|
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #1: 2nd Jan 2018 4:44 PM | |
HEY LETS DO THIS
I wanna make a full ranking of all 19 episodes, but I'm definitely gonna have to rewatch early ones since its been quite awhile. An ongoing list makes it much easier though, I'm gonna start with s4 and slot things in as I rewatch them
| |
| | |
Igor
Minotaur
| Reputation: 147 | Group: | Deceased | Posts: | 6,270 | Joined: | Aug 8, 2014 |
| Post #2: 2nd Jan 2018 4:46 PM | |
1 > 2 > 3 | Winner of 11 Courses of Thanksgiving
|
| | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #3: 2nd Jan 2018 4:46 PM | |
I had the FE Watches movie 1-10 rating scale in the OP at first but I don't really feel like rating each episode, I'd rather just rank instead of rank + rate
So far through S4
1. USS Callister
2. Hang the DJ
3. Crocodile
4. Metalhead
5. Arkangel | |
| | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #4: 2nd Jan 2018 4:53 PM | |
1. San Junipero
2. USS Callister
3. Shut Up and Dance
4. Hang the DJ
5. Nosedive
6. Crocodile
7. Playtest
8. Metalhead
9. Arkangel
10. Hated by the Nation
11. Men Against Fire
I thiiiink these are my S3/S4 rankings. I feel good about the top five being above the rest
I'm not gonna slot in S1 and S2 until I rewatch those | |
| | |
Igor
Minotaur
| Reputation: 147 | Group: | Deceased | Posts: | 6,270 | Joined: | Aug 8, 2014 |
| Post #5: 2nd Jan 2018 4:59 PM | |
Season 1:
Fifteen Million Merits > The National Anthem > Entire History of You
|
All these are rather strong. Fifteen Million Merits may be one of my favorites of the series, it's so well done cinematicaly, with the world they built, and the story. The later two are pretty much on the same level, I could see them being equal and changing them.
|
Season 2:
White Christmas > White Bear > Waldo > BRB
|
Assuming WC is S2 its at the top. Insane concept that makes the best use out of the cookie in the series. White Bear's concept is insanely well done. The twist is beautifully well executed and unexpected. Lots of action keeps it pretty interesting even when you think it will be lackluster. Waldo is a hidden gem of the series and criminally underrated. I think it foreshadows Trump/Russia's meddling in elections beautifully. Very strong message. BRB was incredibly boring. The concept is kinda interesting but it's just not super compelling to me. |
Season 3:
Shut Up and Dance > Playtest > Nosedive > Hated in the Nation > Men Against Fire > San Junipero
|
Shut Up easily by far and away the best in the season. Such a dark and well executed concept that you can totally see being believable and even happening in present day. It continues to be intense and the ending is heart wrenching. Playtest is ok, the concept is well executed and pretty interesting. Nosedive I put higher than I thought, I think the concept was really well executed but the last quarter of the episode was kinda bad. Hated in the Nation and Men Against Fire are really similar to me. Hated edges it out as being slightly more interesting/more of an innovative concept. Mean Against Fire it was really easy to figure out the twist, even when I was hammered. And it ended up being a pretty boring episode. San Junipero is what I hated the most, just a shitty love story. I could see it being better than Hated/Fire, they are all pretty mediocre. |
| Winner of 11 Courses of Thanksgiving
|
| | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #6: 2nd Jan 2018 5:01 PM | |
"Hated in the Nation > Men Against Fire > San Junipero"
:ds: :mal: :paul: :henry: | |
| | |
Igor
Minotaur
| Reputation: 147 | Group: | Deceased | Posts: | 6,270 | Joined: | Aug 8, 2014 |
| Post #7: 2nd Jan 2018 5:03 PM | |
|
"Hated in the Nation > Men Against Fire > San Junipero"
:ds: :mal: :paul: :henry: |
Read what I wrote, they are all equally bad and I can see Junipero being better than the last 2 | Winner of 11 Courses of Thanksgiving
|
| | |
Josh Frost
my pronouns are they/them
| Reputation: 58 | Group: | Overlord | Posts: | 12,257 | Joined: | Dec 8, 2016 |
| Post #8: 2nd Jan 2018 5:04 PM | |
I'll do this when I get back home. I'm gonna rewatch a lot of them and then figure it out from there, I think. | |
| | |
Josh Frost
my pronouns are they/them
| Reputation: 58 | Group: | Overlord | Posts: | 12,257 | Joined: | Dec 8, 2016 |
| Post #9: 2nd Jan 2018 5:07 PM | |
igor who hurt u | |
| | |
jamie
together we can defeat obese children
| Reputation: 115 | Group: | Overlord | Posts: | 11,794 | Joined: | Jan 11, 2015 |
| Post #10: 2nd Jan 2018 6:00 PM | |
hey did u edit out the number thing i was gonna use that | |
I was wrong about Jamie he is a true visionary and I name him my successor |
|
| | |
Nofo
The Butcher
| Reputation: 2 | Group: | Legend | Posts: | 8,246 | Joined: | Jul 20, 2013 |
| Post #11: 2nd Jan 2018 6:14 PM | |
Igor, are you an incel? Is that why you're such a miserable bastard? | nav is ugly and i am pretty |
| | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #12: 2nd Jan 2018 7:47 PM | |
|
hey did u edit out the number thing i was gonna use that |
|
I had the FE Watches movie 1-10 rating scale in the OP at first but I don't really feel like rating each episode, I'd rather just rank instead of rank + rate |
ya | |
| | |
Curtis
First Place Dick
| Reputation: 1,170 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 79,236 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #13: 2nd Jan 2018 7:47 PM | |
But it's the FE Watches chart if you wanna use it
| |
| | |
jamie
together we can defeat obese children
| Reputation: 115 | Group: | Overlord | Posts: | 11,794 | Joined: | Jan 11, 2015 |
| Post #14: 2nd Jan 2018 8:16 PM | |
thnx | |
I was wrong about Jamie he is a true visionary and I name him my successor |
|
| | |
Boc
| Reputation: 157 | Group: | Admin | Posts: | 19,205 | Joined: | Jun 22, 2012 |
| Post #15: 3rd Jan 2018 10:13 AM | |
season 4
1. USS Callister
2. Crocodile
3. Metalhead
4. Hang the DJ
5. Black Museum
6. Arkangel
overall
1. San Junipero
2. Fifteen Million Merits
3. White Bear
4. USS Callister
5. Nosedive
6. Shut Up and Dance
7. Crocodile
--gap--
8. Metalhead
9. White Christmas
10. Be Right Back
11. Hang the DJ
12. National Anthem
13. Entire History of You
14. Hated in the Nation
15. Playtest
16. Black Museum
17. Arkangel
18. The Waldo Moment
19. Men Against Fire | |
| | |
1 Users Viewing (1 Guests) |
|
|