Kiwi @ 20/5/2017 22:39

Primate @ 21/5/2017 18:32 The people who tried to say mittens was lying because a town watcher shouldn't have watched ds looked the worst yeterday. I don't remember who that was though. Yeah there were a few who said DS said Doctor/watcher shouldn't do anything on him so why would Mittens/they. That's definitely poor logic, especially because if he was Day cop they should be but those who made the argument seemed to be base it on his flip which obviously the watcher/doctor couldn't have known that night 1. Whether that's scummy or just poor logic, who knows. I don't think scum really needed to drive the lynch yesterday in all honesty

I was one of the ones who made this argument, but it wasn't based off of DS' flip, it was just based off of the fact that I thought Spin's flip gave a little more credibility to DS' and would thus maybe make one, specifically the doctor and watcher, take DS' advice of not visiting. That was my poor logic yesterday, but I also didn't feel comfortable lynching Mittens because 1.) I got why a watcher would be inclined to visit DS due to his high visibility D1 and 2.) I believed Mittens when he mentioned his RB flavor. My poor logic was just reasons why I was skeptical of Mittens and I don't think that's entirely unfair.

Still if Spins flip gives DS credibility, he's a day cop and his claim that watcher/doctor shouldn't bother with him as he's a dead man walking still doesn't make a lot of sense

Reads:
Herm is poking around the edges ,and not scumhunting at all. He scum.

TIB, I had him as scummy d1. If there is scum who stayed off the lynch it could be him. I agreed with his logic yesterday and that made him seem more town, but he could still be scum.

Sock, he was one of the aforementioned salesmen.

Merc, same as sock.

Ahoda, he's a Schneider from way back, but seems a little defensive today. His hints earlier make me lean more town, though.

Farlig seems 100% like scum farlig to me, but I can give him the benefit today.

Nofo, not sure wtf he's doing. Looking through yesterday, he may or may not be playing an entirely different game.

Timmah, Not sure if his ds hard on is legit, or a way to actively lay low while still posting enough. I think it's likely the former.

Maddie is using that. "Why would anyone watch ds" thing, but ultimately stayed off the lynch. That doesn't look great to me.
.

Ahoda should say scumsider not Schneider

Primate @ 21/5/2017 0:23

Lamps claiming for no reason was sus. The claim itself was not.

I'm not so mad at what lamps claimed as I am that we have 2 dead town now that both lied in their claims. That shit helps scum, not town, usually

Timmah @ 21/5/2017 0:09

Primate @ 21/5/2017 0:23 Lamps claiming for no reason was sus. The claim itself was not. I'm not so mad at what lamps claimed as I am that we have 2 dead town now that both lied in their claims. That shit helps scum, not town, usually

That makes sense. I'm just saying that lamps couldn't have claimed his actual role without throwing it away. I'm more chapped that he outed any kind of claim without pressure

I don't understand Marc's play honestly. His insistence on a 2 Ned mafia doesn't make sense unless he's original mafia and wants Tom relate confusion. On the other hand his hardcore stances on the rest of everything, and his obvious attention his stances have taken do not scream scum. Quite the conundrum.

That should say second mafia. I'm drunk. Sue me.

Timmah @ 21/5/2017 0:16

I don't understand Marc's play honestly. His insistence on a 2 Ned mafia doesn't make sense unless he's original mafia and wants Tom relate confusion. On the other hand his hardcore stances on the rest of everything, and his obvious attention his stances have taken do not scream scum. Quite the conundrum.

I would definitely like to hear more from him. It seems like he tends to lay lower when scum, but the sales job looks too ott to be 100% kosher. I want to hear more.

I coyld see some of the concerns that people brought up about vlady, but he stays away on weekends for the most part, so it would be a bad move. ching him right before a weekend seems like a long game move by scum to me.

Should say silencing not ching.wtf is ching?

Maddie @ 20/5/2017 21:36

Ok Merc is a little sus i feel like when he's scummy he always references a third party or cult and maybe like second mafia is the other scummy variation he decided to settle on this game.

I also tend to reference third parties when I'm town since, ya know, it's part of the game.

I wonder if you tend to say this when you're mafia, I remember you saying this once before.

I think Vlady is town, but I'm basing that purely on the fact that he seems to have been silenced. He should come by and clear that up lol.

I have a weird feeling about Primate, but I can't get a good read on him. It's not WIFOM btw, although it may look like it since he just mentioned me.

I feel like scum could have voted DS over Spin, not sure what scum would do on D2. Probably not jump on the Mittens lynch?

My cat's all over me rn lol.

Primate @ 21/5/2017 7:07

Ahoda should say scumsider not Schneider

I thought it was a new nickname.

Tiers = Curtis
Schneider = Ahoda

I like where this is going.