I guess Rose will be busy today plumbing the house. That post was probably a reference to the state of her scum board. :P

Christian @ 11/9/2016 12:49

Now that dr has explained herself, I actually think she could be telling the truth about her role. If she is lying, the real doctor can counter her claim in some shape or form. If she is the real doctor, she's gonna be able to prove it during the night phases based on who she protects.

It was pretty clear what she was even before she hardcalimed. If scum weren't boneheads, then they knew as well.

Dadd @ 11/9/2016 12:51

Grimapple @ 11/9/2016 11:07 Chris25 @ 11/9/2016 11:00 Grimapple @ 11/9/2016 11:57 Thanks for proving you are the dumb side and not just scum. But scum should know what her role is and are banking on not having to kill Rose tonight by getting her lynched. I'm guessing at least one scum on her lynch train currently; likely a couple. It's hard to tell if you are actually playing or not. Either way, you bore me. I'm actually paying attention, which is more than I can say for you. If you weren't such an ass, I'd swear you are scum pretending to be dense. Or maybe you just don't know the first thing about girls and can't read them like I do. You're paying attention? Three attacks, two dead town, one survives. I vote for the one that survives because.....obvious....and you vote..... me?! Yes, you're definitely paying attention.

Yes- she made it pretty clear what she was claiming. Scum would have just said they were town bulletproof. Rose specifically indicated she wasn't. It was N1, when doctor is unlikely to have enough to go on to protect anyone else, so does it take a brick or a brick house?

Grimapple @ 11/9/2016 14:17

Christian @ 11/9/2016 12:49 Now that dr has explained herself, I actually think she could be telling the truth about her role. If she is lying, the real doctor can counter her claim in some shape or form. If she is the real doctor, she's gonna be able to prove it during the night phases based on who she protects. It was pretty clear what she was even before she hardcalimed. If scum weren't boneheads, then they knew as well.

Care to explain?

And if someone claims you're just going to believe them and lynch the first person on their train?

Cool Girl @ 11/9/2016 13:11

Grimapple @ 11/9/2016 11:05 Dadd @ 10/9/2016 22:09 Two town die and Dr survives an attack.... ##lynch dr This was the first person to push a dr lynch to try to get a train going, so my gut is saying he is scum. Have to look at Wikey interactions from D1 or lack of them to shore up this feeling, but I feel pretty good on this one. More so when dr as much as softclaimed. Wow you're full of shit, you're starting a new train yourself now so does your gut say you're scum too?

My gut says you are a little bitch.

Cool Girl @ 11/9/2016 14:20

Grimapple @ 11/9/2016 14:17 Christian @ 11/9/2016 12:49 Now that dr has explained herself, I actually think she could be telling the truth about her role. If she is lying, the real doctor can counter her claim in some shape or form. If she is the real doctor, she's gonna be able to prove it during the night phases based on who she protects. It was pretty clear what she was even before she hardcalimed. If scum weren't boneheads, then they knew as well. Care to explain? And if someone claims you're just going to believe them and lynch the first person on their train?

And one someone says they are the town doc you jump to lynch them?

And it was pretty obvious- who does the doc protect night one? They protect themselves. What role would survive an attack night one, be not bullet proof nor wanting to claim bulletproof, but also not want to point out their actual role.

Again- brick or brick house?

I think the counter argument is that the "Doctor" claim is a clever fake claim. :P

Again, you're full of shit. Who are you even?

She doesn't really try to argue herself out of her own lynch trying to figure things out so it seems like she could be guilty, just using a fake claim a clever way.

One thing to note. If dr flips scum, we look at Dadd. Jumped on dr right away but then backed off when it did not seem like a sure deal that she would be lynched.

If dr is town. Which I am leaning towards right now. Christian is definitely someone that needs to be looked at. From wanting to out a doctor, to scoffing at dr's claim but still not voting. So in a few days when I look back at this day I won't out him as one of the votes on the lynched doctor.

I explained why I voted for Boc over Wikey, and I explained why I survived the attack last night, and I held off on claiming for as long as I can because I didn't want to out my role.

What else do I need to explain?

Also, doctor is not a clever fake claim.

##lynch Angi

I agree with Boc. She was the most suspicious to me from her behavior yesterday.

yeah guys, not really understanding why the dr votes after the claim. she could be lying scum but she be town doc and why are we not giving her the benefit of the doubt until we have more to go on other than the fact she survived?

##unlynch Buffy
##lynch Angi

i see them both as potential scum but we'd probably learn more from an Angi lynch so it probably makes more sense.

itsbrianyay @ 11/9/2016 14:55

yeah guys, not really understanding why the dr votes after the claim. she could be lying scum but she be town doc and why are we not giving her the benefit of the doubt until we have more to go on other than the fact she survived? ##unlynch Buffy ##lynch Angi i see them both as potential scum but we'd probably learn more from an Angi lynch so it probably makes more sense.

oh men this

Anyone who voted Rose after she claimed needs serious looking at. One of two reasons:
1) She's actually Doc, and they're trying to use "doubt" as a reason to get rid of the Doc
2) She's actually Scum, and they're trying to look good on a Scum lynch

Either way, they're probably up to no good! (: