I think Primate is making the argument that Dr is cult, not mafia.

She can't possibly be mafia.

Moose @ 20/9/2016 19:48

Ole' Vern @ 20/9/2016 19:41 I wonder if DR is protecting her or Nofo every day, since Grim is ded Could be. With a usurper, it's likely that a mafia GF is still out there though. Could be either?

Are you forgetting there's a Town Doctor? lol

Christian @ 21/9/2016 9:30

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 0:44 Ok. Dr did you protect me? Looks like I was wrong about KC. There is active scum left though. Primate or Boc today imo. This post smells fishy. Can you elaborate why Primate and Boc?

They are kind of MOR lurking types. I've had a town read on you for a while now, Vern and Shadow were scanned by Tim (they could be GF but at least they are less likely), dr is doc, henry and Dylan are supposedly inactive. I guess that leaves Moose as well and anyone else I forgot.

How is that fishy? Did you not cross any of those names off? I agree with you that it could be Moose fwiw.

I was given a private forum with dr day 3, so someone visited both of us night 2. Angi saw the person visiting one person (dr) that night tho so it was most definitely another person.

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:18

Primate @ 21/9/2016 9:28 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 9:19 There is nothing forced about that. I have/had evidence pointing towards Dr as possible cult. Now I am less convinced because she has no reason to protect me if she is cult. None? Are you kidding me? I could think of two without even breaking a sweat. 1) You are cult with her (not saying you are, but it's a possible reason) 2) She wants town credit 1) is wrong so yeah none. How would 2) help gaining her town cred. Does anyone believe she could be GF? Really?

So I am just supposed to take your word for it? If so, damn it would be easy for scum/cult to win this game. You also apparently ignored the point of my post and took it as direct attack on you. I said these were possible reasons (to an outsider, not someone that knows is own fucking role/alignment). And people call me the ape with a simple brain!

And no, I don't believe she's the GF. But if she IS the only other cult member, by doc'ing someone else she appears PT. Do we have any other claimed town PRs currently? If not, I could argue -dr not docing herself calls into question your response. See how easy that was?

Nofo @ 21/9/2016 10:26

They are kind of MOR lurking types.

I'm actually starting to come to the

Nofo @ 21/9/2016 10:26

How is that fishy? Did you not cross any of those names off? I agree with you that it could be Moose fwiw.

I get a bit of a town feeling from Primate and I initially concluded that Boc was an unlikely recruit since he jumped on the Wikey lynch train pretty late. But it is as you say, Boc and Shadow in particular have been in the shadows quite a bit. Since none of the other claimed townies turned up cult, I'm not really convinced you and Rose were recruited because of the risk of being targeted.

Now that I think back, Vernon called out Shadow for wanting to lynch both Herm and Dadd on D5, which seems to suggest to me that the most likely cult suspects are Shadow and Boc.

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:33

I was given a private forum with dr day 3, so someone visited both of us night 2. Angi saw the person visiting one person (dr) that night tho so it was most definitely another person.

That solves that. No recruitment of Dr N2 then. :P

Christian
Chris25
Primate
Vernon
Dr
Nofo
Boc
Shadow
Henry
Moose
...
Dylan???

Shadow was very quick to lynch Grim D4. He was also the first one to figure out that Tim was the Cop.

Day 4

Day 4 Lynch Train: Tim: 8 (Angi, Chris, Ahoda, Grim, Nofo, Vic, dr, Dadd) Grim: 3 (Tim, Shadow, Vernon) Dadd: 1 (Herm)

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:43

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:33 I was given a private forum with dr day 3, so someone visited both of us night 2. Angi saw the person visiting one person (dr) that night tho so it was most definitely another person. That solves that. No recruitment of Dr N2 then. :P

Wait a minute, at first I thought this was the same thing that happened to me and Ahoda, but we were given a forum to talk to on night 1. The forum wasn't there at the start of the night so it seems we were given the forum to talk to on the same night.

I don't think you visit the people that you select to spend a night or day together now that I think about, so the issue of Rose being visited N2 still remains. I'm a bit skeptical now since your private forum seems to have a completely different set up than the forum I was in.

Primate @ 21/9/2016 10:40

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:18 Primate @ 21/9/2016 9:28 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 9:19 There is nothing forced about that. I have/had evidence pointing towards Dr as possible cult. Now I am less convinced because she has no reason to protect me if she is cult. None? Are you kidding me? I could think of two without even breaking a sweat. 1) You are cult with her (not saying you are, but it's a possible reason) 2) She wants town credit 1) is wrong so yeah none. How would 2) help gaining her town cred. Does anyone believe she could be GF? Really? So I am just supposed to take your word for it? If so, damn it would be easy for scum/cult to win this game. You also apparently ignored the point of my post and took it as direct attack on you. I said these were possible reasons (to an outsider, not someone that knows is own fucking role/alignment). And people call me the ape with a simple brain! And no, I don't believe she's the GF. But if she IS the only other cult member, by doc'ing someone else she appears PT. Do we have any other claimed town PRs currently? If not, I could argue -dr not docing herself calls into question your response. See how easy that was?

Wow take your chill pill, you question me seeing no reason she would do that if she is cult. K if she's the only cult sure. But you can't argue that your 1) is a reason I could see for her doing that as cult. Has nothing to do with you having to believe my word for it. I don't think it's likely that she is cult based on my own alignment and that is my point of view obv.

Nofo and Rose were both on Tim's lynch train actually. It's not out of the question that they were protecting their Grim Reaper. :P

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:43

Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:33 I was given a private forum with dr day 3, so someone visited both of us night 2. Angi saw the person visiting one person (dr) that night tho so it was most definitely another person. That solves that. No recruitment of Dr N2 then. :P

Not really.

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:53

Christian @ 21/9/2016 10:43 Cool Girl @ 21/9/2016 10:33 I was given a private forum with dr day 3, so someone visited both of us night 2. Angi saw the person visiting one person (dr) that night tho so it was most definitely another person. That solves that. No recruitment of Dr N2 then. :P Wait a minute, at first I thought this was the same thing that happened to me and Ahoda, but we were given a forum to talk to on night 1. The forum wasn't there at the start of the night so it seems we were given the forum to talk to on the same night.

It was gone during day 2?