Mafia is going to have a hard time trying to figure out whom Dr will protect tonight, hopefully she protects who they choose so we don't lose another town member.
I hate this post
This post confuses me as well. What purpose does it serve?
Jesus Christ, okay I'm always fucking playing catch-up
Tim claimed cop and scanned Grim as a scum role, Grim hints that she (I think it's a she, sorry it's a he) may have dropped "gifts" off to people during the night and that now they know where it came from.
Ahoda counter claims cop, claims he got pro-town reads from Miko and Curtis and a scum read from Tim. That means that somebody lawyer'd Curtis or framed Miko the rounds he scanned them.
Doesn't make much sense for Ahoda to counter-claim a cop for no reason if he's scum. I lean towards lynching Tim if only because it tells us about Grim as well, and because he was put on the spot for a claim by Ahoda, and Ahoda didn't need to counter-claim for no reason
##Lynch Tim
Somebody tell me if I'm wrong about anything please
EDIT: Ahoda's read on Miko was scum, I accidently recapped as town
Ahoda's counter-claim is more believable, because why make up that you got a town read from Curtis and scum from Miko? It makes his claim less believable if anything else... which makes it more believable because why would he deliberately make it more complicated?
i scanned you night 2. i don't think i had a specific reason. i was just looking for someone who had not claimed that i thought would be alive for a while.
You didn't go for a suspect?
i wanted to look at someone that would be difficult to lynch without evidence.
Funny, you think that would have been a reason to investigate Curtis. I can't imagine why you didn't choose that, when he is notoriously difficult to lynch, whereas Vern is not.
in a normal game he might be hard to lynch, but this is not a normal game. as it is he went down without a fight because he was inactive.
EDIT: Ahoda's read on Miko was scum, I accidently recapped as town
Ahoda's counter-claim is more believable, because why make up that you got a town read from Curtis and scum from Miko? It makes his claim less believable if anything else... which makes it more believable because why would he deliberately make it more complicated?
To those saying that there was no reason for Ahoda to counterclaim, you can say the same thing about Tim claiming in the first place. Why did he do it when he wasn't under any pressure pressure?
One possible explanation is that scum decided they needed to try something bold after losing four members of their team, and they settled on claiming cop. It's possible they were banking on there been no actual cop to counterclaim.
It's a strange situation, and I don't think we have two investigators on the town side, regardless of whether or not one of them is paranoid/insane/random. The signs point to a framer being in play, and that that is what is messing up results.
Despite all this, I'm not sure if Tim is the best play for today. I think Moose is a pretty good bet as scum. Herm is also lurking and doesn't appear to give a damn.
