Didnt you ask if we could all win together? And the answer was yes?

We had ublazrob in our group then, who we believe to be evil. He always said his role would be triggered at some part in the game. We believe the wisps triggered his role in phase 15(?) or something.

Sooo thats probably why that answer was a yes.

We used the guards to clear everyone besides Klaus and Happy. Who have already roleclaimed (and we have seen them at work) and they arnt bad guy roles.

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:07

Didnt you ask if we could all win together? And the answer was yes? We had ublazrob in our group then, who we believe to be evil. He always said his role would be triggered at some part in the game. We believe the wisps triggered his role in phase 15(?) or something. Sooo thats probably why that answer was a yes. We used the guards to clear everyone besides Klaus and Happy. Who have already roleclaimed (and we have seen them at work) and they arnt bad guy roles.

first we asked if there were AT LEAST two evil ppl in your group, red guard said NO. Then we asked if there were ANY evil ppl in your group, the red guard again said NO. Obviously we didn't acutally ask "are there any evil ppl", we made sure it was foolproof (:

also we've seen Ninefingers at work. He can sense items in rooms that are next to us.

also you still haven't answered my question (:

did you or did you not ask the RED guard any questions?

Well Merc could sense item in peoples pockets last game

That didnt work out so well eh

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:10

also you still haven't answered my question (: did you or did you not ask the RED guard any questions?

We didnt ask him anything cause we had already proved logically that the blue guard was the truth teller :D

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:11

Well Merc could sense item in peoples pockets last game That didnt work out so well eh

:|

Yes Paco asked the red guard if he was red and he said no.

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:12

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:10 also you still haven't answered my question (: did you or did you not ask the RED guard any questions? We didnt ask him anything cause we had already proved logically that the blue guard was the truth teller :D

just like we didn't ask the blue guard anything because we logically proved that he was the truth teller :D

same boat my friend

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 23/4/2012 21:13

Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:12 Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:10 also you still haven't answered my question (: did you or did you not ask the RED guard any questions? We didnt ask him anything cause we had already proved logically that the blue guard was the truth teller :D just like we didn't ask the blue guard anything because we logically proved that he was the truth teller :D same boat my friend

lol i meant we proved the red guard to be the truth teller

oh well I dont have the questions 100% :D

Bagshot is probably the best person to ask :P

Everything else was to blue.

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:13

Jeffrey Fernandis @ 23/4/2012 21:13 Malarkey @ 23/4/2012 21:12 Jeffrey Fernandis @ 24/4/2012 2:10 also you still haven't answered my question (: did you or did you not ask the RED guard any questions? We didnt ask him anything cause we had already proved logically that the blue guard was the truth teller :D just like we didn't ask the blue guard anything because we logically proved that he was the truth teller :D same boat my friend lol i meant we proved the red guard to be the truth teller

No you only asked him.

Like I said its impossible for the key to be both in rows 1-6 and 7-9 so the blue one has to be telling the truth

My phones out of battery so I can't post the rest yet

Bagshot @ 23/4/2012 21:12

Yes Paco asked the red guard if he was red and he said no.

ah okay, thank u

maybe the guards roles SWITCHED somehow? I dunno, but I don't see how us asking "is the other guard blue?" and red guard saying "YES" can mean the red guard is a liar

and before Malarkey goes "OMG LOL THATS CUZ NINEFINGERS IS SCUM" that's funny cuz he was the one bitching at us for NOT asking the blue guard any questions. The WHOLE phase he was saying we need to ask the blue guard something to make sure but no one listened. Why would he want to be caught in a lie Malarkey? :)

Its possible they switched when the room swaps and the soul storm happened