Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
GOT: 1-16; Robert vs. Mance
 Poll Question: Which character is better?
Robert Baratheon Posted Image
 
9 Votes
(69%)
Mance Rayder Posted Image
 
4 Votes
(31%)
 
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,204
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #1: 16th Apr 2013 5:22 PM 
"I'm not trying to honor you, I'm trying to get you to run my kingdom while I eat, drink, and whore my way into an early grave."
--
Robert Baratheon is the ruler of the Seven Kingdoms. He took the throne by conquest in the war known as Robert's Rebellion. He is a childhood friend of Eddard Stark and considers him his true brother. He names Ned as Hand of the King when the previous Hand dies in mysterious circumstances.

vs.

"I'm going to light the biggest fire the North has ever seen!"
--
Mance Rayder was once a noted ranger of the Night's Watch. He deserted his post and fled north of the Wall to join the wildlings. He rose to become the King-Beyond-the-Wall, a title bestowed on a wildling leader who manages to unify all of the tribes under his command. It appears he has held the position of King-Beyond-The-Wall for more than a decade, as Ser Alliser Thorne mentions he was King-Beyond-the-Wall during the previous winter.
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
Curtis
User Avatar
First Place Dick
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,170
Group:Admin
Posts:79,236
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #2: 16th Apr 2013 6:24 PM 
I really liked Robert's character and I like the actor in that role a lot. Mance seems cool but he's only had a few lines really. Robert for sure
Posted Image
   
PORL
User Avatar
UNFORGIVABLE
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 153
Group:Admin
Posts:4,222
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #3: 16th Apr 2013 6:45 PM 
Voted Mance. Robert in the show was an infuriating dick. I mean...that was the point. But I found him hard to stomach at times. Mance Rayder is a dick too but at least he's a dick with some kind of an agenda. Robert was an interesting character for sure but the cult of personality surrounding Mance is great.
 
   
Curtis
User Avatar
First Place Dick
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 1,170
Group:Admin
Posts:79,236
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #4: 16th Apr 2013 6:57 PM 
Robert and Ned's scenes and Robert/Cersei scenes were some of my favorites of the first season
Posted Image
   
Kiwi
User Avatar
Detective Bollig
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 38
Group:Veteran
Posts:1,876
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #5: 16th Apr 2013 7:01 PM 
Robert but mainly because of his pre-GOT stories... Seemed like such a boss with his warhammer.
 
   
Boc
User Avatar
Posted Image
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 157
Group:Admin
Posts:19,204
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #6: 16th Apr 2013 7:39 PM 
lol Robert didn't come off as a dick to me. He was one of the few people who didn't completely dick Ned over in King's Landing so he's alright in my book!
Posted Image
Posted Image
   
PORL
User Avatar
UNFORGIVABLE
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 153
Group:Admin
Posts:4,222
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #7: 16th Apr 2013 7:43 PM 
I think it was the actor tbh.
 
   
Nobert
User Avatar
Cerberus
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 102
Group:Elite
Posts:4,552
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #8: 16th Apr 2013 9:16 PM 
Robert! Would love to see the rebellion on TV if it were possible
 
   
Patrick
User Avatar
Sole Survivor
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 63
Group:Legend
Posts:7,435
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #9: 17th Apr 2013 1:15 AM 
Robert
 
   
Dyl
User Avatar
Butt Not Even Visible
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 80
Group:Moderator
Posts:13,554
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #10: 17th Apr 2013 1:50 AM 
Mance is going to light the biggest fire the North has ever seen. Give him some props.
"So, uh, what are we saying here? If we save LA from a nuclear bomb, then you and I can get together for dinner and a movie?"
   
Zersch
User Avatar
birdhouse love
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 527
Group:Overlord
Posts:15,899
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #11: 17th Apr 2013 8:09 AM 
Robert, based on what many others have already said. Smashed the pretty boy on the Trident.

I really do like Mance, though. Just... it's probably my own fault, but the actor looks so different from how I perceived him in the book that its jarring. Maybe he was described this way and I just don't remember, but I envisioned someone a bit more young and suave. I guess this version makes more sense to have the wildlings rallied behind him.
Spoiler+
   
Ari
User Avatar
Snowman Overlord
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 32
Group:Elite
Posts:3,189
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #12: 17th Apr 2013 11:15 AM 
Robert

Mance Rayder is a pretty cool name though
 
   
PORL
User Avatar
UNFORGIVABLE
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 153
Group:Admin
Posts:4,222
Joined:Jun 22, 2012
Post #13: 17th Apr 2013 5:13 PM 
Apparently Dominic West was approached about the role of Mance but he turned it down because Iceland sucks and he refused to go there. That would've been incredible beyond words.
 
   
Ari
User Avatar
Snowman Overlord
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 32
Group:Elite
Posts:3,189
Joined:Jun 26, 2012
Post #14: 18th Apr 2013 8:51 AM 
boo!
 
   
1 Users Viewing (1 Guests)
  6. GoT character tourney  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service