True, Ahoda's Curtis scan means he could be insane cop and Tim is actually town and real cop, but then why would he get a scum scan on Grim? Seems like a stupid move if he was actually scum because as soon as she flips he's done, he can't even claim insane cop anymore.
Let's examine the situation, shall we? :P If both are Cops, then naturally one of them would have to be an Insane Cop. Tim initially said he was handing us scum on a silver platter, which seems to suggest that he was telling the truth at the time. But if Ahoda's supposed to be an Insane Cop, then how does that explain Miko scanning as town? Unless he was lawyered the same night as he was killed, which makes no sense to me. lol
Ahoda's scans:
night 1 Miko as town
night 2 Curtis as town
night 3 Tim as scum
Tim's scans:
night 1 Shadow as town
night 2 Vernon as town
night 3 Grim as scum
Christian's logic is what my rambling posts try to convey.
Ahoda is either a real cop and Curtis was lawyer'd, or he is insane cop and Miko was either framed or bussed.
Tim is either a real cop and Shadow/Vernon are town and Grim is scum, or he's scum, (if he was insane cop then that would be fucking amazing knowing Shadow and Vernon would be scum in that situation, but I dont' think they are scum and I don't think Tim is insane)
Knowing Tim scanned Shadow and Vernon as town gives me more cause to believe him since I have town reads on them. BUT I think this issue needs to be resolved because doing something like a Grim or Moose or inactive lynch tells us nothing and we face this same issue tomorrow.
Lynching Tim tells us a bit, if we're incorrect about him being scum and he shows up as real cop, that sucks but we know Shadow/Vern are town and Grim is scum. If he shows up as insane cop then we know Shadow and Vern are scum lol (that's wouldn't happen tho I feel like) and Grim is town. If he shows up as scum then that clears Grim's name a bit and gets another scum out of here.
Lynching Ahoda tells us a bit, if he flips real cop then we know Tim is scum and scum has a lawyer, if he flips insane cop then we know Tim is town and Miko was either framed or bussed, and I don't think he would flip as scum but if so it clears Tim a bit and also gets another scum out.
Lynching Grim... if she flips as town gift giver, then we know Tim is either insane (not likely given his Shadow and Vern reads), or scum. If she flips scum then we know Tim is real cop and Ahoda is insane.
Idk I feel most comfortable with the Tim lynch still since Grim hinted that people who got her gifts are silently supporting her by being on that train, and if they're gifts like the gun I can understand why they don't want to speak up because that makes them targets for scum
True, Ahoda's Curtis scan means he could be insane cop and Tim is actually town and real cop, but then why would he get a scum scan on Grim? Seems like a stupid move if he was actually scum because as soon as she flips he's done, he can't even claim insane cop anymore.
This is a weird post
:henry: Grim got bussed with scum and all 3 of them are town, all part of Vic's mastermind plan
True, Ahoda's Curtis scan means he could be insane cop and Tim is actually town and real cop, but then why would he get a scum scan on Grim? Seems like a stupid move if he was actually scum because as soon as she flips he's done, he can't even claim insane cop anymore.
This is a weird post
:henry: Grim got bussed with scum and all 3 of them are town, all part of Vic's mastermind plan
Nah, I'm literally just talking through all the options. Most likely option is one or two of Tim/Ahoda/Grim are scum, with the safest guess being Tim. if he doesn't flip scum or insane cop then it's Grim.
i still believe Tim
but i also think ahoda is town and insane cop
their actions don't make sense to me otherwise. Maf may be desperate but i don't see what they'd gain from trying just to get Grim lynched?
