Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 11:09

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:53 Wait a minute, at first I thought this was the same thing that happened to me and Ahoda, but we were given a forum to talk to on night 1. The forum wasn't there at the start of the night so it seems we were given the forum to talk to on the same night. It was gone during day 2?

Yes. We could only talk to each other during the latter half of night 1.

Angi was a tracker, not a watcher yo

But don't let facts stop your story like Hilldog

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 11:03

Primate @ 21/9/2016 10:40 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:18 Primate @ 21/9/2016 9:28 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 9:19 There is nothing forced about that. I have/had evidence pointing towards Dr as possible cult. Now I am less convinced because she has no reason to protect me if she is cult. None? Are you kidding me? I could think of two without even breaking a sweat. 1) You are cult with her (not saying you are, but it's a possible reason) 2) She wants town credit 1) is wrong so yeah none. How would 2) help gaining her town cred. Does anyone believe she could be GF? Really? So I am just supposed to take your word for it? If so, damn it would be easy for scum/cult to win this game. You also apparently ignored the point of my post and took it as direct attack on you. I said these were possible reasons (to an outsider, not someone that knows is own fucking role/alignment). And people call me the ape with a simple brain! And no, I don't believe she's the GF. But if she IS the only other cult member, by doc'ing someone else she appears PT. Do we have any other claimed town PRs currently? If not, I could argue -dr not docing herself calls into question your response. See how easy that was? Wow take your chill pill, you question me seeing no reason she would do that if she is cult. K if she's the only cult sure. But you can't argue that your 1) is a reason I could see for her doing that as cult. Has nothing to do with you having to believe my word for it. I don't think it's likely that she is cult based on my own alignment and that is my point of view obv.

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 11:03

Primate @ 21/9/2016 10:40 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:18 Primate @ 21/9/2016 9:28 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 9:19 There is nothing forced about that. I have/had evidence pointing towards Dr as possible cult. Now I am less convinced because she has no reason to protect me if she is cult. None? Are you kidding me? I could think of two without even breaking a sweat. 1) You are cult with her (not saying you are, but it's a possible reason) 2) She wants town credit 1) is wrong so yeah none. How would 2) help gaining her town cred. Does anyone believe she could be GF? Really? So I am just supposed to take your word for it? If so, damn it would be easy for scum/cult to win this game. You also apparently ignored the point of my post and took it as direct attack on you. I said these were possible reasons (to an outsider, not someone that knows is own fucking role/alignment). And people call me the ape with a simple brain! And no, I don't believe she's the GF. But if she IS the only other cult member, by doc'ing someone else she appears PT. Do we have any other claimed town PRs currently? If not, I could argue -dr not docing herself calls into question your response. See how easy that was? Wow take your chill pill, you question me seeing no reason she would do that if she is cult. K if she's the only cult sure. But you can't argue that your 1) is a reason I could see for her doing that as cult. Has nothing to do with you having to believe my word for it. I don't think it's likely that she is cult based on my own alignment and that is my point of view obv.

Don't tell me what to do, I am playing my role damn it!

All I'm saying is there are always more than one way to look at things since everyone has different bits of information. Closed mindedness leads to stupid lynches.

I feel like I want to look at Angi's posts now to see if she breadcrumbed things. :P

When I was looking I also found this old quote from KC, I want to give it some more colors to see if we learn something new. lol

KC

A little analysis of the first day. Tried to make sense of yesterday. Day 1: Angi lynches Vernon Brian lynches Herm Primate lynches Curtis Christian lynches Chris Vernon lynches Henry dr lynches Ahoda Moose lynches Vernon Henry lynches Vernon Curtis lynches Tim Vlady lynches Vernon Chris lynches ahoda JC lynches Vernon Nofo lynches Vlady All the lynches above seem like the stereotypical lynches for these people. ------ Brian lynches Boc (one of two people who hadn't posts. Was it coincidence or was it a cover up.) dr lynches Boc (This combined with the fact she survived an attack is very convenient). Herm lynches Boc (CHOO CHOO) KC lynches Wikey JC lynches Boc Vlady lynches Boc (Again ignoring how quick this train is building) Grim lynches Wikey (Would not be a terrible move for scum to put a vote on this train in case something were to change). Primate lynches Boc (to spite me, That shit). Christian lynches Wikey Vernon lynches Wikey (says in case Boc comes. Does this jump back to the Grim comment?). Young Jeff makes a similar point about the Boc train growing quickly. Angi goes back and forth. Vlady lynches Henry (as long as it is not Wikey, right?) Jeff lynches Henry as well. Christian jumps off the Wikey train. Angi calls dr scummy. Very interesting. If Dr flips gf I could see Angi being the usurper. Shadow lynches Wikey Angi lynches Wikey Angi switches back to Boc Boc shows up and lynches Wikey Angi does not switch to Wikey, but to Vernon. Kind of suspcious. Miko lynches Wikey Brian unlynches Boc.

Looking back at Jeff's actions in particular, I'm really starting to think that Henry is the Mafia Godfather. :P

Seems like it might not be a cult recruitment. Dr was a big target for mafia that night so I think there's a chance she's town after all. Grim posted after these posts, but I didn't find a connection between Grim & Angi.

Angi

I tracked someone and they visited Dr last night. No need to release whom it was at this point unless something negative happened to Dr.

Dr

Nothing bad, but something did happen. Whoever visisted me is probably town

Dr

Actually, I may have had multiple visitors, so whoever Angi tracked might not be the same person who did this thing to me

Christian @ 21/9/2016 9:25

As far as cult's concerned, it could be Nofo and Dr. They're prime cult targets and they're acting a bit weird imo. I'm just confused about Ahoda being roleblocked some nights ago because there were clear indiciations that he was town at that point. ## lynch Moose She was more or less coaching Vic all the way through yesterday. It also seems to be that she's been trying to go after cult more than mafia these last couple of phases. That raises red flags. I still think Henry is scum and that's why Vic and Moose went out of their way to not lynch him on D5.

And you more or less avoided lynching Vic at all. Some could say you didn't want to risk losing a scumbuddy. Christian my friend, do I think you are scum. No, but you are wrong on so many levels.

Could Shadow be the GF?

There is obviously a chance she's still town. Just like there is a chance Cool Girl could have been a cult target after using the day kill (pretty much assumed to be vanilla after that unless I misinterpreted the role).

It's been a while since I've played a game with cult so remind me if a person is recruited would the write up indicate that or still show their town alignment?

Christian @ 21/9/2016 9:05

Nofo and Rose were both on Tim's lynch train actually. It's not out of the question that they were protecting their Grim Reaper. :P

I said this already, on D5 I think, everyone who was online late in the day and still lynched Tim is either retarded or scum.

Tim: 8 (Angi, Chris, Ahoda, Grim, Nofo, Vic, dr, Dadd)
Grim: 3 (Tim, Shadow, Vernon)
Dadd: 1 (Herm)

Those were

Ahoda, Grim, Nofo, Vic, dr, Dadd


I WONDER WHAT ALIGNMENT NOFO AND DR ARE HMMMMMMMMMMMM


But IMO they aren't a threat ATM, we should lynch potential GF/SK to lower the amount of kills.

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:24

Moose @ 20/9/2016 19:48 Ole' Vern @ 20/9/2016 19:41 I wonder if DR is protecting her or Nofo every day, since Grim is ded Could be. With a usurper, it's likely that a mafia GF is still out there though. Could be either? Are you forgetting there's a Town Doctor? lol

I was talking about Nofo possibly being either GF or Cult recruit. That was before Dr said she protected him.

Primate @ 21/9/2016 10:20

There is obviously a chance she's still town. Just like there is a chance Cool Girl could have been a cult target after using the day kill (pretty much assumed to be vanilla after that unless I misinterpreted the role). It's been a while since I've played a game with cult so remind me if a person is recruited would the write up indicate that or still show their town alignment?

It woul show Cult not town

I don't think Shadow is cult. I suppose he could be Mafia of some kind.

I'm not sure what to think of Dr and Nofo. Primate brought up a good point though. Why would she protect him when she had him labeled as potential cult during the day?

Also, why were the private forums set up differently for Christian/Ahoda and Dr/Nofo? Nobody's flipped with that role yet, right?

I also wonder if Mafia attacked KC or Nofo.

Christian, if you thought Henry was Mafia for two days in a row, and even said Jeff's posts have you thinking he may actually be the GF, why are you still voting for me? And why do you have Chris and Boc as Town?

Moose @ 21/9/2016 12:36

I don't think Shadow is cult. I suppose he could be Mafia of some kind. I'm not sure what to think of Dr and Nofo. Primate brought up a good point though. Why would she protect him when she had him labeled as potential cult during the day? Also, why were the private forums set up differently for Christian/Ahoda and Dr/Nofo? Nobody's flipped with that role yet, right? I also wonder if Mafia attacked KC or Nofo. Christian, if you thought Henry was Mafia for two days in a row, and even said Jeff's posts have you thinking he may actually be the GF, why are you still voting for me? And why do you have Chris and Boc as Town?

Wow so many questions. Why are you asking why the private forums were set up differently, who are you asking that, who would know, and what are you trying to accomplish by asking that?