All-Stars has the better cast (duh), but Micro is easily the better season.

Micro
TOP
1. Cirie (Of course it wasn't a F3......)
2. James
3. Penner

BOTTOM
1. Mary (b/c who?)
2. Joel
3. Kathy/Chet (In a way I felt bad for them, but they also just weren't really good @ the game)

All-Stars
TOP
1. Rob M
2. Rob C
3. Colby

BOTTOM
1. Alicia
2. Shii Ann
3. Jenna L