I was thinking that on day 2 Henry was being way more of a distraction than a help, regardless of whether he was town or scum. I don't think we would be at a big loss without him

lol Dyl two scum have already died so there's probably only like two, three or maybe four left in the game. You don't think we can afford to lose someone who's more of a detriment to our progress than a help?

So I just looked at the player list there's less people left than I thought so yeah, now I'm not too keen on lynching him just on the basis of being a dolt.

Bryce @ 22/7/2013 18:38

Greenday @ 22/7/2013 9:09 So I just looked at the player list there's less people left than I thought so yeah, now I'm not too keen on lynching him just on the basis of being a dolt. Oh yeah? And Merc, you can jail 2 people??

Well yeah, I mean because there was no true day 3 my mind was telling me there were 15 people left and that there would be more time to try and kill mafia later and take a risk with Henry today. But then I saw that there are only 12 left and if there are in fact 4 mafiosi still out there, no way. Not enough time, game could be over within 2 days if mafia are still 4 strong and win out.

Bryce @ 22/7/2013 19:08

Were we told how many there were?

No, I did say if. I said in my first post that there could be two three or four left, and I said four in my last one because I was pointing out how quickly they COULD win in my worst case scenario.

Guys what if Henry is either Vengeful Townie or bomb and is trying to goad either us to lynch him or someone with a night kill to use it on him?

Dylan @ 22/7/2013 21:50

Greenday @ 22/7/2013 15:33 Guys what if Henry is either Vengeful Townie or bomb and is trying to goad either us to lynch him or someone with a night kill to use it on him? #scumtalkpart2 Henry is an idiot but if he was town he'd do the best for a town win. Why are you worried about Henry trying to kill people if he's town? He would be trying to kill scum. This is your second major slip up today. I still don't understand what Merc is meaning. I doubt the host would tell him that he was going to get blocked but then his jail went through. I guess the whole double jail thing could mean Patrick the first night (night 2) and Henry last night (night 3). Still not sure about what he was told. Merc called out Ari so for now I am pretty confident in his township for now.

I'm sorry, but is it not at all possible for him to kill scum as Vengeful Townie OR bomb? Vengeful Townie, he could use his kill on scum. Bomb, he could kill mafia if they try to attack him. It's not a very likely theory, but it is totally possible. Just because I brought up a theory that makes me scum? The two things I said today that you say are "scum talk" are slip-ups? Try harder.

Bryce @ 22/7/2013 23:26

Nobert @ 22/7/2013 14:39 Henry_42 @ 22/7/2013 16:28 oh look at me..I am using a button to show my emotions..and you can always tell whether I'M serious about it or not....no questio nabout it..clearly there to see.... LOL....stupid canadian faggot....gtfo...get a new internet provider and then come back and tell us more of your stories lol you mistook what I was saying. i should've been more clear. I was trying to say that you liking the deaths doesn't necessarily mean it's you being mafia, its you being "Henry". Which means I don't think that's good of a reason to lynch you! And where the heck did Rob go?? Called people out before and then just doesn't show up...interesting.

He died like night 2

Kiwi @ 23/7/2013 0:48

How does Greenday not have a single lynch on him?

I do not understand how my theories make me look scummy :| I've already explained how Vengeful Townie/bomb is plausible so I'm not going there again. But... suppose we DID have more people and could POTENTIALLY afford to cut Henry loose. Other than a number that has at least a few days and to be recovered along with roles to help that cause, what would we have lost? Is he contributing anything with his discussions or just causing a fuss? Regardless of it being Henry being Henry, I do not understand how that is hard to grasp. And I DID back off from that suggestion as soon as I realized that there were fewer people left than I initially thought.

Um, Dylan didn't point out to me that there were 12 people left. I posted back to back. Read the thread again, page 3.

The explanation is very simple and has been stated multiple times in here. I thought there were more people and more time to recover from POTENTIALLY getting rid of town (although it's still not out of the question to me that he could be scum), but when I realized that there were a full THREE less people still in than I thought and that therefore we had less time to try and recoup, that's when I reconsidered. Not that difficult.

Kiwi @ 23/7/2013 1:25

Greenday @ 23/7/2013 13:20 The explanation is very simple and has been stated multiple times in here. I thought there were more people and more time to recover from POTENTIALLY getting rid of town (although it's still not out of the question to me that he could be scum), but when I realized that there were a full THREE less people still in than I thought and that therefore we had less time to try and recoup, that's when I reconsidered. Not that difficult. I think lynching "annoying townies" is never a simple explanation. I do get what you are saying, I just think you are trying to cover you REAL intentions.

It's not so much ANNOYANCE as it is that I view him as a DISTRACTION. For a good part of today he wasn't contributing anything but interpersonal drama and even now what he's saying is very minimal and still relatively personal

I play mafia very sporadically and don't really pay attention to the ones I'm not in. I wouldn't really know how Henry usually plays.

And it all comes together like a jigsaw puzzle or a rubiks cube

##Lynch Henry