| |
Misty ♡
 | | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #1: 2nd May 2016 6:18:42 PM | |
|
|
So I have been toying around with this idea for a while now. I have done edgic for an ORG twice(ish) as a PW. Usually while doing it, it gets me thinking of what the people's position in the game is like, what they gotta do to win and so forth. I don't wanna indulge in too much strategizing in this game in general so this is where I will try and consolidate all of my "strategic thoughts" about the game based on whatever chats I have with players and try to extrapolate that into a pseudo-edgic rating or conjgic TM (conjecture + logic) rating. I mean I am hilariously bad at edgic to begin with so this will likely be a nice source of comedy post game too. -shrug- I like to laugh. Let's begin shall we.
Click here for Part 1 |
Click here for Part 2.0 |
I tend to slack when I am doing these. But they're also helpful in consolidating all of my ~strategy thoughts~ to one place.
These "Round 0 ratings" are based on my first impressions and what I heard about the players from other players before the tribe pick-em
Aubry - No sign of her.
Bob - Was pretty boring, run of the mill conversation with Bob that I, at one point, dropped without warning. He comes off as kinda condescending (unintentionally) hence the N
BobDawg - BobDawg was a delight to talk to. Very good energy. Keeps the conversation flowing smoothly. Very engaging presence.
Candice - Candice is a mixed bag (as seen from the tone) She has her moments of being very good and personable to talk to. But then there are moments of what seem like too much paranoia about the littlest things. I am still not buying that she is a newbie and that this is her first game.
Chris - Daugherty was another great conversationalist. Not AS good as BobDawg in that at times I felt like I had to carry the convo a bit to move it along. Still a pleasant one though and Chris comes across as a smart but down to earth guy.
Coach - Hardly any interaction at all with Coach but he was there more than Aubry.
Debbie - I like Debbie's shtick. I am a fan. I think it's funny and is a really good ice breaker. Beyond that I know nothing about her. Was tempted to give her an OTTP but I think for Round 0 OTT toneless is a better fit.
Fabio - Very weird to talk to. Like the convo feels super forced with the excessive heart emojis and the "dumb blonde"-esque way of talking. Gives shady/weird vibes to me hence the N.
Ib - Chats with Ib were so chill and laid back it's hard not to like him. And I can't be the only one who likes him so the P tone is based mostly off of my guess that he has good PSPV from other players. He didn't try to delve much into game talk and kept things pretty casual hence the MOR.
Jerry - I found Jerry to be boring and forgettable. As in I literally forgot what I talked about with Jerry already :x LOL.
Joanna - I'll give Joanna props for trying. The effort is there. The execution though. Very robotic. Very dull and feels very forced. There's no flow to the convo most of the times. Candice in particular gave me lots of NSPV about Joanna.
Joe - Same as Coach.
Jenn - Jenn is a special one. I am super excited that Jenn is on the same tribe as me because she makes a KILLER first impression. I would say it's almost IMPOSSIBLE not to like Jenn. Great great personality.
Misty - I think I did a good job of not coming across as gamebotty. Hence the MOR. And from the looks of things at least a few people wanted to be on the same tribe as me. Hence the P tone.
Nick - Nick was an interesting one. We didn't talk TOO much but he left a good enough impression on me that I remember liking him. Yet I don't remember specifics. Normally that would make him a MOR. But his approach to me (and to Candice) was good enough that I gave him a CP. That explanation doesn't make too much sense BUT WHATEVER.
Sandra - Who?
Shane - Shane was very blunt and to the point. But not in a bad way. There wasn't much, if any, substance to the conversation. But his presence was hard to ignore.
Tina - I really liked Tina right off the bat. But then it tapered off. Now she's just kind of there. Not entirely forgettable but not exactly memorable.
Contenders:
BobDawg - He's too likable to not be #1 contender.
Debbie - If she can use her shtick in an effective way, she can be a force to be reckoned with. From what I have seen so far she seems to be doing just that.
Chris - Smart guy who has a solid head on his shoulders.
Ib - Kind of a dark horse (pun not intended LOL). Winning the captains thing may have been a misstep but he seems skilled enough to overcome it. Social skills are on point. | | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #2: 4th May 2016 8:11:05 PM | |
Round 1: Final 18. Joe voted out.
Boot:
Joe - He ignored me (and others from what I heard) on day of TC while talking in the group chat. o_O ODD.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Aubry - Still no sign of her.
Bob - Not AS boring as last time but still pretty run-of-the-mill.
BobDawg - Chats with ol Dawgsta haven't been as consistent as I had expected. That makes it harder to give him a CP. Still as P toned as ever tho.
Candice - Oh my. Candice went SO overboard with trying to save Joe. It turned Tina off a bit. Even I felt like it was too much. I still ADORE her but she needs to chill.
Chris - Pretty similar dynamic with Chris still. Again I can't really justify a CP in the limited interactions.
Coach - The talk with Coach this round was just amazing. I am a FAN of his now. Super easy to talk to. Very pleasant. There is a BIT of a rough edge to his
Debbie - Still as much of a fun character as always. But a character still.
Fabio - Not as N as before. He seems to be finding his groove. He took initiative in making the alliance w/ Nick and I.
Ib - Hasn't been around these past 2 days. I was able to catch him very briefly today but it wasn't really a meaningful conversation.
Jerry - Jerry's PSPV has been getting better and better. Even from me. He made solid efforts to talk to me, get to know me. Gotta respect and appreciate that.
Joanna - Not AS bad as Round 1 but she is still super robotic and still has a decent amount of NSPV (mainly from Candice).
Jenn - Hasn't been around too much. But as usual is a DELIGHT when she is here.
Misty and Nick - Grouping Misty and Nick together because it would SEEM they are at the center of the Chikorita tribe. Candice, Tina, Shane, Jerry have all separately approached working with Nick and/or Misty. Both seem to be well liked and can straddle the middle. Visibility is pretty high for both since they seem to be on everyone's radar as people to work with.
Sandra - Who? [2]
Shane - Shane also made a lot of efforts to socialize and forge a bond. Not AS liked as Jerry but the effort is there.
Tina - Tina showed a super strategic side to her this round. I am starting to really like Tina and am glad that she seems to be wanting to work with me/stick with me for the long haul.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Contenders:
So I am gonna try to keep this as 2 from each tribe.
BobDawg - Same as Round 0 pretty much. By now BobDawg likely has a solid majority and a solid sub-alliance to have majority within a majority.
Coach - After talking to Coach today it's HARD not to put him here even though he has some flaws in his approach i.e not being subtle.
Tina - Although her edgic is CP, her game is pretty UTR. That's the perfect combination and she seems to be in one of the cushiest spots on this tribe - just the right # of connections and just the right amount of visibility.
Jenn - Jenn's the kind of player/person who can get ANYONE to like her. Combined with her UTR presence, she is poised to go deep. | | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #3: 9th May 2016 6:23:49 PM | |
Round 2: Final 17. Aubry voted out.
Boot:
Aubry - Still no sign of her. [2]
---------------------------------------------------------------
Bob - I didn't hear ANYTHING from Bob in Round 2 and he wasn't really present for the tug of war either IIRC.
BobDawg - It's kinda sad how much my chats with BobDawg have dropped off considering he was one of my early favorites. Oh well.
Candice - No tone for Candice this round because she had a bit of cool down. No one really talked about her to me and in my own chats with her she wasn't N by any means.
Chris - Same as BobDawg.
Coach - I think it was Round 2 where Coach was having good chats with me while simultaneously fishing for info from my tribe mates. I thought he was a LITTLE rough in his approach to cross tribal communication but he is seeming to be worse off than I initially anticipated. Still had his highlights in chats with me hence the M.
Debbie - Same old Deb. Same old OTT.
Fabio - Fabio started experiencing some AIM issues during this round i think. He helped out quite a bit in the tug of war but besides that wasn't around at all.
Ib - Same as BobDawg only less around.
Jerry - My round 2 interactions with Jerry were uneventful really. And he wasn't really around to help much in the challenge.
Joanna - She was a force to be reckoned with in this challenge but her team lacked. She seemed worried to an extent but ultimately survived. Because of her challenge contribution her visibility spiked but also
Jenn - Again not around much and our chats, while fun, haven't progressed beyond EXTREME (somewhat forced) excitement and Pokemon games.
Misty - I THINK I am still well liked enough on this tribe (and in the game to an extent) to warrant a P tone. I wasn't really strategic in Round 2 so the MOR.
Nick - Not TOO much happened with Nick and I this round. His PSPV wasn't as present as last round.
Sandra - Talking to Sandra was AMAZING. She is very clear cut and easy to talk to. Doesn't really mince words yet has a good sense of humor. Our chat was very open and well flowing. She quickly moved up to my favorite person of that tribe.
Shane - Shane went HAM in the challenge and was one of the main reasons we won.
Tina - Tina and I had some very nice personal chats this round. She is a very well rounded player who can get others to like her without appearing threatening. I am jealous of this skill tbh.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Contenders:
The ordering changes to reflect that someone from Chikorita will win and atm our best positioned tribe member is Tina. Rest is the same still. Keeping Coach on there because of the events of Round 3 to an extent. | | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #4: 10th May 2016 2:57:04 PM | |
Round 3: Final 16. Joanna voted out.
Boot:
Joanna - ROBBED tbh. It's sad that people don;t give Wesley a chance. He can be a great and loyal ally.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Bob - Where are you Bob!
BobDawg - Although my own interactions with him were non existent, I got second hand info indicating that he was in the center of things over on Ifbith.
Candice - Candice was ALL OVER THE PLACE last round. She was super nosy in the other tribe's tribal without being subtle at all. At one point she said she spammed Chris "who's going home tell me plz plz plz" <__< Girl needs to CHILLAX.
Chris - Chris is PRETTY much in the same boat as BobDawg and the same reasoning applies to him.
Coach - Coach went from possible easy boot to swing vote. That's amazing. And we have been having regular fun chats. Coach is pretty damn great.
Debbie - Was apparently in the minority and got a stray vote cast against here. Haven't heard too much from her lately and she got some NSPV from Sandra.
Fabio - He has disappeared :\
Ib - Ib's activity has been spotty as well. He's gotten mixed SPV from his tribe (Coach likes him, Sandra wants him gone.) I myself am mixed on him too.
Jerry - Jerry was around. But I can't remember what he did.
Jenn - Still not around TOO much but when she is she is as amazing as ever. Even Candice was able to catch up with Jenn this round.
Misty - I was very similar to Candice in that I was involved to an extent in the other tribe;s TC but I did so subtly (at least I think) And Joanna gave me her coins without me having to ask. That indicates at least some extent of PSPV.
Nick - Another quiet-ish round for Nick but he had tons of PSPV this round.
Sandra - Although I personally enjoy talking to Sandy a lot, she can come on too strong and rub a few people the wrong way. She was in the think of things last vote too.
Shane - Same as Jerry.
Tina - Another relatively quiet round for Mama Wesson. But she and I still keep up our fun chats. She was strategic in discussing the challenge with me.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Contenders:
Only change is Coach moving above BobDawg. From what it sounds, Coach is in the middle of things over on Ifbith. Perfect place to be for now. | | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #5: 13th May 2016 9:38:29 PM | |
Round 4: Final 15. Sandra voted out.
Boot:
Sandra - UGH another ally lost :(
---------------------------------------------------------------
Bob - Where are you Bob! [3]
BobDawg - Our talks have started to become better again and he is back to being his awesome self that I saw early on.
Candice - Candice needed a cooldown and thank goodness she got one this round.
Chris - Similar to BobDawg, Chris and I started re-connecting better this round. Also it was apparently between Chris and Sandra for the vote so Chris is the yin to Sandra's yang in a sense.
Coach - I THINK Coach was in the middle of things again but from the sounds of it, Coach handled the situation poorly hence the M. But he was very strategic in my chats with him.
Debbie - I think Debbie has finally started to rub people the wrong way.
Fabio - Still no sign of him :\
Ib - He has also disappeared. I think he's busy with finals.
Jerry - Jerry and I had a good chat here and there this round but nothing of note.
Jenn - Jenn also wasn't around TOO much but when she was she as as good as always.
Misty - Giving myself the P tone again because Sandra ended up passing her coins to me which indicates some level of PSPV again. I was involved in some strategy talks with Coach/Sandra hence the CP.
Nick and Tina - Putting them both together because they both had a pretty low-key round but contributed in the challenge win IIRC.
Shane - Nothing of too much note but when he was around he was pretty much his funny, somewhat blunt self.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Contenders:
Little shuffle in the contenders. Coach keeps going back and forth between being smooth and being too pushy. Tina still seemed like in the best spot on OG Chikorita (this doesn't account for the swapfuck that happened to her next round RIP :( ) | | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #6: 16th May 2016 1:51:47 PM | |
Round 5 and 6: Final 14 and 13. Coach voted out and Fabio evaced.
Boot:
Coach - Coach finally crossed over from CP to OTT territory in his super-aggressive approach to the game and info sharing/snooping. He still had his moments tho both good and bad hence the M tone.
Fabio - About damn time tee bee aech.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Bob - Where are you Bob! [4]
BobDawg - For R5, Dawg was superb to talk to this round but there were huge strategic undertones to everything we talked about. The switch to get the idol clue/old tribe numbers safety was a big visible move too. For R6, nothing much happened between Dawg and I.
Candice - R5: Candice and I finally had another great chat and it was juts lovely. But she is still coming off as mixed and kinda cut throat. I am not very sure how to feel about her but I definitely do not buy the first time player/n00b thing. R6: Candice went off the deep nend again with regards to her paranoia about merge and #s and Ifbith v/s Chikorita. Bless her but she is a handful and a half.
Chris - Chris always feels like Dawg-lite :x LOL. For both R5 and R6.
Debbie - Debbie shows up. Debbie says a couple of lines in keeping with her shtick. Debbie disappears. Rinse, lather, repeat.
Ib - The # of disappearances is too damn high! At least Ib did the challenge tho hence no INV for him.
Jerry - Nothing of note happened with Jerry in both rounds.
Jenn - R5: Jenn is back to her OVERLY ENTHUSIASTIC shtick in conversations. I can hardly talk about the game with her before it gets sidetracked. Still lovely to talk to though. R6: Borderline inactive.
Misty - R5: This was KIND of my cool down round? At least I think. R6: I pushed HARD for us to throw and Fabio to leave. May have rubbed some people the wrong way.
Nick - R5: Nick was SUPER strategic and visible this round. Same as BobDawg pretty much. He ended up picking up an idol and is in a great spot overall. R6: We talked through the throwing and he filled in Jerry I think.
Shane - R5: Shane's OTTness has started to run me (and others (mainly Coach)) the wrong way. R6: Nothing of note.
Tina - R5: Tina is SUCH a sweetheart and it SUCKS to see her get swapfucked. RIP angel </3 THAT BEING SAID. I think she is pissed at me for w/e reason. For R6: We just straight up stopped talking and I am sad.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Contenders:
Tina surviving over Coach just goes to show how good she is. Coach dropped off and Nick showed up mostly because IDK who else to put there. He does have an idol so he has some safety. Jenn is dropping FAST. BobDawg is also on there mostly because the rest of the OG Ifbith is borderline inac.
| | |
| | | |
Misty ♡
| | Reputation: 4 | | Group: | Member | | Posts: | 272 | | Joined: | Apr 29, 2016 |
| Post #7: 23rd May 2016 7:41:37 PM | |
Round 7: Final 12. Crowley voted out
Boot:
Bob - Where are you Bob! [5] Not in the game anymore. YAY!
---------------------------------------------------------------
Gonna skip writeups since the round is long done.
| | |
| | | |
| 2 Users Viewing (2 Guests) |
|
|
