2/2017 9:13

For the record, in epicmafia if the lyncher actually gets his target lynched, the game ends. The second part about winning with the town is if his target is NKed or whatever, the lyncher can still sorta half-win if he's alive when the town wins

Like someone said earlier, I can't see a way in which Christian would end the game if Chris was lynched and Timmah still alive, as I've never seen it played that way here before. I've never officially played at epicmafia, so I was unaware of that part of it. I only steal their role ideas for my games. :)