Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:15

Bagshot @ 23/4/2012 21:12 Yes Paco asked the red guard if he was red and he said no. ah okay, thank u maybe the guards roles SWITCHED somehow? I dunno, but I don't see how us asking "is the other guard blue?" and red guard saying "YES" can mean the red guard is a liar and before Malarkey goes "OMG LOL THATS CUZ NINEFINGERS IS SCUM" that's funny cuz he was the one bitching at us for NOT asking the blue guard any questions. The WHOLE phase he was saying we need to ask the blue guard something to make sure but no one listened. Why would he want to be caught in a lie Malarkey? :)

Didnt you guys get a yes for north-east? We got a yes for south-east so they didnt switch, key cant both be in the north-east and the south-east.

I said Ninefingers is probably a smart bad guy. A smart bad guy would appear to be helping ;)

The other group definitely has at least 1 scum though, there's no way they don't

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:18

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:15 Bagshot @ 23/4/2012 21:12 Yes Paco asked the red guard if he was red and he said no. ah okay, thank u maybe the guards roles SWITCHED somehow? I dunno, but I don't see how us asking "is the other guard blue?" and red guard saying "YES" can mean the red guard is a liar and before Malarkey goes "OMG LOL THATS CUZ NINEFINGERS IS SCUM" that's funny cuz he was the one bitching at us for NOT asking the blue guard any questions. The WHOLE phase he was saying we need to ask the blue guard something to make sure but no one listened. Why would he want to be caught in a lie Malarkey? :) Didnt you guys get a yes for north-east? We got a yes for south-east so they didnt switch, key cant both be in the north-east and the south-east. I said Ninefingers is probably a smart bad guy. A smart bad guy would appear to be helping ;)

he's also risked his life multiple times for us!

you srsly have no idea what you're talking about Malarkey :-/ You've never talked to the guy besides the anteroom. Never interacted with him, saw his role at work, etc.

I know u think you have it ALL figured it out but whatever

Bagshot @ 23/4/2012 21:20

The other group definitely has at least 1 scum though, there's no way they don't

well we have ousted 3 scum (at least we're pretty confident they were scum): Brock, Robert, DRRR

The only ones I doubt are Frosti Kiwi and Walter, I'm not convinced Drr was scum.

I wont say impossible again Jeffrey :D

If you can prove it to me that something can be in both rows 1-6 and 7-9, ill be willing to accept that possibly Ninefingers wasnt lying :P

Merc also "risked" (looked that way but Willis was directing him yes i know) his life a few times last game. Same with Budd / Curtis. Doesnt really say much. We all believed Merc was an item scanner last game as well, fooled us all.

DRīs chalk message didnt sound like a defeated scum person to me tbh

also the exit key could of shifted from northeast to southeast when the WISPS happened. Other rooms did move so its certainly possible

but anyway in the red room Willis told FROSTI that we were silly for listening to anything the guards said and that them revealing the key's location would of been too easy. We all decided it was Willis trying to divert us since we figured out so much info but now Im starting to think there might of been some truth to it maybe

I dont know what to think TBH. But Malarkey you do seem WAY too confident that you have everything figured out :P

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:28

I wont say impossible again Jeffrey :D If you can prove it to me that something can be in both rows 1-6 and 7-9, ill be willing to accept that possibly Ninefingers wasnt lying :P Merc also "risked" (looked that way but Willis was directing him yes i know) his life a few times last game. Same with Budd / Curtis. Doesnt really say much. We all believed Merc was an item scanner last game as well, fooled us all.

yes Malarkey cuz the mole would use the exact same alibi two games in a row.

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:29

DRīs chalk message didnt sound like a defeated scum person to me tbh

did she leave that in the guard room? Did anyone save that message?

Well if they look NE and we look SE then it'll get found.

I always have everything figured out Jeffrey ;)

Anyways your group can look in the north-east. We will look in the south-east. Lets see where that brings us.

Where does north go jeff?
and south?

I was confused by your answer earlier :P

I saved it, ill post it and ?s when I get home.

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:32

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:28 I wont say impossible again Jeffrey :D If you can prove it to me that something can be in both rows 1-6 and 7-9, ill be willing to accept that possibly Ninefingers wasnt lying :P Merc also "risked" (looked that way but Willis was directing him yes i know) his life a few times last game. Same with Budd / Curtis. Doesnt really say much. We all believed Merc was an item scanner last game as well, fooled us all. yes Malarkey cuz the mole would use the exact same alibi two games in a row. Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:29 DRīs chalk message didnt sound like a defeated scum person to me tbh did she leave that in the guard room? Did anyone save that message?

Ninefingers might not know of Mercīs claim. It might be the only role he could fake for all we know.

She wrote that Kiwi is the devil. Frosti is a tyrant and that Walter is fishy and something about Alex being a cool guy. She also said she was the messiah, doubt she would still claim that when she was dead and buried

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:32

I always have everything figured out Jeffrey ;) Anyways your group can look in the north-east. We will look in the south-east. Lets see where that brings us. Where does north go jeff? and south? I was confused by your answer earlier :P

lol didn't you also come from the north? That's the room u were just in :P

south takes us pretty close to the southeast corner, that's all I know. It's somewhere on that bottom LINE I drew

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:34

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:32 Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:28 I wont say impossible again Jeffrey :D If you can prove it to me that something can be in both rows 1-6 and 7-9, ill be willing to accept that possibly Ninefingers wasnt lying :P Merc also "risked" (looked that way but Willis was directing him yes i know) his life a few times last game. Same with Budd / Curtis. Doesnt really say much. We all believed Merc was an item scanner last game as well, fooled us all. yes Malarkey cuz the mole would use the exact same alibi two games in a row. Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:29 DRīs chalk message didnt sound like a defeated scum person to me tbh did she leave that in the guard room? Did anyone save that message? Ninefingers might not know of Mercīs claim. It might be the only role he could fake for all we know. She wrote that Kiwi is the devil. Frosti is a tyrant and that Walter is fishy and something about Alex being a cool guy. She also said she was the messiah, doubt she would still claim that when she was dead and buried

well there are revivers in this game as you know (:

Im sure a "messiah" is something they'd be more inclined to resurrect! Just sayin (: