Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2 3 4 ... 9
The Fifth Day; "The price of crossing my door is blood, Captain"
 
Bruckheimer
User Avatar
Hatchet
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Novice
Posts:101
Joined:Oct 16, 2020
Post #1: 26th Oct 2020 7:39 PM 
The death of Angelica was the last straw. There was no one left to lead the pirates after both their Captain and Jr Captain had succumbed to the sea. The pirates had a sense of dread approaching them. They weren't certain they would make it through the night. As they held on, not so much for dear life but for a quick and painless death, the eerie whistle of the armada blew. And it was is if death itself was blowing her horn.

im317 has been killed.

You are Mr Cotton

Posted Image

Role: Parrot
Description: You pick one person to visit every night. You will receive the same night results PM as your target.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Hidden from player - If Cotton visits Jack, he gets detailed info about the next day game mechanic

The sigh of Cotton's death was too much for the survivor to bear. One after the other they walked the plank and welcomed their demise with open arms.

Cody is dead.

You are Pintell

Posted Image

Role: Mason
Description: You shares a personal forum with Ragetti.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Hidden from player: If Ragetti dies, Pintell becomes 1-shot PGO.

Vern is dead.

You are Ragetti

Posted Image

Role: Mason
Description: You shares a personal forum with Pintell.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Hidden from player: If Pintell dies, Ragetti becomes 1-shot PGO.

garlic is dead.

You are Scrum

Posted Image

Role: Bodyguard
Description: You can visit one person every night. If the target is attacked, you will die instead.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Hidden from player: If Scrum picks Angelica, they're both BP for the night

TiB is dead.

You are Dog with keys

Posted Image

Role: Gatekeeper
Description: You search each night to find the prisoner and set them free
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Hidden from player: There is no prisoner. The visit does nothing. Additionally, since the dog isn't an actual pirate it will appear guilty on investigations

The armada of the East India Trading Co had proven to be too overwhelming for the pirates to overcome. Without Jack, without the Black pearl and without being able to unify, they had been washed away by the might of Lord Cutler Beckett. he EITC showed mercy to the surviving Soldier and brought them back into the fold.

The East India Trading Co. have achieved their win condition. Mafia has won the game.

Lord Culter Beckett played by spin

Posted Image

Role: Don
Description: You will survive first kill attempt on self, either nightkill or lynch. You have final say on night actions. You will appear as a Pirate when investigated.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the EITC have been eliminated and/or you make up 50% of the total remaining players

Ian Mercer played by Perry

Posted Image

Role: Assassin
Description: Thrice per game, you can perform either an undetectable (ninja) or an unstoppable (strongman) factional kill. Three total. You can pick any combo of kill types.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the EITC have been eliminated and/or you make up 50% of the total remaining players

James Norrington played by gmaj

Posted Image

Role: Loyalist
Description: You can pick a person every night to protect. The person protected will also gain an extra anonymous vote to be used during the next day. You can protect the same person back to back.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the EITC have been eliminated and/or you make up 50% of the total remaining players

John Scarfield played by Moose

Posted Image

Role: Informed
Description: You have no active actions. Every night you will receive a PM explaining the game mechanics of the next day.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the EITC have been eliminated and/or you make up 50% of the total remaining players

Sao Feng played by Penner

Posted Image

Role: Traitor Goon
Description: You picks one person each night. If the target is part of the East India trading company, you will join them. You have no active night abilities
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated You win when all threats to the EITC have been eliminated and/or you make up 50% of the total remaining players
Hidden from player: If Sao Feng is attacked by the East India trading company at night, Sao Feng won't die but will join them.

Jen and Christian have achieved their secondary win condition.

You are Mulroy

Posted Image

Role: Soldier
Description: You are unaligned and will join the faction of whoever visits him first.
Wincon: You win if you're alive at the end of the game
Role: Soldier
Description: You are aligned with the Pirates. You share a forum with Murtogg. You have a kill and a doc save between the two of you.
Wincon: You win when all threats to the Pirates have been eliminated
Secondary wincon: You win if you and/or Mulroy are alive at the end of the game.


Official winners:
spin
Moose
Perry
gmaj
Penner
Jen
Christian
Cultis
Kyle
Mal
 
   
Thisisbourbon
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,853
Joined:Sep 7, 2016
Post #2: 26th Oct 2020 7:40 PM 
Good job mafia!
 
   
Cody
User Avatar
Pollux
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 112
Group:Legend
Posts:5,882
Joined:Dec 4, 2018
Post #3: 26th Oct 2020 7:42 PM 
FAKEIG WAS TOWN? LMAOOOOO I’m cackling.

Gg Penner. That was top notch. What happened with Christian then?
 
   
Thisisbourbon
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,853
Joined:Sep 7, 2016
Post #4: 26th Oct 2020 7:43 PM 
But was I?

My wincon changed to fucking with Vern. Nav just forgot to change it.
 
   
Cody
User Avatar
Pollux
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 112
Group:Legend
Posts:5,882
Joined:Dec 4, 2018
Post #5: 26th Oct 2020 7:44 PM 
Did town have any protective roles lol
 
   
Cody
User Avatar
Pollux
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 112
Group:Legend
Posts:5,882
Joined:Dec 4, 2018
Post #6: 26th Oct 2020 7:44 PM 
I was so sure you were Mafia bc if how awful you were. But all good. Thanks for the game Nav
 
   
Thisisbourbon
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,853
Joined:Sep 7, 2016
Post #7: 26th Oct 2020 7:44 PM 
You are looking at him.
 
   
Bruckheimer
User Avatar
Hatchet
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Novice
Posts:101
Joined:Oct 16, 2020
Post #8: 26th Oct 2020 7:45 PM 
Forum links:

Masons: https://femasonpirates.freeforums.net/
Mafia: https://feeastindiapirates.freeforums.net/
Soldiers: https://fepiratesoldiers.freeforums.net/
Cult: https://fedreadpirates.freeforums.net/

Game commentary: https://feeastindiapirates.freeforums.net/thread/3/game-commentary?page=1

let me know if anything is not visible

im not gonna do an HoL/HoF because the game was way too chaotic but I'll have some noted about game mechanics in a separate post
 
   
Thisisbourbon
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 100
Group:Overlord
Posts:13,853
Joined:Sep 7, 2016
Post #9: 26th Oct 2020 7:45 PM 
I was awful? Really?
 
   
Kyle
User Avatar
gahd damn town cop
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 34
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,470
Joined:Aug 10, 2020
Post #10: 26th Oct 2020 7:45 PM 
Oh my god lol what a steamroll
 
   
Bruckheimer
User Avatar
Hatchet
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Novice
Posts:101
Joined:Oct 16, 2020
Post #11: 26th Oct 2020 7:45 PM 
Cody @ 26/10/2020 16:44
Did town have any protective roles lol


Mal was town's major protective role. garlic was semi protective
 
   
Kyle
User Avatar
gahd damn town cop
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 34
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,470
Joined:Aug 10, 2020
Post #12: 26th Oct 2020 7:53 PM 
Bruckheimer @ 26/10/2020 20:45
Cody @ 26/10/2020 16:44
Did town have any protective roles lol


Mal was town's major protective role. garlic was semi protective


I needed him more. Not sorry about it. 🙂
 
   
Moose
User Avatar
HYHOTCAMMORPGFFXIV? WAEFTWYCPTTEOARRATAWHEUTL60FFWNROP
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 99
Group:Elite
Posts:4,871
Joined:Aug 7, 2014
Post #13: 26th Oct 2020 7:53 PM 
WOW. Good job team! Idk how I survived but I think this marks my first win where I actually lived to see it.
Posted Image
   
Bruckheimer
User Avatar
Hatchet
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 6
Group:Novice
Posts:101
Joined:Oct 16, 2020
Post #14: 26th Oct 2020 7:54 PM 
These were the mechanics I had planned

Posted Image

I tend to skew too much in favor of Mafia when I'm hosting because of how easy it seems for town to just claim and win on FE in general. But in this case the mechanics favored mafia entirely way too much so town really had little to no shot overall. I'd say overall the only "bad" decision was made by the Soldiers (Jen/Christian) to kill Josh instead of spin but being that they didn't exactly need to win with Town it's not a huge mark against them.

Some controversial decisions I made during the course of the game:

Night 2 - Penner was recruited by Mittens on the same night when Penner was joining the Mafia team by visiting spin. Since recruitment went first I allowed Mittens' action to go through. The safe and more likely "correct" thing to do would have been to end it there and nulling Penner's addition to Mafia but since it happened in the same night I decided to let Penner join both forums - Cult and Mafia because it suited the lore really well that Sao Feng would have conflicting allegiances and would look out for himself. I don't regret this choice a whole lot because it was such a huge coincidence that both things happened in the same night.

Including Mittens on the Calypso rng list - Even though Mittens wasn't town he was still a "Pirate" and thats why he was eligible to be killed by Calypso. I really hated writing Mittens' death because of how much I was looking forward to see Cult v/s Mafia play out with Penner acting as a go-between.

Overall this was really not a good setup balance wise and town just had no shot whatsoever which is not in the spirit of the game so I won't likely host for a while. I did personally enjoy watching the chaos unfold but from a player's perspective it just could not have been fun. Oh well. Thank you everyone who made the mistake of signing up and being my guinea pigs.
 
   
Thisisbad
User Avatar
If you need positivity, look elsewhere.
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 212
Group:Overlord
Posts:14,891
Joined:Feb 5, 2016
Post #15: 26th Oct 2020 7:55 PM 
Thanks for the game Nav.

Great jobmafia.

I apologize town. I was awful. Work got me swamped and i could never catch back up. I'm sorry.
Rodney is a great guy. Oops, nevermind he's a terrible human being.
He likes his sandwiches to be Turkey and Swiss. Triangle cut. Let vern have his crust. Poison the part Rodney eats.

TIB - 2 time award winner "Worst mafia player" at FE (maybe everywhere)

2020 winner of World’s Best Brother Award


https://imgur.com/7PZxVxA.jpg

Curtis said he wishes I never joined FE.

2020 winner funniest FE member.

https://youtu.be/7wlcNEh_OdQ
   
1 Users Viewing (1 Guests)
  122. Pirates Mafia  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service