Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Lockhart’s Back, Baby!
 
Mirabella Plunkett
User Avatar
Mythmaker
Offline Marker
Reputation: 8
Group:Member
Posts:617
Joined:Feb 9, 2018
Post #1: 16th Mar 2018 6:26:14 AM 
Quote
Did you miss me?


Posted Image


Quote
Let’s start with the fish. Mira, you’re wonderful. I’m shocked that you’re here, and I said I would vote for you at FTC back at F12. Make them come true. My question for you is, you were extremely reliant on items all game. Do you think that needing multiple items weakens your game in any way, shape, or form?


That's a good question for me, it's definitely something I need to address at this final tribal.

First of all, while I had two real items in the game (both idols), I basically threw one away at F8 on a vote I was pretty certain would result in Angelina going home regardless. I was confident enough in my game without items that I felt I had a comfortable path to f6 without it and didn't want the extra threat status that another public idol would give to me. I needed my group of 4 to trust me and dumping the Slytherin idol helped make them comfortable enough to stick with me in the medium term. So I didn't really need that item, although I don't regret putting all the effort I did into getting it since it helped me make my case for why people should work with me to vote out Angelina at F9.

The Gryffindor Idol was linked to me for the first 8 rounds of the season however, and there's no doubt that me having it affected a lot of voting outcomes in the game. But I don't think the way I used it hurts my resume. Anyone could have tried to have that idol, but 15 out of 18 players declined because they didn't want the target that a public idol puts on you (or, in the case of Albus, they presumably forgot the url for the board). I took a risk by grabbing it, and it came with advantages and disadvantages, but it was a tactical decision and the results showed that I demonstrated strategic prowess in my handling of it.

How often do you see someone manage to openly hold a public idol for 8 consecutive rounds in an ORG?

I knew that I wanted to play a pretty bold game and would draw a target sooner or later, so I deliberately went for the public idol with plans to use it to make it as uncomfortable as possible for anyone to target me in a vote. It was a similar strategy to Yul Kwon's decision to make his idol public in Cook Islands, and while the special idol he had was more powerful than mine here, the premise of the gambit is to make others worried that they could go home if they try to rally votes against you. It worked against you when you wasted the idol nullifier on me in the Snape round, it worked against the big alliance that voted for Newt instead of me at merge, and it worked again when Draco got more votes than me in Angelina's boot round because of further idol worries. I used the threat of an idol more than I used actual idols to protect myself, and I could have used my various item bluffing schemes to create a similar threat without actually possessing items if I needed to (as I did at F6/F5).

I don't think having had items or not had items is by itself a positive or a negative factor when it comes to deserving a jury vote, I think it's more important to look at whether a player uses them intelligently to advance their game or not. I wasn't the only person in this game to hold two items (You had an idol and an idol nullifier and I believe Amos had an idol and a cloak, Maxime had an idol and a challenge advantage and Lily had a double vote and a cloak), but I was the only person who was able to effectively use my items to advance myself into a seat at FTC.

And finally, I would like to point out that both Ron and Draco had access to all of the potion ingredients for the Slytherin idol at exactly the same time as me and neither of them even bothered to attempt the recipe to collect the idol. They both had every opportunity I had to get both of the items I held in this game, and the fact that I got the Slytherin idol when they did not doesn't make me luckier than them. It just shows that I was willing to put in the extra effort to complete that strenuous list of potion steps when they were not.





Quote
Now, for all three of you. To me, the game looked BORING after Angelina’s boot. Multiple jurors have said the game was boring after either Angelina left. I want to know, from the three of you: did you think the game got boring after Angelina left? If you do believe it got boring, what did you do to try and make it more interesting?


OMG I was so certain you would ask this question and I love you for it <3

I absolutely felt that this game got boring after Angelina left. Absolutely.

I think it's incredibly clear that there were four players in this game that were determined to liven things up, take risks, take initiative and do their best to entertain the viewers.

You, Snape, Angelina and Me.

All four of us put an incredible amount of time and energy into this game and were willing to accept the risks that come with being high-visibility in order to do some creative and ambitious things that would be remembered. And I have a ton of respect for that type of approach. I wrote a rather flowery eulogy for you specifically in my confessional because I feel like you played with the type of creative boldness that I am constantly striving to achieve. The biggest difference, perhaps, was that you were brave enough to shake things up in plain sight while my craziest antics were often things that couldn't be traced back to me, like the fake instagram account and the fake Ravenclaw Idol. I can't imagine how fun it would have been to watch twelve players desperately confessing random guesses about an instagram account that has nothing to do with the game, but I got a barrage of slack messages from people speculating about it and I was laughing for two days straight.

It was tragic that I didn't get to spend much time on the same side as the other three of you, but I can guarantee you that Mirabella vs. Snape will go down as one of the biggest and most entertaining arcs of the pre-merge and the Mirabella vs. Angelina arc would be right up there for rivalry of the season. Lockhart vs. Lockhart might be the best of all.

Unfortunately, all those arcs resolved themselves by the time F8 arrived, there weren't really many explosive rivalries left and to be perfectly honest I found myself in a powerful but precarious position that would have become a lot more precarious if the status quo got overturned too early. With the huge threat tattoo I was wearing, openly shit disturbing and shaking things up would have gotten me targeted pretty quickly. But that doesn't mean there wasn't things I could do to try and add some spice, and I still tried to be active doing things like:

- As I mentioned, I pretended I got a vote switcher from the Instagram account and I bluffed that I was going to use it at F6, then again at F5. This made a lot of people uncomfortable and the F6 round was by far the most interesting post-Angelina round because for a couple of hours before deadline, Cormac did a great job trying to scramble to protect himself and the vote switcher idea freaked a lot of people out. Pomfrey tried to take him up on the offer and attempted to get the vote on Fred and very briefly even on me. It ended up at the same result as expected, but it was a fairly wild round.

- I spread a couple of rumours of various teams being hatched, most notably trying to convince pomfrey that there was a Ron/Draco/Cormac F3 deal that I just made up out of thin air. This sort of thing made people a lot more anxious and uncomfortable I think, but even as I was able to make people suspicious of each other, most of the people still in the game were pretty reluctant to take the initiative to propose new vote targets, so things tended to stay the course.

- I spread rumors that me and you had had a big fight when you were voted out and had fun inventing taunts that we supposedly said to each other in the heat of the moment. I think my favourite was telling people you called me "the world's first and worst water-breathing rat." I even mentioned it in my public rites of passage because the other f4 players could see those. Yes, that served the purpose of trying to convince people I had an extra enemy on the jury and was less of a threat, but it was also a running joke I shared with the viewers and used to pass the time.

- Most importantly, I tried my best to confess like crazy and think of new ways to do funny things in there, like bringing back my drunk tarot readings and trying to get other players to say catchphrases that the PWs suggested. No one else was really scrambling much, and some people were even offline a lot during those rounds, so I couldn't always do a lot to liven up slack, but at the very least I tried to always find ways to make things interesting for the viewers, even if it had to be in my confessional.


There was some stuff happening in-game that you wouldn't necessarily have seen from Ponderosa, but it wasn't close to the same level of drama as the early merge rounds and I want you to know that I noticed it and tried to do what I could to at least make it fun for the audience as much as I could without putting my own position in the game at risk.



Posted Image
   
Mirabella Plunkett
User Avatar
Mythmaker
Offline Marker
Reputation: 8
Group:Member
Posts:617
Joined:Feb 9, 2018
Post #2: 16th Mar 2018 7:03:21 AM 
Ron Weasley @ 16/3/2018 0:03
You had an amazing golden ticket in the Lockhart boot as your key resume piece, but you’ve seemingly done nothing else all game besides burn bridges. My two questions are why did you let Mira make the end and why did you (seemingly) do nothing else after I left?

I agree that that moment was a huge “showey” play. The only real one that I could potentially take 100% credit for.


Unless I missed you convincing Lockhart to give up an immunity necklace and pass his idol to Maxime, I'm gonna contest that Lockhart deserves a lot of credit for this :)
And so does Maxime for getting his idol.

But I would also like to point out that I was pushing for the vote to be on pomfrey or lockhart in the actual chatlog you just posted (which came at the end of a long discussion over where I was pushing for both of them before you brought up the draco/lockhart/you chat). Lockhart had just come off of two rounds of openly campaigning to vote me out and I had every reason in the world to be working on getting that vote on him. The only reason I wasn't actively waving pitchforks against him in that group chat was because Maxime was repeatedly telling me privately that she thought Lockhart wanted to work with her long-term so I was worried she might be more reluctant to vote for Lockhart than Pomfrey. My priority was saving Fred from that vote so I was willing to settle for a pomfrey vote if necessary, but I was going after Lockhart that round.

(side note: you told me about that lockhart/draco/ron group in a side chat before you shared it in the group chat, and I'm pretty sure you actually asked me whether you should raise with maxime in the group to shake things up, to which I encouraged you. It's funny reading this back and seeing me pretending to be surprised about the group chat information in this conversation while also pretending that Maxime hadn't already told me about getting the idol from lockhart hours earlier.)

I don't think the suggestion that you cooked up the idea and carried out this plan all by yourself and should get 100% credit is valid.

Posted Image
   
Mirabella Plunkett
User Avatar
Mythmaker
Offline Marker
Reputation: 8
Group:Member
Posts:617
Joined:Feb 9, 2018
Post #3: 16th Mar 2018 7:08:11 AM 
Draco Malfoy @ 16/3/2018 1:05
I think my game is somewhat of a missed opportunity


RT
Posted Image
   
Mirabella Plunkett
User Avatar
Mythmaker
Offline Marker
Reputation: 8
Group:Member
Posts:617
Joined:Feb 9, 2018
Post #4: 16th Mar 2018 7:29:56 AM 
Ron Weasley @ 16/3/2018 2:12
Hate to do this....but I will....


on a vote I was pretty certain would result in Angelina going home regardless.

Final 9 was a round where you ideally wanted to "make a show". You specifically wanted majority votes on yourself. I had conversations with Fred and Pomfrey about hiding the fact the votes were being split on yourself and Draco for the simple fact that Mira may get upset and not use the idol if she didn't have to. You wanted majority on yourself to act like you needed the idol to survive, in reality--the items that you were giving me--I gave to Angelina, allowing her to find out you already had the idol--leading to them splitting the vote and not just putting them all on you and/or all on Draco.


You may very well have had those conversations, but people still told me that the vote was being split between me and draco an I still knew there wouldn't be a majority of votes on me before the deadline hit, so yes, I was pretty certain the vote would result in Angelina going home regardless.

It might have been smart of you to hide the fact that votes were being split, but you didn't do that. So I don't know why you are taking issue with this.



Quote

I think it's incredibly clear that there were four players in this game that were determined to liven things up, take risks, take initiative and do their best to entertain the viewers.

You, Snape, Angelina and Me.


This is barf worthy. The fact that you just discredit Pomfrey, Fred, and myself and any involvement we had in this game. The moves that we made, and the initiative that we took to make game moves. You would not be sitting where you are if it wasn’t for the three of us. We both would not be sitting here right now without Pomfrey/Fred’s information from the other side from the merge game.
To label Pomfrey or myself boring is to spit on our shoes, and therefore I am spitting right back.

You are here because of your final 5 and final 6 immunity challenge wins. Otherwise, you would be 5th placer. You were an active person in a sea of rather inactives, so a reliable vote to be used.


You, Pomfrey and Fred were smart players doing things that were strategic and in the your own best interests. I'm not intending to take away from the agency of the three of you. The question was about making the game more fun and the three of you were intentionally not trying to make big splashy waves every round with reckless and boisterous moves the way the people I listed did. Snape did a lot of things that caused drama and were fun but not smart. Lockhart giving away his immunity and getting voted out was fun but not smart.

I would have a very different answer if he was asking who made the best game moves, but that wasn't the question. Pomfrey's personality was enough to entertain everyone so maybe I should have included her here as well, but I interpreted lockhart's question to be purely in terms of people making the season fun by making a lot of moves to ensure the game didn't stay static and I think my original list is a pretty reasonable answer to that.
Posted Image
   
5 Users Viewing (5 Guests)
  Final Tribal Council  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service