Tricks @ 14/4/2014 23:45

Greenday, whenever you see this, does your role seem like the vampire/mentor is the 'cult' it applies to?

My role mentions "insane" people so I do not believe this was the true cult.

Curtis @ 15/4/2014 0:14

Shadow @ 15/4/2014 0:13 Also wasn't everyone speculating Greenday was going to be attacked by cult? Seemed likely since he poses a threat to them, but if Vic is the Cult that Greenday's role is associated with, then Vic couldn't kill last night because he didn't have a follower

Based on what I just said, since I don't think this was the real cult, I don't think the real cult can actually kill. If this was the real cult I absolutely would be dead as of last night.

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 6:46

Greendayger @ 15/4/2014 6:09 Tricks @ 14/4/2014 23:45 Greenday, whenever you see this, does your role seem like the vampire/mentor is the 'cult' it applies to? My role mentions "insane" people so I do not believe this was the true cult. I thought you specifically said cult before? Wouldn't insane be like paranoid or something?

I asked for clarification on whether that meant any non-townies including mafia and cult and he specified that it was cult

Ari @ 15/4/2014 14:39

Town: Ari - obviously ;) Likely town: DR Perry Meh: Curtis - was lynched by HC. Vernon - strikes me as town. Patrick - strikes me as town. Greenday - not sure about his claim but ill put him here. Ahoda - strikes me as town. Not sure: Boc Shawn Buffy Possible lynches: Angi - lynched Greenday. lynched Curtis. lynched Malion. Bandwagony votes. Cash Money - lynched Herm because the Mal train gained a lot of steam quickly. Hasnt said much else. g0 - dont think he/she has said anything of note regarding his/her suspicions. Herm - Been the target of a lot of suspicion. Malion was lynched in his stead. Mafia ploooy? A lot of people seem to suspect him though. That rarely happens to mafia. itsbrianyay - Said Herm was scummy. Didnt lynch. Dont think he has said anything about other suspicions. Shadow - scummy post I mentioned earlier. Has accused me and Herm. Then lynched Mal. Tricks - lynched Herm. Said Curtis and Boc where scummy. Wikey - Said Curtis was scummy. Pointed at Boc, Greenday, Vernon, Vic. Lynched Greenday. Hasnt said much else. Not sure if Herm is the best target. He seems to have so many people against him, that doesnt happen to mafia a lot. Some of the people here above have talked a lot but said very little....

How are drr and Perry "likely town" when their claims haven't exactly cleared them any more than mine have?

Ari @ 15/4/2014 15:20

Greendayger @ 15/4/2014 20:16 Ari @ 15/4/2014 14:39 Town: Ari - obviously ;) Likely town: DR Perry Meh: Curtis - was lynched by HC. Vernon - strikes me as town. Patrick - strikes me as town. Greenday - not sure about his claim but ill put him here. Ahoda - strikes me as town. Not sure: Boc Shawn Buffy Possible lynches: Angi - lynched Greenday. lynched Curtis. lynched Malion. Bandwagony votes. Cash Money - lynched Herm because the Mal train gained a lot of steam quickly. Hasnt said much else. g0 - dont think he/she has said anything of note regarding his/her suspicions. Herm - Been the target of a lot of suspicion. Malion was lynched in his stead. Mafia ploooy? A lot of people seem to suspect him though. That rarely happens to mafia. itsbrianyay - Said Herm was scummy. Didnt lynch. Dont think he has said anything about other suspicions. Shadow - scummy post I mentioned earlier. Has accused me and Herm. Then lynched Mal. Tricks - lynched Herm. Said Curtis and Boc where scummy. Wikey - Said Curtis was scummy. Pointed at Boc, Greenday, Vernon, Vic. Lynched Greenday. Hasnt said much else. Not sure if Herm is the best target. He seems to have so many people against him, that doesnt happen to mafia a lot. Some of the people here above have talked a lot but said very little.... How are drr and Perry "likely town" when their claims haven't exactly cleared them any more than mine have? Would be a HUUUGE gamble if they where mafia to both claim something like that. If either flips mafia the other one will likely be lynched. Your claim however seems a bit out there. Not saying you are lying but as I see it you cant really prove it can you? (unlike DR surviving 2 attacks!)

Yeah it's really tricky for me because my role is really useful for the town but the drawback is I'm not actually told whether my role was successful or not. So I can't exactly give you guys the leads we need.

Shawn @ 15/4/2014 16:32

I don't know why but something still doesn't sit right with me about Greenday. Day 1 he lynched Boc and it was mainly ust because Boc was against Greenday, it was very defensive. Then he lynched Drr who is looking pretty town at the moment if Perry isn't lying but I doubt they would make that big of a risk this early in the game and lie about that so she seems town for now. Then he just randomly joins the easy Jordan train and says "Sounds like a plan I guess"

alol in no way shape or form is drr cleared. FoS on this post because it almost seems like trying to hard to start this revisionist history for scum reasons. I'm still not sold on drr at ALL.

Fuck Doc Rivers.

Re: Herm, what if this is a role where one is town and one is mafia, and there is SOME sort of decision which one comes up with the slayer role. Herm seemed oddly specific about it being "word-for-word" what Tim had

HIGHLY doubtful. I don't think I've ever played a mafia game where a non-vanilla role was IDENTICAL to another role.

Tricks @ 15/4/2014 21:28

Cash Money @ 15/4/2014 20:25 The thing is, both backups can't take over simultaneously. That would either have to be covered explicitly or through invisible text, and I find invisible text unlikely since it would directly contradict the visible text. Yeah, that's what's really perplexing me. The only other possibility I can think of is that the slayers would be of different alignments? I don't know. At this point, I'd rather lynch Vernon and think about Herm again tomorrow. Not ruling out that Herm could be third party.

That was what I had said initially in terms of different alignments.

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 22:18

Shadow @ 15/4/2014 22:16 You say that as your vote is on Brian tho^ with ari I like my vote on Brian. I think I'm right.

You keep doing this calling out people or defending others thing while keeping votes on others or the person you're defending.

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 22:25

Greendayger @ 15/4/2014 22:23 Buffy @ 15/4/2014 22:18 Shadow @ 15/4/2014 22:16 You say that as your vote is on Brian tho^ with ari I like my vote on Brian. I think I'm right. You keep doing this calling out people or defending others thing while keeping votes on others or the person you're defending. I do what? Sorry, where's your vote?

Nowhere because I can't decide who I think is more scummy and would rather not WASTE my vote JUST to vote, tysfm

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 22:49

I don't think voting who I think is scum is wasting my vote. I'm not jumping on a train just because everyone else is.

But what you've been saying seems to have contradicted your lynch votes on multiple occasions